| Speakachu |
So, I have a situation I'm not sure about, but I'd like to know how this works:
A kineticist with Kinetic Whip attacks a swashbuckler from 10 feet away. It's an energy element, let's say fire. The swashbuckler wishes to parry the attack, and has a melee reach of 10 ft. Is he able to?
1. OP&R doesn't say it won't work against touch attacks, and other topics I've found indicate that it does work against them.
2. The attack is still a melee attack, not a ranged attack, and thus qualifies for the ability.
3. OP&R does not say that the swashbuckler must be within melee range of the attacker to use this ability.
By RAW, the answer to this question is obviously yes. There's no stated reason why he's not able to, so it just works. Now, this makes no logical sense. In the "OP&R vs. touch attacks" threads I've found, the argument is made that you can deflect the attack by hitting the arm or whatever. In this case, though, from start to finish the swashbuckler has nothing in range that his weapon can interact with. It cannot interact with the whip itself, it cannot interact with any limb of the creature wielding it.
Is this a case of RAW trumps logic? Or should the whip be unparryable in spite of RAW?