Javaed |
It depends entirely on the types of monsters you expect to face. To be honest, all of those traits are highly situational, but you may face off against enough aquatic enemies in a pirate campaign for the trade to be worthwhile.
Now, if you're going to be facing off against a bunch of orc-pirate crews then I wouldn't make the trade =)
ryric RPG Superstar 2011 Top 32 |
What you're losing is: +4 AC vs giants
+1 to hit vs. orcs and goblins
+2 Perception for some stone related stuff
What you're gaining is: +2 AC vs. aquatic creatures
+1 to hit vs. aquatic creatures
+2 to some sailing skills
modification to the greed ability
If you're going to be fighting more aquatic creatures than orcs and giants, and not going to be around stonework much, it looks like a decent trade.