Martial Guilt


Pathfinder First Edition General Discussion

1 to 50 of 126 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>

12 people marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

I've just come from a thread where someone actually said that taking Butterfly Sting with their martial characters was a "cheesy move." This manner of thinking just totally blew my mind.

Don't ever think that a smart move like putting Butterfly Sting into a well-made two-man martial build is cheesy or otherwise "overdoing it." That's exactly what the casters want you to think. It's not even all that powerful a combination. Not when a single caster can wipe the floor with both your characters with one well-placed spell.

Self-imposed guilt such as what I've seen today is simply a long-time form of mass manipulation perpetrated by casters in order to maintain the status quo.

Why else is it that a martial works his butt off to create a competitive build gets decried as "broken" or "cheesy," but when a spellcaster uses minimal resources to much greater effect, they are considered "cool," "powerful," or "gods?" Definitely a double standard instituted by the brain-washing casters. It's the only thing that makes sense.

Long live martials!

;P


Archers, throw down your bows, the symbol of your servitude to the Fickle Wind bearers! Join the ranks of the Slinger Glovers and rise as one against your "masters!"


6 people marked this as a favorite.

Silence, peon! Cease attempting to rise above your proper place as a meat shield at once. Backtalk again, and it's 40 limp lashes for you!

Spoiler:
=D


I do say that there are a few "cheesy" things- One level of Crossblooded Sorc, Leadership with cohort who simple takes Craft feats and sits home making magic items, and so forth.

Butterfly sting was made for martials, it's not taking advantage of something the devs may have overlooked- That's cheesy.


*falls prostrate*

I am not worthy! I am not worthy!

Scarab Sages

I wonder do the same people ho think Butterly's Sting is "cheesy" have any problems with Spell Specialization, Spell Perfection, Dazing Spells?


Yup. Same with weapon specialization. Totes broken.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

3 people marked this as a favorite.

I once saw a thread in the rules forum where a GM wanted affirmation in his belief that his player's idea of having an everburning torch sticking out of his backpack for a hands-free light source was "cheesy".

Scarab Sages

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I had Continual Flame cast on the top of my helmet once, it looked like my head was always brightly burning. I ended up getting a lot of bonuses to intimidate thanks to the ghost rider effect, but it made stealth much more difficult.


Did this ruckus about Butterfly Sting happen before or after the feat was essentially tied to being a Desna worshiper in Inner Sea Gods


Lamontius wrote:
Did this ruckus about Butterfly Sting happen before or after the feat was essentially tied to being a Desna worshiper in Inner Sea Gods

1. Only for PFS

2. This only matters if you're also trying to take another feat that requires the worship of a particular faith. Since there are no evil characters in PFS, there are no alignment problems with the worship of a chaotic good God. As far as I know, even Paladins could take the feat since they're not restricted to a particular set of gods. It does limit character fluff, but then "used only by followers of Desna" has been right there in the fluff of the feat from the beginning.


7 people marked this as a favorite.
Lamontius wrote:
Did this ruckus about Butterfly Sting happen before or after the feat was essentially tied to being a Desna worshiperMinion of The Monarch in Inner Sea Gods

Sorry, been watching too much venture brothers lately.


martials are from venus, casters are from mars.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Apparently one handed small reach weapons are too much cheese for gms.

RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16

7 people marked this as a favorite.

It appears Crane Wing was allowing martials to not play the AC game when it comes to personal defense (as casters don't, via Mirror Image or Displacement). This issue has been rectified.


On the real though, I know this thread is tongue in cheek but I honestly don't even know what people want from martials. You speak of the disparity then people complain about rapid reload and butterfly sting. Tons of people hate the crane wing nerf but when I bring it up to a guy who loves monks he says it was op and... I don't get it.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Lamontius wrote:
Did this ruckus about Butterfly Sting happen before or after the feat was essentially tied to being a Desna worshiper in Inner Sea Gods

The developers have long since established that new material does not invalidate old material, allowing both to be used in home games (specific examples being the juju oracle and the dueling weapon property, each having been printed twice in two sources with completely different abilities). Essentially, there are two Butterfly Sting feats now. :)

Be sure to mark on your sheet which source you're using! ;P


not my point and not an answer to my question


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

I don't think they said, Lamontius. Sounded like it was the earlier version of the feat.

Liberty's Edge

Lamontius wrote:
Did this ruckus about Butterfly Sting happen before or after the feat was essentially tied to being a Desna worshiper in Inner Sea Gods
Faith of Purity wrote:

Good does not fight evil by its mere existence, and most of the gods of good teach that their worshipers must take active roles in preventing the spread of corruption in the mortal world. The feats detailed below are not necessarily unique to the followers of these gods, but appear far more commonly among the congregations of these gods.

Desna
Much of a Desnan’s combat prowess revolves around helping her allies work in concert and using mysterious knowledge to uncannily avoid blows.

Butterfly’s Sting (Critical)
You can forgo a critical hit in order to pass it on to an ally.
Prerequisite: Combat Expertise.
Benefit: When you confirm a critical hit against a creature, you can choose to forgo the effect of the critical hit and grant a critical hit to the next ally who hits the creature with a melee attack before the start of your next turn. Your attack only deals normal damage, and the next ally automatically confirms the hit as a critical.

So, not something that started with Inner Sea Gods.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

I don't play superstitious spell sundering beast totem human FCB Barbars with courageous weapons because I think they are broken.

So I too am guilty of martial guilt.

Scarab Sages

8 people marked this as a favorite.
FanaticRat wrote:

Tons of people hate the crane wing nerf but when I bring it up to a guy who loves monks he says it was op and... I don't get it.

Your friend who loves monks is also suffering from martial guilt. People suffering from this disease have become so convinced that anything a martial is capable of absolutely cannot be as good as anything a spell of any level can do that when an ability like Crane Wing comes along and allows a character without spells to do something a character with spells could do (much more effectively) there must be something wrong.


Ravingdork wrote:

I've just come from a thread where someone actually said that taking Butterfly Sting with their martial characters was a "cheesy move." This manner of thinking just totally blew my mind.

A lot of people have a strange sense of smell.

Sometimes I think every time someone builds a pc that is capable in combat without mainly relying on magic that's a bad thing.

Recent threads: My inquisitor archer is breaking my game, two ratfolk PCs using teamwork feats and their swarming trait are OP, etc, antagonize is too strong (I'm not talking about hating it for "common sense" reasons).


I do agree with the feat that originated this topic (Butterfly's Sting) not being cheesy as well as the concept of the first post, but not with the load of baggage the thread is taking as it is moving on.

"Your friend is suffering from the disease of Martial Guilt"?

"He doesn't agree with my sense of balance? He must be sick."

That is what I am seeing when I read this and is pretty disrespectful.

Even now the complaint about the Crane Wing revision continue when the best examples of spells with similar results are mirror image and displacement when those pretty poorly replicate or even match Crane Wing. Not to say that I don't think spells exist that do so or are even better. Just they include things like fly, greater invisibility, dimension door, et cetera which result in the caster not being an option to attack in the first place depending on the situation.


8 people marked this as a favorite.

Mirror Image and Displacement are significantly better than the Original crane wing.

Crane Wing was "Destroy your ability to do damage and in return negate one attack against you.

Meanwhile Mirror Image is "Roll against my AC, if you hit roll to see if you hit me on a 1/9 chance"
and Displacement is "50% of all attacks against me miss"
the two of them together create a hilarious state of near invulnerability.

While under the effects of Mirror Image and/or Displacement a caster still is able to operate unhindered. To use Crane Wing one needed to punch their attack bonus in the jibblies.

TL;DR
Old Crane Wing was weaker than common defensive spells and got nerfed anyway.

Sovereign Court

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Marcus Robert Hosler wrote:

I don't play superstitious spell sundering beast totem human FCB Barbars with courageous weapons because I think they are broken.

So I too am guilty of martial guilt.

Admitting it is the first step. ;)

Unfortunetly all "cures" require casters. :(

Scarab Sages

Blazej wrote:
Not to say that I don't think spells exist that do so or are even better. Just they include things like fly, greater invisibility, dimension door, et cetera which result in the caster not being an option to attack in the first place depending on the situation.

Ummmm, fly and greater invisibility make the caster better at attacking, adding bonuses and various situational advantages. If Crane Wing was broken, then fly, displacement, greater invisibility, etc. are leaps and bounds beyond that. I think in Pathfinder terminology they would be considered destroyed. That's what comes after broken, right?


Someone taking Butterfly Sting should have the same guilt as someone taking fickle winds. Both are cheesy. The Guilt is well earned, martial or caster matters not.

Oh, and:

Mystically Inclined wrote:
2. This only matters if you're also trying to take another feat that requires the worship of a particular faith. Since there are no evil characters in PFS, there are no alignment problems with the worship of a chaotic good God. As far as I know, even Paladins could take the feat since they're not restricted to a particular set of gods. It does limit character fluff, but then "used only by followers of Desna" has been right there in the fluff of the feat from the beginning.

In PFS, to gain the benefit of any ability tied to the worship of a deity you must be within one alignment step of that deity. So no Paladins with Butterfly Sting from Inner Sea Gods.


Insain Dragoon wrote:

Mirror Image and Displacement are significantly better than the Original crane wing.

Crane Wing was "Destroy your ability to do damage and in return negate one attack against you.

Meanwhile Mirror Image is "Roll against my AC, if you hit roll to see if you hit me on a 1/9 chance"
and Displacement is "50% of all attacks against me miss"
the two of them together create a hilarious state of near invulnerability.

While under the effects of Mirror Image and/or Displacement a caster still is able to operate unhindered. To use Crane Wing one needed to punch their attack bonus in the jibblies.

TL;DR
Old Crane Wing was weaker than common defensive spells and got nerfed anyway.

"B-but it was usable an infinite number of times per day!" I believe that's the primary rationale for this kind of thing. If something isn't magic, it's not allowed to be awesome. It's certainly not based on the ability being limited to a certain # of uses per day. Otherwise, about a dozen or so rogue talents would be AMAZING in their effectiveness rather than 'roll a skill check again' or 'try a Reflex save to maybe take half damage if you were going to die'.


Insain Dragoon wrote:

Mirror Image and Displacement are significantly better than the Original crane wing.

Crane Wing was "Destroy your ability to do damage and in return negate one attack against you.

Destroy your ability to do damage? Am I missing something? It was a -2 penalty to attack rolls that became a -1 after the third feat. It certainly doesn't help with attacks, but as far as penalties go it is about a minimal as it can get.

Insain Dragoon wrote:

Meanwhile Mirror Image is "Roll against my AC, if you hit roll to see if you hit me on a 1/9 chance"

and Displacement is "50% of all attacks against me miss"
the two of them together create a hilarious state of near invulnerability.

Starting off, the spellcaster probably going to have a lower AC than the character with Crane Wing. So while mirror image is incredibly useful, if ten attacks are thrown at the Crane Wing monk and mirror image spellcaster it is a likely conclusion that if any attack would have connected with the monk, then the spellcaster would have probably been hit a couple times and been reduced to few (if any) images remaining. Although, mirror image does work on ranged attacks (which the AC bonus from Crane Style protects against even if it can't be deflected) as well as attacks against invisibility so it has that working for it (which Crane Wing can not protect against).

Similar comments about displacement, it works better than Crane Wing if all the attacks were going to hit no matter what. Reasonably, that isn't the case for the Crane Wing user. The Crane Wing character might suffer an unlucky hit now and then, but when those same attacks are thrown at the spellcaster, there will be a lot more potential hits that displacement will help against, but it will not stop.

Displacement and mirror image don't combo well together. Their abilities overlap and do not stack.

Mirror Image wrote:
An attacker must be able to see the figments to be fooled. If you are invisible or the attacker is blind, the spell has no effect

So, to counter mirror image one can just look at which area the target is in, close their eyes, swing wildly, and open their eye to see what just happened. Doing this, they suffer a 50% miss chance because their target has total concealment, but since the caster in this case has that 50% protection from displacement it doesn't matter anymore. This combo is beaten by blinking (as opposed to blink which does work with mirror image but carries it's own set of issues for the caster).

Insain Dragoon wrote:
While under the effects of Mirror Image and/or Displacement a caster still is able to operate unhindered. To use Crane Wing one needed to punch their attack bonus in the jibblies.

As mentioned before, it is only a -2 penalty to attack which can become as small as -1 by the levels a spellcaster is using displacement. However, the spellcaster is probably worse off because of the action cost required to cast those spells (unless quickened, then more spell resources). Combats don't last that long so it is important when a character has t spend an action to cast protective spells. On the other hand the Crane Wing character just has to spend a swift action (to start the style) and make an attack during his turn.

Insain Dragoon wrote:

TL;DR

Old Crane Wing was weaker than common defensive spells and got nerfed anyway.

Old Crane Wing was weaker than mirror image and displacement only in some situations which are relatively uncommon.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Imbicatus wrote:
I wonder do the same people ho think Butterly's Sting is "cheesy" have any problems with Spell Specialization, Spell Perfection, Dazing Spells?

As one of those people I can say that in my case, yes, FREAKING OMG YES! and yes.

Some of us dislike crazy tuff options across the board. We've mostly realized that we play a different game than the standard pathfinder player though.

- Torger


Insain Dragoon wrote:
Meanwhile Mirror Image is "Roll against my AC, if you hit roll to see if you hit me on a 1/9 chance"

"But if you miss by 5 or more then you destroy an image anyway."


What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?
One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
thejeff wrote:

What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?

One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.

Just that, but the people who hate martials will spring on anything that makes them even remotely interesting.


"Blazej wrote:

Starting off, the spellcaster probably going to have a lower AC than the character with Crane Wing. So while mirror image is incredibly useful, if ten attacks are thrown at the Crane Wing monk and mirror image spellcaster it is a likely conclusion that if any attack would have connected with the monk, then the spellcaster would have probably been hit a couple times and been reduced to few (if any) images remaining. Although, mirror image does work on ranged attacks (which the AC bonus from Crane Style protects against even if it can't be deflected) as well as attacks against invisibility so it has that working for it (which Crane Wing can not protect against).

Similar comments about displacement, it works better than Crane Wing if all the attacks were going to hit no matter what. Reasonably, that isn't the case for the Crane Wing user. The Crane Wing character might suffer an unlucky hit now and then, but when those same attacks are thrown at the spellcaster, there will be a lot more potential hits that displacement will help against, but it will not stop.

Displacement and mirror image don't combo well together. Their abilities overlap and do not stack.

The bit about lower AC is presumptuous. Speaking as a member of a party with an Arcane Duelist bard who's serving as the party tank, I can assure that having access to Mirror Image does NOT automatically make your AC trash. Let's keep this to the strengths of the feat and spell while leaving class dynamics out of it.

Also, those two spells do work together. It's a bit awkward, but there's no reason there can't be a 50% miss chance on top of possibly hitting images.

Scarab Sages

thejeff wrote:

What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?

One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.

I have no problem with the feat as written. It's thematic for Desna worshipers to trade a crit to open up the opponent for someone else.

I do have a problem when people use it with two weapon fighting with a keen kurki and a flaming burst, corrosive burst, shocking burst pick to give themself a massive crit.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Imbicatus wrote:
thejeff wrote:

What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?

One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.

I have no problem with the feat as written. It's thematic for Desna worshipers to trade a crit to open up the opponent for someone else.

I do have a problem when people use it with two weapon fighting with a keen kurki and a flaming burst, corrosive burst, shocking burst pick to give themself a massive crit.

"I have no problem with the feat, I just have a problem with people investing in its value."

That's what I heard.

What is the whole point of the feat if not for "high threat range guy" to pass off crits to "high crit damage guy"? If the two PCs' crits were comparable (like if they were both using the same type of weapon), there would be no point in having the feat at all. It would literally do nothing but change whose name was attached to the crit.

Are you also okay with Power Attack, but have a problem when people use it with full BAB, rage, or Weapon Training to offset the penalty to hit?

Scarab Sages

Jiggy wrote:
Imbicatus wrote:
thejeff wrote:

What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?

One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.

I have no problem with the feat as written. It's thematic for Desna worshipers to trade a crit to open up the opponent for someone else.

I do have a problem when people use it with two weapon fighting with a keen kurki and a flaming burst, corrosive burst, shocking burst pick to give themself a massive crit.

"I have no problem with the feat, I just have a problem with people investing in its value."

That's what I heard.

What is the whole point of the feat if not for "high threat range guy" to pass off crits to "high crit damage guy"? If the two PCs' crits were comparable (like if they were both using the same type of weapon), there would be no point in having the feat at all. It would literally do nothing but change whose name was attached to the crit.

Are you also okay with Power Attack, but have a problem when people use it with full BAB, rage, or Weapon Training to offset the penalty to hit?

Absolutely not.

My problem is a flavor one. It's not the feat I have a problem with, it's the abuse of "you are your own ally" rule to circumvent the flavor of the feat. It's clear from reading the feat it's meant to provide a teamwork benefit to someone else. I see it exactly the same way as trying to use a teamwork feat by yourself without the inquisitor's solo tactics.


Cerberus Seven wrote:

The bit about lower AC is presumptuous. Speaking as a member of a party with an Arcane Duelist bard who's serving as the party tank, I can assure that having access to Mirror Image does NOT automatically make your AC trash. Let's keep this to the strengths of the feat and spell while leaving class dynamics out of it.

Also, those two spells do work together. It's a bit awkward, but there's no reason there can't be a 50% miss chance on top of possibly hitting images.

I don't think lower AC is presumptuous because it does mean you have made choices that will bring your AC 4-5 points higher than characters that have made other choices (Dodge, fighting defensively along the probably synergy from Acrobatics). I wasn't saying the spellcasters AC is trash in anyway, but all other things equal the Crane Style character will have a higher AC which does matter to the situation of fairly comparing the total defensive abilities compared to magical spells.

Yes, by the literal wording of the spells, it may be the case that the order of operations has you checking displacement miss chance before dealing with the effects of mirror image. But you didn't address the fact that closing your eyes defeats the combo even under the most favorable reading to you. I am tempted to go on to say why I don't think they would ever work together, but it isn't relevant and I think it would only confuse from the point that closing your eye defeats the combination in any case.


Imbicatus wrote:

Absolutely not.

My problem is a flavor one. It's not the feat I have a problem with, it's the abuse of "you are your own ally" rule to circumvent the flavor of the feat. It's clear from reading the feat it's meant to provide a teamwork benefit to someone else. I see it exactly the same way as trying to use a teamwork feat by yourself without the inquisitor's solo tactics.

That's not flavor, that's function. If we take the feat for what it means, you set up your ally for a crit and not yourself. That's the flavor of it. Any potential loopholes about what qualifies as an 'ally' is all rules-based mechanics.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Imbicatus wrote:
Jiggy wrote:
Imbicatus wrote:
thejeff wrote:

What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?

One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.

I have no problem with the feat as written. It's thematic for Desna worshipers to trade a crit to open up the opponent for someone else.

I do have a problem when people use it with two weapon fighting with a keen kurki and a flaming burst, corrosive burst, shocking burst pick to give themself a massive crit.

"I have no problem with the feat, I just have a problem with people investing in its value."

That's what I heard.

What is the whole point of the feat if not for "high threat range guy" to pass off crits to "high crit damage guy"? If the two PCs' crits were comparable (like if they were both using the same type of weapon), there would be no point in having the feat at all. It would literally do nothing but change whose name was attached to the crit.

Are you also okay with Power Attack, but have a problem when people use it with full BAB, rage, or Weapon Training to offset the penalty to hit?

Absolutely not.

My problem is a flavor one. It's not the feat I have a problem with, it's the abuse of "you are your own ally" rule to circumvent the flavor of the feat. It's clear from reading the feat it's meant to provide a teamwork benefit to someone else. I see it exactly the same way as trying to use a teamwork feat by yourself without the inquisitor's solo tactics.

Oh! I thought you were talking about two different people, one TWFing with a pair of keen kukris and one with an uber-crit weapon. Nevermind then. :)


Imbicatus wrote:
Jiggy wrote:
Imbicatus wrote:
thejeff wrote:

What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?

One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.

I have no problem with the feat as written. It's thematic for Desna worshipers to trade a crit to open up the opponent for someone else.

I do have a problem when people use it with two weapon fighting with a keen kurki and a flaming burst, corrosive burst, shocking burst pick to give themself a massive crit.

"I have no problem with the feat, I just have a problem with people investing in its value."

That's what I heard.

What is the whole point of the feat if not for "high threat range guy" to pass off crits to "high crit damage guy"? If the two PCs' crits were comparable (like if they were both using the same type of weapon), there would be no point in having the feat at all. It would literally do nothing but change whose name was attached to the crit.

Are you also okay with Power Attack, but have a problem when people use it with full BAB, rage, or Weapon Training to offset the penalty to hit?

Absolutely not.

My problem is a flavor one. It's not the feat I have a problem with, it's the abuse of "you are your own ally" rule to circumvent the flavor of the feat. It's clear from reading the feat it's meant to provide a teamwork benefit to someone else. I see it exactly the same way as trying to use a teamwork feat by yourself without the inquisitor's solo tactics.

Casters abuse "you are your own ally" for years but when a martial does it...

Scarab Sages

Scavion wrote:
Imbicatus wrote:
Jiggy wrote:
Imbicatus wrote:
thejeff wrote:

What's so cheesy about Butterfly Sting anyway? What's the abuse?

One guy using a crit-fishing weapon and the other using a high multiplier?
Or is there something else I'm overlooking.

I have no problem with the feat as written. It's thematic for Desna worshipers to trade a crit to open up the opponent for someone else.

I do have a problem when people use it with two weapon fighting with a keen kurki and a flaming burst, corrosive burst, shocking burst pick to give themself a massive crit.

"I have no problem with the feat, I just have a problem with people investing in its value."

That's what I heard.

What is the whole point of the feat if not for "high threat range guy" to pass off crits to "high crit damage guy"? If the two PCs' crits were comparable (like if they were both using the same type of weapon), there would be no point in having the feat at all. It would literally do nothing but change whose name was attached to the crit.

Are you also okay with Power Attack, but have a problem when people use it with full BAB, rage, or Weapon Training to offset the penalty to hit?

Absolutely not.

My problem is a flavor one. It's not the feat I have a problem with, it's the abuse of "you are your own ally" rule to circumvent the flavor of the feat. It's clear from reading the feat it's meant to provide a teamwork benefit to someone else. I see it exactly the same way as trying to use a teamwork feat by yourself without the inquisitor's solo tactics.

Casters abuse "you are your own ally" for years but when a martial does it...

It's upsets me when caster do it too. It's lazy spell writing by not being specific in target fields.

I agree that it's legal for caster with spells and for butterfly's sting users to target themselves with those abilities, and due to the FAQ, I would absolutely allow it to be run that way if I were GMing someone who sat down with a build based on that.

I just won't do it myself and find it distasteful to bring to a table.

Likewise I wouldn't play a rogue Horizon walker with a +22 favored terrain bonus even though it's rather easy to build one and perfectly legal.


4 people marked this as a favorite.
Blazej wrote:
I don't think lower AC is presumptuous because it does mean you have made choices that will bring your AC 4-5 points higher than characters that have made other choices (Dodge, fighting defensively along the probably synergy from Acrobatics). I wasn't saying the spellcasters AC is trash in anyway, but all other things equal the Crane Style character will have a higher AC which does matter to the situation of fairly comparing the total defensive abilities compared to magical spells.

Concerning AC, Crane Style's buff to fighting defensively doesn't stack up to be any better than things like Barkskin, Shield, Dispel Evil, or anything else which provides non-universal AC bonuses. The fact that these spells don't penalize the user or impose special restrictions on when they can be used just makes them that much better. And again, you're clearly favoring a certain kind of character for the Crane Style user, one who supposedly has a better AC than the Mirror Image caster. That spell is usable by both bards and magi. Crane Wing can technically be taken by anyone, even ones with crappy AC (who would REALLY appreciate the way the feat works, more so than high-AC ones) who feels like dumping 4 feats into it. For 4 whole feats worth of investment, it really SHOULD be one of the best defensive options in the game.


Blazej wrote:
Cerberus Seven wrote:

The bit about lower AC is presumptuous. Speaking as a member of a party with an Arcane Duelist bard who's serving as the party tank, I can assure that having access to Mirror Image does NOT automatically make your AC trash. Let's keep this to the strengths of the feat and spell while leaving class dynamics out of it.

Also, those two spells do work together. It's a bit awkward, but there's no reason there can't be a 50% miss chance on top of possibly hitting images.

I don't think lower AC is presumptuous because it does mean you have made choices that will bring your AC 4-5 points higher than characters that have made other choices (Dodge, fighting defensively along the probably synergy from Acrobatics). I wasn't saying the spellcasters AC is trash in anyway, but all other things equal the Crane Style character will have a higher AC which does matter to the situation of fairly comparing the total defensive abilities compared to magical spells.

Yes, by the literal wording of the spells, it may be the case that the order of operations has you checking displacement miss chance before dealing with the effects of mirror image. But you didn't address the fact that closing your eyes defeats the combo even under the most favorable reading to you. I am tempted to go on to say why I don't think they would ever work together, but it isn't relevant and I think it would only confuse from the point that closing your eye defeats the combination in any case.

I dunno, I have a hard time seeing how going from a super high miss chance to a flat 50% miss chance before AC is really a counter.


Jiggy wrote:
I once saw a thread in the rules forum where a GM wanted affirmation in his belief that his player's idea of having an everburning torch sticking out of his backpack for a hands-free light source was "cheesy".

I remember that thread... it made me cry...

heck I remember some people calling the Ioun that acts like a torch cheesy....


Cerberus Seven wrote:
Blazej wrote:
I don't think lower AC is presumptuous because it does mean you have made choices that will bring your AC 4-5 points higher than characters that have made other choices (Dodge, fighting defensively along the probably synergy from Acrobatics). I wasn't saying the spellcasters AC is trash in anyway, but all other things equal the Crane Style character will have a higher AC which does matter to the situation of fairly comparing the total defensive abilities compared to magical spells.
Concerning AC, Crane Style's buff to fighting defensively doesn't stack up to be any better than things like Barkskin, Shield, Dispel Evil, or anything else which provides non-universal AC bonuses. The fact that these spells don't penalize the user or impose special restrictions on when they can be used just makes them that much better. And again, you're clearly favoring a certain kind of character for the Crane Style user, one who supposedly has a better AC than the Mirror Image caster. That spell is usable by both bards and magi. Crane Wing can technically be taken by anyone, even ones with crappy AC (who would REALLY appreciate the way the feat works, more so than high-AC ones) who feels like dumping 4 feats into it. For 4 whole feats worth of investment, it really SHOULD be one of the best defensive options in the game.

Those spells give a natural armor bonus, shield bonus, and deflection bonus respectively. Each has different benefits, but there are a few standard items that give this bonuses that won't stack with the spells and will likely find their way into the hands of those who desire yet more AC (they do take item slots, which would be irritating for the monk with the amulet of natural armor taking the neck slot).

To be clear, I'm not trying to dismiss or make it seem that those spells are bad. They are good spells (although, I think for clerics shield of faith is a better example since dispel evil is better for it's unique abilities at the cost of that spell level).

Each of those covers a different spellcaster (so unless you employ a more unique build, you will likely only see the spellcaster cast one of those spells on themselves, but of them, only barkskin wouldn't likely come with the cost of the lost action during combat.

I am favoring a certain type of character using Crane Style. It likely is due to me running a campaign for a Crane Style monk with that monstrous AC. However the usage of the feat is such that it will likely be on melee characters, typically monks or unarmed fighters for the high feat prerequisites (which is an honestly good point since this is in total a chain of five feats it should give reasonable bonuses over the length), and because they are melee they are going to tend to spend more resources on a higher AC (not getting what the end power gain from a spellcaster have a little more leeway for purchasing magical items).

It might be the case that if an armorless raging barbarian with this feat chain at a dire wolf, he couldn't lose (unless the wolf decides to grapple) and he would definitely get good use blocking one attack per round. However with the way the feat was designed, I do not believe that is not the character it worked best for. It's optimal environment wasn't blocking some melee attacks, it was blocking all melee attacks by having a high enough AC that is was only likely (by chance) one attack (or two if they got very lucky) would hit you per round.

To be honest would you have been happy if if Crane Wing was instead changed to say:

"While using Crane Style, when you have at least one hand free and are either fighting defensively or using the total defense action, you have a chance to deflect any melee weapon attack that would normally hit you. Physical attacks against you have a 50% miss chance. The Blind-Fight feat doesn't help opponents with this miss chance. You expend no action to deflect the attack, but you must be aware of it and not flat-footed. An attack so deflected deals no damage to you."

[Changes are removal of once per round limitation and changing the automatic deflection into a miss chance]

Would it be more powerful or less powerful? It makes the style a constant melee displacement for only a minor action cost and it can operate continuously. It would make the barbarian happier, but in the situation I ran for it would end up causing the Crane Style monk to get hit more often as his guaranteed shield would have become a coin flip. Even though it would work on every time he got hit, it would be irrelevant as he would suffer only one hit per round more often than not.

Would you say this feat is great, a unnecessary downgrade, cheesy, or still weak compared to spell casters?

I would say that is more powerful than any spellcaster option to do the same at that level (except for things like fly against things that can neither fly or make ranged attacks).


Jiggy wrote:
Imbicatus wrote:
My problem is a flavor one. It's not the feat I have a problem with, it's the abuse of "you are your own ally" rule to circumvent the flavor of the feat. It's clear from reading the feat it's meant to provide a teamwork benefit to someone else. I see it exactly the same way as trying to use a teamwork feat by yourself without the inquisitor's solo tactics.
Oh! I thought you were talking about two different people, one TWFing with a pair of keen kukris and one with an uber-crit weapon. Nevermind then. :)

You'd have to be two weapon fighting. Between the heavy feat load and the penalties you'd better be getting something like 18-20x4 crits out of it.


FanaticRat wrote:
Blazej wrote:
But you didn't address the fact that closing your eyes defeats the combo even under the most favorable reading to you.
I dunno, I have a hard time seeing how going from a super high miss chance to a flat 50% miss chance before AC is really a counter.

In this case the spell caster either wasted a turn casting mirror image or expended something like a 6th level spell to cast quickened mirror image to no additional effect. It doesn't negate all of their defenses like displacement but it does counter the idea that you can get bring the chance of hitting you down to about 5% even after you hit their AC.


Blazej wrote:
FanaticRat wrote:
Blazej wrote:
But you didn't address the fact that closing your eyes defeats the combo even under the most favorable reading to you.
I dunno, I have a hard time seeing how going from a super high miss chance to a flat 50% miss chance before AC is really a counter.
In this case the spell caster either wasted a turn casting mirror image or expended something like a 6th level spell to cast quickened mirror image to no additional effect. It doesn't negate all of their defenses like displacement but it does counter the idea that you can get bring the chance of hitting you down to about 5% even after you hit their AC.

actually it would be a 5th...

Oha nd there is such a thing as a Minor Rod of Quickening... Standard staple for mid to high level wizards...

1 to 50 of 126 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / General Discussion / Martial Guilt All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.