The question I have is about the wafers. The wafers are marked with individual sigils for those of us who sit at the table. The damage effect is described as " you feel like a part of yourself is missing, even after you heal the damage. If you make the knowledge religion check on the wafers after the party dispenses with the cultists you get "if you eat the wafers you think you will get back the missing part of you." So those of us who sat at the table and had the unique wafers ate the ones that were "ours" fed the others back to everyone who survived having holy watered them all based on the knowledge religion result which told us that would sever the link between the wafers and the people. So we've sanctified all the wafers, given them back to those still living (one per person based on a knowledge religion check which tells the party doing this will restore them to health), only ate our own wafers, and destroyed the others. Explain to me how this is an evil act which needs an atonement? The cost of the atonement is trivial, but based on the information available to the characters, unless you eat a wafer without having lost something to the ritual, how is this evil?
