David Tennant to quit as Doctor Who


Television

1 to 50 of 130 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>

*link to BBC news article on this subject*


That sucks! ~shrugs~ Oh well. I wonder who the next Doctor will be.

Sovereign Court RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

Sorry to see him leave the role.

Let the speculation begin.

Scarab Sages

Dammit! first I love Eccleston. he's the reason I started watching. then he's ripped away. next I love Piper, and she leaves. i finally start liking Donna and she leaves. Piper is finally back and she's kicked out again. and now Tennant is gone??? Why does this show enjoy messing with me so much??? It tries so hard to make me love the characters knowing they're going to be ripped away.

anyhow, i have no idea who could possibly be the doctor next, but I have a feeling it's gonna be something to try and shock us. prolly female or something, though i don't think that's possible i also don't think it's ever explicitely been stated that it isn't.


If anything, change is one of the main reasons I love WHO.

I'm really glad to see Tennant leave (my favorite doctor by the way) but it's good to shake things up and there are TONS of great actors that could bring something new to the show.

I wonder what the new personality of our favorite Time Lord will be like?

James Nesbitt was hotly tipped to be the next Doctor, although today the radio said he says he wont be doing it. (Yay! Can't stand his work and dislike his voice.)

Robert Carlise (Begby from Trainspotting) is also strongly rumoured to be the new guy in the policebox.

Richard E Grant is another one people keep bringing up along with Rhys Ifans.

But I think it may actually be Paul McGann (the 8th doc returning) as Russell T Davis said recently that it's never been stated in the show what number Doctor Christopher Eccleston or David Tennant were playing. Therefore there may even be people (and new stories) in between McGann and Eccleston's adventures.

Also the newspapers here (a couple of months ago) leaked that McGann has been filming parts set after or during the timewar to be shown in the specials with Tennant next year....

Hmmmm?!

My theory is that Mcgann will be doc for a little bit, dies and passes the torch to a new actor and we get a series set before the 'new Who' for lots of time loopy weirdness that's also right up (the new man in charge) Steven Moffat's alley!

Cue: Russell Tovey (who RTD loves big time and wishes was the next Doctor?!)

Or I may be completely wrong, lol! :P


Hmmm, or Nick Logue is in the UK at present, and has acting experience... :D


I'd like to see an old duffer in the role again.

Paizo Employee Director of Game Design

I really did enjoy Tennant as the Doctor.. this fills me full of sadness, but such is the way of things.

Jason Bulmahn
Lead Designer
Paizo Publishing


I enjoyed Tennant greatly he was a fantastic doctor. However change is a part of the show and I wish him the best.

Sovereign Court RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

Problem with your theory R-type is we do have the Doctor regenerating from Sylverster McCoy to Paul McGann.

Now it's true that David's doctor could be the 11th, 12th or 13th doctor, but Paul's is the 8th.

Dark Archive

I would like to see David Oyelowo in the role. I really enjoyed his work on Spooks or MI-5 here in the states. I just feel that he would make an excellent replacement for Tennant. Tennant was the one who really sealed the deal for me on the new series. I always felt that Eccelston was too angsty to be the Doctor, although I have enjoyed his work on other projects.

RPG Superstar 2011 Top 16

Matthew Morris wrote:

Problem with your theory R-type is we do have the Doctor regenerating from Sylverster McCoy to Paul McGann.

Now it's true that David's doctor could be the 11th, 12th or 13th doctor, but Paul's is the 8th.

I recall hearing somewhere that every twelfth regeneration is supposed to be an evil Doctor. Is that true? If it is, we can rule out David's Doctor as the 13th, since he's clearly not evil.


Matthew Morris wrote:

Problem with your theory R-type is we do have the Doctor regenerating from Sylverster McCoy to Paul McGann.

Now it's true that David's doctor could be the 11th, 12th or 13th doctor, but Paul's is the 8th.

Sorry if I wasn't clear (it was typed fast). Yeah, we saw McCoy turn into McGann but I mean we didn't ever see McGann's 8th Doc regenerate into Christopher Eccleston. So there is room for a Doctor (or lots) in between McGann (Doctor eight) and Eccleston (generally assumed Doctor nine. ;)


Vigil wrote:
Matthew Morris wrote:

Problem with your theory R-type is we do have the Doctor regenerating from Sylverster McCoy to Paul McGann.

Now it's true that David's doctor could be the 11th, 12th or 13th doctor, but Paul's is the 8th.

I recall hearing somewhere that every twelfth regeneration is supposed to be an evil Doctor. Is that true? If it is, we can rule out David's Doctor as the 13th, since he's clearly not evil.

One weird rumour doing the rounds is that John Simm (who we last saw playing The Master) might be playing the new Doctor. I hope not.

Scarab Sages

R-type wrote:
Vigil wrote:
Matthew Morris wrote:

Problem with your theory R-type is we do have the Doctor regenerating from Sylverster McCoy to Paul McGann.

Now it's true that David's doctor could be the 11th, 12th or 13th doctor, but Paul's is the 8th.

I recall hearing somewhere that every twelfth regeneration is supposed to be an evil Doctor. Is that true? If it is, we can rule out David's Doctor as the 13th, since he's clearly not evil.

One weird rumour doing the rounds is that John Simm (who we last saw playing The Master) might be playing the new Doctor. I hope not.

Ya...that doesn't make much sense to me. I suppose if the regenerations are truly random then there's a chance that it could happen. on the other hand, i prefer to think that all the regenerations are encoded on their DNA, and so it wouldn't happen. i dunno...that's just me. i figure it's about the same as two identical people being born to two seperate genetic trees...

On a side note, I loved the way Simm played the master and I was unhappy he only got to do it for a couple of episodes.


There was once a rule where each Time Lord got only thirteen regens each, then there was an episode (80's) in which The Master was given another thirteen by the Council. New Who may have changed this or perhaps being 'the last Timelord' this no longer applies to The Doctor.


I would quite like to see Philip Glenister play the Doctor.

Scarab Sages

R-type wrote:
There was once a rule where each Time Lord got only thirteen regens each, then there was an episode (80's) in which The Master was given another thirteen by the Council. New Who may have changed this or perhaps being 'the last Timelord' this no longer applies to The Doctor.

Ya...i never really understood how the council had the authority to do that. i know he had an item or something that let him keep going (I think it was that ring, but it prolly wasn't and i might be imagining things), and i could see where maybe a highly advanced item could do it, but that's a like a judge in a court telling you that you get to restart life from infanthood...

edit: my bad, i was mistaking the item for his attempts with the harmony to get more. I could've sword he got more some other way where he could just keep going. the more i read, the more i suspect it's a psychological thing where the timelords believe thay only get 13, and if they believed they got more they'd have more. i might be wrong, but it's interesting to consider.


I think I recall the ring as well.

Hey, Russell Brand should be the new Doc, lol!

Sovereign Court

Philip Glenister is going to be too busy chasing vampires for ITV for the next couple of years..thats if the 'Van Helsing' show takes of

Scarab Sages

Eddie Izzard gets my vote. He's very funny and a great actor as well.


Ubermench wrote:
Eddie Izzard gets my vote. He's very funny and a great actor as well.

I'd go for that!

Scarab Sages

kessukoofah wrote:
R-type wrote:
There was once a rule where each Time Lord got only thirteen regens each, then there was an episode (80's) in which The Master was given another thirteen by the Council. New Who may have changed this or perhaps being 'the last Timelord' this no longer applies to The Doctor.

Ya...i never really understood how the council had the authority to do that. i know he had an item or something that let him keep going (I think it was that ring, but it prolly wasn't and i might be imagining things), and i could see where maybe a highly advanced item could do it, but that's a like a judge in a court telling you that you get to restart life from infanthood...

edit: my bad, i was mistaking the item for his attempts with the harmony to get more. I could've sword he got more some other way where he could just keep going. the more i read, the more i suspect it's a psychological thing where the timelords believe thay only get 13, and if they believed they got more they'd have more. i might be wrong, but it's interesting to consider.

It was covered in one of the books (I forget which one, sorry) the council of time lords imposed a limit on regenerations to control overpopulation of existing time lords and allow room for births of new time lords. I think it was a one for one trade, one death one birth


Ubermench wrote:
He's very funny and a great actor as well.

Something that you can't say about Russell Brand, or Matt Lucas, Jonathan Ross, or David Walliams.

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16

Ubermench wrote:
Eddie Izzard gets my vote. He's very funny and a great actor as well.

He is a great actor, and if he were less well-known, I think he'd do a fantastic job. I wouldn't want to see anyone starting out with his own fan base as the Doctor, though.

Scarab Sages

Ubermench wrote:
It was covered in one of the books (I forget which one, sorry) the council of time lords imposed a limit on regenerations to control overpopulation of existing time lords and allow room for births of new time lords. I think it was a one for one trade, one death one birth

Ok, but how would they have the power to do that? it would seem to imply that Time lords could just keep going as much as they want, and the only thing stopping them is a bunch of old guys going "nope. only 13". i dunno. seems odd to me. although i seem to recall that i read somewhere that the eye of harmony is tied to their regeneration somehow to keep everything in balance. if that was the case, then i could see it working.

Scarab Sages

ericthecleric wrote:
Something that you can't say about Russell Brand, or Matt Lucas, Jonathan Ross, or David Walliams.

Sorry I have know idea who they are.

Scarab Sages

kessukoofah wrote:
Ubermench wrote:
It was covered in one of the books (I forget which one, sorry) the council of time lords imposed a limit on regenerations to control overpopulation of existing time lords and allow room for births of new time lords. I think it was a one for one trade, one death one birth
Ok, but how would they have the power to do that? it would seem to imply that Time lords could just keep going as much as they want, and the only thing stopping them is a bunch of old guys going "nope. only 13". i dunno. seems odd to me. although i seem to recall that i read somewhere that the eye of harmony is tied to their regeneration somehow to keep everything in balance. if that was the case, then i could see it working.

The council of time lords have always been used as a "deus ex machina" for Dr. Who stories, so of course the explnation seems odd. Also the council has all the powers taken from Rassalon making them somewhat godlike.

Scarab Sages

Ubermench wrote:
..."deus ex machina"...

hehehe...I just pictutred the doctor flying around in the TARDIS, and it was funny, cuz he's god-like compared to people, and he's in a machine...anyhow.

ya. I can see how they'd have that much power i guess.

Scarab Sages RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

Well I don't really know who Paterson Joseph is (the front runner for the position at the moment), but if they're gonna have a black Doctor (which I think would be cool, a nice break from tradition), then my vote is for Colin Salmon.

EDIT: I wonder what they'll do once they hit the 13th Doctor? This Doctor (no mattter what his actaul number in the progression is) is number 11. That means only 2 more Doctors.

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 16, 2012 Top 32

I'd like to see Anthony Head (Giles from Buffy) as the next Doctor, though I wouldn't mind a few seasons of flashbacks to the Eighth Doctor fighting the Time War.

I'd also like to see the Doctor's daughter return as a permanent companion (especially if the older Anthony Head were cast as the Doctor). The interaction between her and the Doctor was great fun.


flash_cxxi wrote:

I wonder what they'll do once they hit the 13th Doctor? This Doctor (no mattter what his actaul number in the progression is) is number 11. That means only 2 more Doctors.

As others have said , as the last of the time lords all bets are off on his limit.

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 16, 2012 Top 32

flash_cxxi wrote:
Well I don't really know who Paterson Joseph is (the front runner for the position at the moment), but if they're gonna have a black Doctor (which I think would be cool, a nice break from tradition), then my vote is for Colin Salmon.

I don't know. I've always thought the Doctor's various incarnations should have a bit of a family resemblance to one another (and I wasn't a big fan of the Fifth Doctor as a result).

flash_cxxi wrote:
I wonder what they'll do once they hit the 13th Doctor?

That's a good question.

Also, do you remember the Valeyard? He was the evil Doctor from the possible future (sometime between the Twelfth and Thirteenth Doctors) who was plotting to take over the Doctor's final regeneration.

Liberty's Edge

They should get Ross Noble.

Paizo Employee Chief Technical Officer

kessukoofah wrote:
R-type wrote:
One weird rumour doing the rounds is that John Simm (who we last saw playing The Master) might be playing the new Doctor. I hope not.
Ya...that doesn't make much sense to me. I suppose if the regenerations are truly random then there's a chance that it could happen. on the other hand, i prefer to think that all the regenerations are encoded on their DNA, and so it wouldn't happen. i dunno...that's just me. i figure it's about the same as two identical people being born to two seperate genetic trees...

When Jon Pertwee (the third Doctor) and Roger Delgado (the first Master) decided to leave the show in 1973, a story called The Final Game was planned as the final episode for both actors. In it, it was to be revealed that the Master was actually an aspect of the Doctor's personality. Roger Delgado's death in an auto accident prevented that story from being completed.

Scarab Sages

Vic Wertz wrote:
kessukoofah wrote:
R-type wrote:
One weird rumour doing the rounds is that John Simm (who we last saw playing The Master) might be playing the new Doctor. I hope not.
Ya...that doesn't make much sense to me. I suppose if the regenerations are truly random then there's a chance that it could happen. on the other hand, i prefer to think that all the regenerations are encoded on their DNA, and so it wouldn't happen. i dunno...that's just me. i figure it's about the same as two identical people being born to two seperate genetic trees...
When Jon Pertwee (the third Doctor) and Roger Delgado (the first Master) decided to leave the show in 1973, a story called The Final Game was planned as the final episode for both actors. In it, it was to be revealed that the Master was actually an aspect of the Doctor's personality. Roger Delgado's death in an auto accident prevented that story from being completed.

Do you have any more about that? it sounds fairly interesting, and while i could possibly see how ti could work, i'd rather have outside confirmation. i mean, it's been shown he's not a figment of his imagination in his interactions with others, and the fact that he's regenerated tells us he's a seperate time lord. I'm just curious about how they had planned to explain it.

Paizo Employee Chief Technical Officer

kessukoofah wrote:
Vic Wertz wrote:
When Jon Pertwee (the third Doctor) and Roger Delgado (the first Master) decided to leave the show in 1973, a story called The Final Game was planned as the final episode for both actors. In it, it was to be revealed that the Master was actually an aspect of the Doctor's personality. Roger Delgado's death in an auto accident prevented that story from being completed.
Do you have any more about that? it sounds fairly interesting, and while i could possibly see how ti could work, i'd rather have outside confirmation. i mean, it's been shown he's not a figment of his imagination in his interactions with others, and the fact that he's regenerated tells us he's a seperate time lord. I'm just curious about how they had planned to explain it.

The info I've found on the net is pretty sparse, and spread across a bunch of websites. (Here's a pretty good google query...) There was some discussion of it in About Time 3 (mostly under the entry for Planet of the Spiders) and in About Time 4 (in the essay accompanying the Shada entry, "What Else Didn’t Get Made?"), but I don't recall if those include any info you can't find on the net. (I highly recommend the About Time series if you're interested in really in-depth information about classic Doctor Who stories—but you might want to wait for the upcoming 2nd Edition of About Time 3).


kessukoofah wrote:
R-type wrote:
Vigil wrote:
Matthew Morris wrote:

Problem with your theory R-type is we do have the Doctor regenerating from Sylverster McCoy to Paul McGann.

Now it's true that David's doctor could be the 11th, 12th or 13th doctor, but Paul's is the 8th.

I recall hearing somewhere that every twelfth regeneration is supposed to be an evil Doctor. Is that true? If it is, we can rule out David's Doctor as the 13th, since he's clearly not evil.

One weird rumour doing the rounds is that John Simm (who we last saw playing The Master) might be playing the new Doctor. I hope not.

Ya...that doesn't make much sense to me. I suppose if the regenerations are truly random then there's a chance that it could happen. on the other hand, i prefer to think that all the regenerations are encoded on their DNA, and so it wouldn't happen. i dunno...that's just me. i figure it's about the same as two identical people being born to two seperate genetic trees...

On a side note, I loved the way Simm played the master and I was unhappy he only got to do it for a couple of episodes.

Some time-lords can control the regeneration process, as was demonstrated when Romana regenerated (from Mary Tamm to Lalla Ward) in Destiny of the Daleks; she fancied looking like Princess Astra, from the end of the previous season, and so she ended up looking like her.

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 16, 2012 Top 32

Charles Evans 25 wrote:
Some time-lords can control the regeneration process, as was demonstrated when Romana regenerated... in Destiny of the Daleks; she fancied looking like Princess Astra... and so she ended up looking like her.

If you listen to his dialogue at the end of The Sound of Drums, you'll notice that the Master does the same thing. As he dies, the Master observes that the current Doctor is very youthful and declares that he can be youthful, too. At which point the regeneration process makes him exactly that.

Dark Archive

Though its unlikely I'd like to see Paul McGann as the Doctor again. The TV movie was dreck and as a result McGann never got a fair shake. He could've been a very good doctor. Though if the above posted rumour is true it'll be neat to see him even if it is in the form of Timewar flashbacks.

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16

Epic Meepo wrote:
If you listen to his dialogue at the end of The Sound of Drums, you'll notice that the Master does the same thing. As he dies, the Master observes that the current Doctor is very youthful and declares that he can be youthful, too. At which point the regeneration process makes him exactly that.

Recent episodes suggest that the Doctor's regenerative forms have more to do with his moods and demeanor. He was feeling all depressed after the Time War, and ended up a black-clad hoodlum. He fell in love with Rose, and became a much more upbeat, dapper, playful character.

Given his mood at the end of the fourth series, he'd probably come back as Patrick Stewart, playing a dour little monk.

Scarab Sages

R-type wrote:

I think I recall the ring as well.

Hey, Russell Brand should be the new Doc, lol!

Rather unlikely, given the current embarrasment he caused the BBC.

Spoiler:
Ringing up a 78-year-old well-loved actor, to brag about 'f~~+ing their grand-daughter', then compounding the insult by ringing back several more times, to 'apologise' (ie make it worse), joking in-between how this would crush the man's spirit.
Then presenting the tape of the incident to be broadcast to the nation.

Scarab Sages

Epic Meepo wrote:
I'd also like to see the Doctor's daughter return as a permanent companion...

Oh, God, no.

That episode was cringe-inducing, precisely for that character. A Mary-Sue of the worst kind.


Snorter wrote:
Epic Meepo wrote:
I'd also like to see the Doctor's daughter return as a permanent companion...

Oh, God, no.

That episode was cringe-inducing, precisely for that character. A Mary-Sue of the worst kind.

It might be interesting, but would depend on who wrote the scripts.

Edit:
Further thought: in the same way that Taggart* has carried on after Jim Taggart was gone, maybe they're exploring options for carrying on Doctor Who after the Doctor uses up his last regeneration and is gone.

*A police drama series set in Glasgow for those not familiar with UK television.


Snorter wrote:
R-type wrote:

I think I recall the ring as well.

Hey, Russell Brand should be the new Doc, lol!

Rather unlikely, given the current embarrasment he caused the BBC.

** spoiler omitted **

How about Jonathan Ross instead?! ;)

Scarab Sages

R-type wrote:
How about Jonathan Ross instead?! ;)

<head in hands>

"weep!"

Sovereign Court

We need someone edgy..a bit of a bastard after the love fest that was David Tennant

How about Mark Warren...


David Fryer wrote:
I would like to see David Oyelowo in the role. I really enjoyed his work on Spooks or MI-5 here in the states. I just feel that he would make an excellent replacement for Tennant. Tennant was the one who really sealed the deal for me on the new series. I always felt that Eccelston was too angsty to be the Doctor, although I have enjoyed his work on other projects.

Going with the spooks things. Miranda Raison, who plays joe in spooks would make a cool doctor.

Sovereign Court RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

How about Catherine Tate? ;-)

Dark Archive

Chris Mortika wrote:


Given his mood at the end of the fourth series, he'd probably come back as Patrick Stewart, playing a dour little monk.

As I understand it, Patrick Stewert is busy working on Eleventh Hour.

1 to 50 of 130 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Gamer Life / Entertainment / Television / David Tennant to quit as Doctor Who All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.