| Special Minion |
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Forgive me if this is rantish. I do not like organized play. I also do not like high-pressure salesmen. Let me lay out my feelings so you have some idea of where I'm coming from:
Organized Play services "Tournament Style Play" mentality, and will eventually lead there regardless of intent. It is hyper-competitive and Legalistic. It must be so in order to maintain consistency across tables. To do so you need to write rules as statute, hamper GM judgment, and structure adventures within a fixed time frame, which ends up channeling down social and spatial interaction.
This leads to combat dominance, which leads to everyone wanting a piece of the limelight, which leads to more combat widgets, which then eats more time, which in turn leads to social & exploration elements further channeled due to greater time constraints upon modules, and hyper-competitiveness wanting the end goodies to complete their builds.
Ultimately the players are turned into a group of rules lawyers and turns GMs into nothing but a referee and scripted narrator who tragically lose sight of what's important about tabletop RPGs; it's not a competition, it's about telling a story (I don't care what Society says about its self, when you get to my age you can spot bullcrap a mile away).
With that in mind, imagine how I felt when the owner of a local game shop contacted me and asked me to cancel my private home game on Saturday so the Paizo rep could have players to run organized play while he (the owner) charges the players $4 each to play. Naturally, I brought the idea to my players and told them they are free to do as they please with no hard feelings. Thankfully, I have loyal players (a couple of whom were equally if not more offended) and my Saturday game lives on.
Now I am left with questions; Is this the kind of behavior Paizo expects from it's Representatives? Do they ask their retailers to do the same? How could they honestly expect a group of casual players cancel what they do in their private lives to accommodate the desires of the business?
The whole experience really makes me want to dump Pathfinder as our go-to game as soon as Pathfinder 2 starts up and just play 5th Edition (I realize WotC has organized play, too but I'm yet to be asked to cancel my private game because they need players to show up).