RPG Superstar


RPG Superstar™ 2009 General Discussion


Are the competitions going to be the same every year? I wanted to jump in last year, but I was tied down with work. Starting a couple of months ahead of time would make things easier.

Liberty's Edge

Yeah, that's kinda been my thought too. I've been brainstorming ideas for wondrous items.

Liberty's Edge RPG Superstar 2008 Top 32, 2011 Top 16 , Star Voter Season 6, Star Voter Season 7, Star Voter Season 8, Star Voter Season 9 aka JoelF847

While the basic format has been the same both years, there have been differences. I would guess that next year's will also have differences. In addition, next year's is certainly going to use the full Pathfinder RPG rules, which aren't out until August, so at the very least you probably want to hold off on any rules mechanic work until then.

Both years have had the open call as a 200 word or less wondrous item, so it's a fairly good bet that it will be the same in 2010, but I wouldn't be shocked if something else was used either.

Paizo Employee Chief Technical Officer

JoelF847 wrote:

While the basic format has been the same both years, there have been differences. I would guess that next year's will also have differences. In addition, next year's is certainly going to use the full Pathfinder RPG rules, which aren't out until August, so at the very least you probably want to hold off on any rules mechanic work until then.

Both years have had the open call as a 200 word or less wondrous item, so it's a fairly good bet that it will be the same in 2010, but I wouldn't be shocked if something else was used either.

What he said.

Also, while starting on a wondrous item now might seem an opportunity to give your submission the polish that could help get your item selected, later rounds ensure that the eventual winner will be someone who can come up with clever ideas and write thousands of words explaining them, doing so with just a few days notice.

Contributor, RPG Superstar 2009, RPG Superstar Judgernaut

I'm really glad they didn't institute a "wondrous" swimsuit round in the competition last time. Everyone else should be, too... ;-P

The Exchange

I've just returned from Paizocon and whilst I was there I got a chance to meet Neil Spicer, Jason Nelson, and Clinton Boomer along with other creative minds that contribute to Pathfinder and I want you guys to know that you've really inspired me to give the RPG superstar a try. Thanks guys and it was really nice to meet you.

Contributor, RPG Superstar 2009, RPG Superstar Judgernaut

Kosivo0121 wrote:
I've just returned from Paizocon and whilst I was there I got a chance to meet Neil Spicer, Jason Nelson, and Clinton Boomer along with other creative minds that contribute to Pathfinder and I want you guys to know that you've really inspired me to give the RPG superstar a try. Thanks guys and it was really nice to meet you.

It was great meeting you as well, Kosivo. Definitely throw your hat into the ring for 2010.

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2009 Top 8 aka Tarren Dei

NSpicer wrote:
Kosivo0121 wrote:
I've just returned from Paizocon and whilst I was there I got a chance to meet Neil Spicer, Jason Nelson, and Clinton Boomer along with other creative minds that contribute to Pathfinder and I want you guys to know that you've really inspired me to give the RPG superstar a try. Thanks guys and it was really nice to meet you.
It was great meeting you as well, Kosivo. Definitely throw your hat into the ring for 2010.

And, with that, a number of wondrous hat submissions are born.

Contributor, RPG Superstar 2009, RPG Superstar Judgernaut

Tarren Dei wrote:
And, with that, a number of wondrous hat submissions are born.

Actually, my backup magic item (i.e., the one I didn't choose over the last leaves) was along those lines. :-)

And just FYI, you totally should have attended PaizoCon, my friend. It was well worth the trip. And I would have loved to have met you in person. See if you can't make plans to come out next year.

Scarab Sages Contributor, RPG Superstar 2008 Top 4, Legendary Games

NSpicer wrote:
Kosivo0121 wrote:
I've just returned from Paizocon and whilst I was there I got a chance to meet Neil Spicer, Jason Nelson, and Clinton Boomer along with other creative minds that contribute to Pathfinder and I want you guys to know that you've really inspired me to give the RPG superstar a try. Thanks guys and it was really nice to meet you.
It was great meeting you as well, Kosivo. Definitely throw your hat into the ring for 2010.

What he said! Likewise nice to meet in person, and absolutely give it a shot. You might win, you might lose, you might fall somewhere in between, but you will most certainly have a great time whatever happens.

Scarab Sages Contributor, RPG Superstar 2008 Top 4, Legendary Games

Vic Wertz wrote:
JoelF847 wrote:

While the basic format has been the same both years, there have been differences. I would guess that next year's will also have differences. In addition, next year's is certainly going to use the full Pathfinder RPG rules, which aren't out until August, so at the very least you probably want to hold off on any rules mechanic work until then.

Both years have had the open call as a 200 word or less wondrous item, so it's a fairly good bet that it will be the same in 2010, but I wouldn't be shocked if something else was used either.

What he said.

Also, while starting on a wondrous item now might seem an opportunity to give your submission the polish that could help get your item selected, later rounds ensure that the eventual winner will be someone who can come up with clever ideas and write thousands of words explaining them, doing so with just a few days notice.

Tru dat. So if you do well enough to get noticed, and Sean Reynolds sends you an email, and it sounds cool and all, but then he says "Oh yeah, we need it back by next Friday," you better be ready to put the pedal to the metal, metaphorically speaking! Great ideas are a necessity, and sometimes you'll have plenty of time to craft and polish to your heart's content, but you also gotta be able to do the deed and hit it hard and fast sometimes. Let's just say it's not an accident that tight turnaround is part of the contest!

Sovereign Court

About starting early on the wondrous item...I'm sure that everything that's been said about the importance of being able to do great work quickly is true. BUT, it wouldn't hurt to put everything you can into the wondrous item now. Standing out of the immense crowd of submissions in the open call round is a pretty big hurdle to get over, in my opinion. Being mechanically solid, interesting/original, and filling a needed niche isn't necessarily enough to get your item into the top 32 (as evidenced by the comments from Clark and Sean in the "Critique My Item" threads).

Then again, maybe if you can't get enough "mojo/moxie" in your submission to catch the judges' attention without spending a ton of time on it, you don't belong in RPG Superstar. I'm just hoping that's not true :-). (I'm also hoping I'll stand a better chance next year if I don't repeatedly use a word that gives Sean K Reynolds a headache!)

Contributor, RPG Superstar 2009, RPG Superstar Judgernaut

Elora wrote:
(I'm also hoping I'll stand a better chance next year if I don't repeatedly use a word that gives Sean K Reynolds a headache!)

Can't go wrong with that strategy!

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2009 Top 8 aka Tarren Dei

NSpicer wrote:
Elora wrote:
(I'm also hoping I'll stand a better chance next year if I don't repeatedly use a word that gives Sean K Reynolds a headache!)
Can't go wrong with that strategy!

Are you talking about irregular plurals? Because I've had it up to my irides with that discussion.

Sovereign Court

Tarren Dei wrote:
Are you talking about irregular plurals? Because I've had it up to my irides with that discussion.

Ha! How could I have forgotten about that wonderful word?

But no...the word in question is "rouge". Yes, rouge, not rogue. That is, lipstick, not thief. As in, I named my item "Rogue's Rouge".

I thought it would be clever, descriptive and at the same time educational to the spelling-challenged. Perhaps even to the point of inspiring intelligent discussions around the game table regarding the proper placement of the letter "u". Alas, Sean's overworked brain kept interpreting "rouge" as mis-spelled "rogue".

Lesson learned.

Contributor, RPG Superstar 2008 Top 16

NSpicer wrote:
I'm really glad they didn't institute a "wondrous" swimsuit round in the competition last time. Everyone else should be, too... ;-P

Not to mention the possibility of Perez Hilton as a guest judge... :)

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2009 Top 8 aka Tarren Dei

NSpicer wrote:
Tarren Dei wrote:
And, with that, a number of wondrous hat submissions are born.

Actually, my backup magic item (i.e., the one I didn't choose over the last leaves) was along those lines. :-)

And just FYI, you totally should have attended PaizoCon, my friend. It was well worth the trip. And I would have loved to have met you in person. See if you can't make plans to come out next year.

I would have loved to have been there. It would have been great to meet you face-to-face ... although, if you had a really squeaky voice or something it would forever ruin Lord Orlan Foehammer's lines in the pbp.

I was a bit busy that weekend.

Do they know what day it is next year? I should try to find an education conference in town on the same week.


Cute kids, TD.

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2009 Top 8 aka Tarren Dei

Mairkurion {tm} wrote:
Cute kids, TD.

Thanks M.

Spoiler:
So, when exactly are you coming to Montreal?


OT @ TD:

Spoiler:
Nov 6-9? 7-10? I think the former.

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2009 Top 8 aka Tarren Dei

Mairkurion {tm} wrote:

OT @ TD:

** spoiler omitted **

OT @ Mairkurion

Spoiler:

I'm there the week after I think. You have my email?


OT @ TD

Spoiler:
No. Mine's --------- underscore --- at hotmail dot com
I'll give you a shout if you want once it is getting closer to time.

Community / Forums / Archive / Paizo / RPG Superstar™ / Previous Contests / RPG Superstar™ 2009 / General Discussion / RPG Superstar All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in General Discussion