Saturday night, the Wizard in our weekly gaming group reached second level. He looked over his school powers and had a question about this rule (Pathfinder Beta, p. 195):
Quote:
Whenever a wizard attains the listed level, he can choose one spell from his school to prepare every day as a bonus spell.
I interpreted this to mean that, out of your Spells Known from your chosen school, you may choose one to prepare as a bonus spell. If you don't know a spell, you can't choose it as a bonus spell, even if it is from your chosen school.
The player however took a literal reading: the rule says you may choose one spell from your school. He interpreted this to mean that you can choose a spell you already know or a spell you have never learned; whether you know it or not as a normal spell is irrelevant, because you spontaenously gain it as a bonus spell.
Can anyone comment on which interpretation is the intent of the rule? or at least which version you use at your table?
Thanks,
Another_Poet