As a long time DM my self for both home groups and society play, I would like to hear from the community of their thoughts on a rating system for gm's who donate their time to help our lovely hobbies run forward.
On many occasions I have played with excellent judges who adjudicate the game in a fun and wholesome manner which inspires creativity and brings the fantasy of role playing to life.
It would be nice to have a means of players to maybe up-vote dm's who contiue to perform and draw new players to the fold of role playing.
On the flip side i have watched new players be driven away by gms, who are petty, petulant, and/or exhibit some other forms of negative behavior which may erode the PFS experience.
5 options maybe
1. Role play
2. Clarity
3. Did your adventure have purpose?
4. where you treated respectfully by fellow players?
5. Did you have opportunities to contribute to party play?
while these may not be the best question selections, As a DM the opportunity for introspection into my own dm style and perceptions of the players could help to improve gaming?
