Me and my buddies had a difference of option the other night on how this game portrays 18 strength's "look" in this game.
Since str is what your attack is based off of, and one of my guys wanted to be the best at the sword he could be, he chose an 18 strength.
Some background to my house rules, is that you can roll the dice for abilities, I don't have a point system and don't feel it is hard at all to modify NPC's ability stat to co-exist with my PC's stats.
So after he puts his 18 in strength, and I asked him what he wanted to look like, he was more or less wanting to be around 6'2" and not really huge.
I told him that won't happen with a 18 strength. He is going to have to look really obvious, because an 18 is the best in the game.
So we got into discussions about why Str is the way to determine if you are the best (most plus) with attacks. I couldn't answer that, due to I myself don't agree with the system, but it is what it is.
He found he can choose weapon finesse and go off his dex, but he will be limited to a d6 weapon, and once again didn't like that.
How do you guys work out the Str aspect of your game? How would you get around having to be the biggest character in the game to be the most skilled? (taking out magical bonuses to weapons and armor)
I don't want to just say by some magical creation blah blah that he looks like a 14 but has a 18, because that would betray every NPC in the game and they would clearly know who has the best sword skil just by looking at them.
Or have I not really looked into this correctly? Does having the highest strength mean without other bonuses you are the most skilled with a weapon?