No, this isn't about the Goblin babies. :)
I just started a RotRL campaign, we've been through 3 sessions and it seems that the party is coming together quite nicely. However, I had a moral "Paladin" question and wanted to turn to the braintrust on these boards for advice.
Small disclaimer here: I know that asking "Should a Paladin have done this?" is akin to dumping kerosene on a bonfire. I'm not asking whether or not the Paladin "should" have done this, but where I go forward from here.
-
The party had returned from the upper level of the Glassworks, killing all the goblins with a stabilized Tsuto (at -2). They tossed him in the jail. Since Sheriff Hemlock had already left for Magnimar to get reinforcements, there was only one guard to watch him. They went back underneath the Glassworks to the Catacombs of Wrath and killed the Sinspawn, the Quasit, and deactivated the Runewell. Once they returned to heal and question Tsuto, it quickly became clear he was not going to cooperate. They soon came to the conclusion that he was too dangerous to leave alone in the jail with the 1st level Warrior while they went to Thistletop to confront Nualia. The paladin moved into the cell, and attacked Tsuto, reasoning that if they left him alone, he could escape and threaten the town.
Since Tsuto was at 5 hp, the "fight" didn't last long. Paladin won initiative, and 1 rd later Tsuto was dead. He took responsibility for it, making sure the body would be cremated and buried in the local cemetary, and the PCs have moved on Thistletop. They are currently in the nettles, as we had to close that session just after the fight with Gogmurt the druid.
I've been playing since 2nd edition, no question in my mind that Paladin acted inappropriately. My question, how do I deal with it in game? I don't want to make him "fall" over one incident, but I need to make it clear that this sort of behavior is unacceptable behavior.
Any suggestions?