Limited Wish to fix a Robe of the Archmagi

[vonFiedler]

A player of mine wants to do this to a completely destroyed Robe of the Archmagi

"Limited Wish: Effect in line with a 6th level spell, namely a buffed Make Whole that can fix things with higher CLs. Since Make Whole is level 2 and allows up to 1/2 CL, and Mending, a cantrip/orison doesn't allow bringing the spell back to magic stuff, a level 4 verson should probably allow up to CL, so a CL 14 Limited Wish to fix it would probably be in the same line of power as the spell itself."

It sounds reasonable, but I can't help but feel maybe there is a reason there isn't a good spell to fix powerful magic items.

Any thoughts?

[Drachasor]

I think it is fine. There are lots of reasonable spells that haven't been printed. That's only because of limited room or people not thinking about them before. Make Whole's use to fix magical items is new to PF, which is why there's not a higher level version.

[GM Hands of Fate]

I would allow it, BUT I would have the player pay for some of the materials for the RotAM. As the robe was completely destroyed, one could argue that some material was needed to repair it, even with a limited wish. I wouldn't make it the entire 37.5kgp. Maybe 10-12kgp in materials.