My players are playing real goody toeshoes (or however you spell that) and giver everyone a chance to surrender. They did the same with Rowyn and seeing as she was on 2 hp and nauseated she couldn't drink the potion.
Now one of the two clerics wants her as a cohort (they lack a rogue, whose player can't be with us everytime) and possible love interest/sex slave.
My question is, what would she do? They changed her attitude to indifferent (from hostile after they refused) and gave her a change to reform as a 'good girl' and help them find Vanthus and bring him to justice (which won't happen, that would ruin the plot, but they can try).
Yours,
Melce