My group *might* be redeeming her. Our GM has heavily modified the book, and we broke into the Queen's dungeons in order to rescue a PC's father (and gained another PC who was being broken into a Grey Maiden), so we met Cinnibar early. My witch successfully hit her with a slumber hex and she made an informative prisoner who was later taken to the temple of Pharasma and got the spells upon her removed. Whether or not she is being genuine is still unknown.
