We're fighting ghouls as undead PCs, and it became apparent that the party ghoul is subject to ghoul fever. They wouldn't take the damage from it (being negative damage), but stage 6 just kills them outright. What happens then? Do they rise a ghoul again, or are they destroyed?
Or even easier:
Immunity to Death Effects: You’re immune to death effects. This keeps you from being automatically killed or from having your dying value automatically increase, but it doesn’t make you immune to other parts of the spell or effect.
So, a ghoul PC already doesn't take negative damage and can't be killed by any disease without taking damage. The only thing remaining in the disease is reduced and removed healing. Which was designed for living creatures in the first place, and wasn't limited to only positive healing. Don't know, you could leave it as is I guess.
Of course people could argue that diseases (most? all?) don't actually have 'death' Trait which that part of Basic Undead Benefits was mainly talking about. But it's not very formal and it does say 'This keeps you from being automatically killed'.
That means they're immune to the death trait, not that they can't be instantly killed. Disintegrate will still instantly kill PCs who are immune to Death Effects if they hit 0 HP, for example. Ghoul Fever does not include the death trait, so they wouldn't be immune to it in the rules.
|2 people marked this as a favorite.|
This feels like an edge case that isn't covered very well by the rules, but shouldn't be hard for a GM to figure out.
A GM worth the title should be able to work out a ruling that is fair, fun, and progresses the story for all of the characters.
It may be a different ruling for individual tables, and that is fine.
The first line of the Ghoul archetype:
"You died from the necrotic disease known as ghoul fever and rose anew as a ravenous ghoul, forever craving the flesh of sapient creatures."
All ghouls, including PCs, constantly crave flesh. There's even a sidebar about how to role-play being hungry and how as you progress and get more ghoul feats you become closer to the ghouls we all know.
Ghoul PCs are ghouls, it's just a slower decent due to their nature of being a PC. The image Paizo has for ghouls in the bestiary is more like a starving ghoul, one who hasn't eaten in a long time and has succumbed 100% to their hunger. A well fed ghoul can easily be a member of high class society or even in politics, especially in Geb, they are just cruel and love cannibalism.