Who gets your one vote?

[Starglim]

If you only had one vote, where would it go?

[mythfish]

If I had only one vote, it would probably go to Yithnai. Or possibly Iskandria. Both are well-written, interesting, and give me plenty of adventure ideas.

[Erik Anderson]

Starglim wrote:

If you only had one vote, where would it go?

The Ghost Hounds of the Rolling Plains. Of course.

But if I had two votes, my second would go to The Enlightened Kingdom of Vramaire.

That being said, I found positive things about each and every entry into this round, and I'm honored to have my work next to them.

[Nem-Z]

With just one vote I'd go for the Freeholds.

[Swamp Druid]

Theocracy of Carnmach

I really loved this one.

[R D Ramsey]

[One vote would go to the Stained Peaks. That's as well-realized a society as I think you can encode in 1000 words.

And one the plus side, it's a great re-imagining of one of the hoariest fantasy cliches.

Easy choice, no doubt on my part at all on this one.

[lojakz]

Clouds Without Water wrote:

[One vote would go to the Stained Peaks. That's as well-realized a society as I think you can encode in 1000 words.

And one the plus side, it's a great re-imagining of one of the hoariest fantasy cliches.

Easy choice, no doubt on my part at all on this one.

I would actually agree whole heartedly with you. I was going to in fact just put The Stained Peaks... then saw you'd beat me to it, so... yes, I concur.

Thank the gods we have more than one vote.

[varianor]

Don't know if I can easily answer that question since my evaluation would have been different. (In fact, I might still be arguing with myself about it.) However, of the ones that stick in my mind easiest?

Carnamach.

[Matthew Morris]

Swamp Druid wrote:

Theocracy of Carnmach

I really loved this one.

Same here.

Ghost Hounds was close.

[Steven Helt]

If I had only one vote as a player, I would vote Iskandria (HM Boomer).

If I had only one vote as a DM, I would vote Vramaire (HM Yithnai).

If I had only one vote as a developer, I would vote Stained Peaks.

[William Cronk]

Stained Peaks.

[Liquidator Queeg]

As I wrote in the "Your Five" thread (I think that's it), I only cast one vote. Stained Peaks hands down. The original premise of the contest was just one vote, so I'm sticking with that for each of the rounds.

[Ernest Mueller]

I'd go with the Theocracy of Carnamach. Stained Peaks was in a tie for my 5th place; it was definitely good... Ghost Dog: Way Of The Barking, bah.

[Matrissa the Enchantress]

Ghost Hound Kinship of the Rolling Plains. No contest.

[Charles Evans 25]

If it was just one vote it would be a hard decision between Vramaire and Stained Peaks for me. I love the way that Stained Peaks is written, but I don't know if 1st level characters could survive adventuring in that environment for long. With all the political intrigues and the less lethal environment (unless you annoy the inquisition) in Vramaire, it seems to me that you have a lot more adventure potential for low level characters in that country.

[magdalena thiriet]

Had I just one vote...I think it would go for Theocracy of Carnamach. That one was just so freaky. Or maybe Iskandria.