How to check if Scenarios have been reported


GM Discussion


I just ran into an issue where it appears as the previous GM for a couple sessions didn't fill out his portion of the sheet correctly, and the player didn't catch it.

I have three First Step sheets, where the GM awarded 3XP per scenario. The first scenario, the player started with 0 fame/prestige, gained two, and ended with 5.

Later in the character's career...he played a L2 character in a Tier 4-5 game, which isn't allowed.

I'd like to check and see if these games were actually reported. Unfortunately, the GM also didn't fill out the Event or Event code.

Shadow Lodge 5/5

GM Hands of Fate wrote:

Later in the character's career...he played a L2 character in a Tier 4-5 game, which isn't allowed.

The other part I can't really help out with, except to say you might want to have the player contact his VC so he can hopefully clear that up.

As for the quoted section, a level 2 PC can play up to sub-tier 4-5. As long as the PC is in the Tier of the scenario (1-5, since that's the only 4-5 sub-tier that I know of) he can play one sub-tier away. If he were third level and playing in a 1-7 tier scenario, he could play in sub-tiers 1-2, 3-4, or even 6-7 if that's how the APL went.


OK my understanding was that if the scenario was played at Tier 4-5, you could play it with Level 3-6 characters.

Thanks for the clarification.

I have suggested he get a hold of both the GM from the scenarios he played in as well as the VC to get this cleared up.

Shadow Lodge 5/5

I'd suggest you re-read the Guide to Organized play. It looks like you're confusing the rules for playing in a Module with those for playing in a Scenario.

Liberty's Edge 5/5 Venture-Lieutenant, Washington—Seattle aka The Great Rinaldo!

Eric Clingenpeel wrote:
I'd suggest you re-read the Guide to Organized play. It looks like you're confusing the rules for playing in a Module with those for playing in a Scenario.

And it is possible the GM who awarded 3 xp for First Steps was doing the same, as (most) modules do award 3 xp.


GUys, thanks for the help, but I am having a debate with a fellow GM. We are looking at the text on page 32 of the guide

Quote:
Tiers are a level restriction for play. If a PC’s level does not fall within the level range of a scenario’s tier, that character can not legally play in that scenario. For example, a 5th-level PC is legal for play in scenarios of Tiers 1–5, 3–7, and 5–9; a 1st-level PC can only legally play in a Tier 1 or Tier 1–5 scenario. Within each tier, PCs should play in the subtier in which they fall whenever possible, but they may be allowed to play up or down, based on the average party level at the table, as outlined below. Some scenarios or special events offer more than two subtiers. In these cases, no PC can play at a subtier more than 1 step away from her character level.

The last line is where we are in contention. This sentence would seem to indicate that a Level 1 character could not play in a Subtier 3-4, even though the scenario is Tier 1-7. (Shipyard Rats)

Liberty's Edge 5/5 Venture-Lieutenant, Alaska—Anchorage aka Dragnmoon

Chris Manos wrote:
The last line is where we are in contention. This sentence would seem to indicate that a Level 1 character could not play in a Subtier 3-4, even though the scenario is Tier 1-7. (Shipyard Rats)

in a 1-7 game, the line "In these cases, no PC can play at a subtier more than 1 step away from her character level." allows a level 1 or 2 to play in sub-tier 3-4 (1 step away from sub-tier 1-2) but not in sub-tier 6-7 which is 2 steps away.

Do not forget you can only play out of sub-tier if the average level of the group allows it.


that is my understanding. Others disagree.


Well, they're wrong. It says "one step," not "one level."

Grand Lodge

Patrick Harris @ SD wrote:
Well, they're wrong. It says "one step," not "one level."

+1

It is "one step" not "one level".

Community / Forums / Organized Play / GM Discussion / How to check if Scenarios have been reported All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in GM Discussion