I'll mark those items already claimed or sold. I'll remove a source from the list when all things have been dealt with.
*denotes a magical item
Master Scourge
potion of blur
potion of cure light wounds
leather armor
punching dagger
masterwork handaxe carved with notches for kills
pistol with 12 bullets and a powder horn sealed with a wax-lined cap to protect the powder from the elements
whip
boatswain’s call
corked dark green bottle containing a thin, light brown fluid
six gold teeth
hefty waxed coat with many hidden pockets
leather snuff box with a diamond stud containing a pinch of dark blue powder
silver wedding ring engraved with the words, "Always devoted to my beloved"
14 pp
29 gp
Mister Plugg
potion of cure moderate wounds - labelled
3 crossbow bolts with heads carved to resemble screaming faces - screaming bolts
cutlass pitted with rust that has a golden basket hilt cast in the likeness of a grinning skull - tidewater cutlass (+1 cutlass that can cast hydraulic push 1/day)
masterwork cat-o’-nine-tails
pistol with 10 bullets and a wax-sealed powder horn
blue wool coat with silver threading, a long tail, and white tasseled leather shoulder straps
amulet made from a scale sealed in amber*
simple iron-shod leather bracers - bracers of armor +1
set of battered iron manacles - shackles of compliance (anyone trying to intimidate or demoralize the wearer gets a +4 bonus on the check; the holder of the key may use command [DC 25] 3/day on the wearer; adjusts from Small to Huge size and automatically lock when placed on a creature's wrists; Hardness 10, Hp 10, Disable Device DC 30, Break DC 28, Escape Artist DC 35)
leather drinking cup
100 sp
200 gp