Most Beneficial Order

Rules Questions

"Apply penalties and bonuses in the most beneficial order"

This little innocuous statement has me baffled. I've seen it repeated over and over on these boards and others like them. It's been used for philosophical rules games and cheese factory character building alike.

...But where is this rule?

I've searched every copy of every book I own for this statement, even back into my 3.5 and 3.0 books. I've even looked online and I mostly find people using this "rule" for some build or such, posting it as gospel yet citing no source.

The closest things I've found that remotely look like a source are a Sage ruleing about poison and death attacks that I believe to have been written by Skip Williams and a question about the Practiced Spellcaster feat in the 3.5 FAQ (last updated 2008).

Where did this little gem come from? Why does it seem everyone knows it? Does it exist anywhere in pathfinder?

Inquiring minds (mostly mine) want to know!

As far as know, it is not a rule as such. But nowhere in any book is there a fixed order in which to apply different bonuses, so it seems only logical that you are allowed to apply them in any order you like, which would mean the most beneficial order for you

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Rulebook, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

Well, thanks to stacking rules, it doesn't really apply to bonuses and penalties: the place you'll see it crop up most is with energy resistance.

A creature with Fire Resistance 20 is hit with a fireball for (lucky roll!) 50 points of damage.

We're all going to agree that if it fails the Reflex save it takes 30 points of damage.

How much does it take on a successful save?

At this point, the order of the alterations matter.

If it's resistance, then save, it will take 15 points of damage.

If it's save, then resistance, it will take 5.

Accepted wisdom is that effects like this are treated to the defender's advantage, but I don't think it's covered anywhere in the rules as such, it's just how it works: a creature that saves is taking 25 points of damage, not "50, but modified". Since that's the case, the more general case to the rule becomes "apply effects to defender's advantage", which is where I've even seen Paizo staff say the same thing.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Most Beneficial Order All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.