
VerBeeker |
4 people marked this as a favorite. |

So what Minkai related stuff is detailed? I'm curious of Jade Regent aftermath

![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Why is this showing as "print edition unavailable"?
This often happens during the transition between the "preorder" period and the "street date release" period.
It should be back for purchase around the 24th.
![]() |
12 people marked this as a favorite. |

I saw this review! I cried a lot reading it, but it's very heartfelt, explore a LOT the dangers and omnipresence of "orientalism", and ultimately gives GREAT PRAISES for the book. :3
Lost Omens: Tian Xia World Guide Review on reddit

![]() |
5 people marked this as a favorite. |

I saw this review! I cried a lot reading it, but it's very heartfelt, explore a LOT the dangers and omnipresence of "orientalism", and ultimately gives GREAT PRAISES for the book. :3
Lost Omens: Tian Xia World Guide Review on reddit
Heartfelt thank you for sharing this.

LilyTrotter |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |
Massively needed and really appreciated, it was nice to see the aspects of my own culture in the book. Though I'm quite sad there were no parts of "boons & curses" for the gods. I know some were given in a supplement for Gods & Magic book but still. I hope they include them in the upcoming divine mysteries. I found it very fulfilling myself as a DM to bless my players who practiced their worship in my games, and it brought many of my players to act more in line with the world. Also questioning why population count was removed?

![]() |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |

Love the book! The pdf version seems a bit hefty at nearly 350 MB. It also doesn’t include the poster map currently. Any chance of a new download?

Clemperor |
4 people marked this as a favorite. |
Been reading through the book since I got it last night, really happy with the vast majority I've ready and skimmed over, been looking forward to this since the announcement.
I am a bit bothered that there's no settlement stat blocks for any of the locations, the stat blocks are something I found incredibly interesting and useful and gave a concise overview of a settlement. I hope we see them published somewhere else.
As LilyTrotter said, no Boons & Curses is a weird choice, Tian Xia citizens having small personal shrines to gods but no way of receiving benefits is another thing I'd love to see going forward, hopefully in Divine Mysteries. The new gods (Baekho, The Lady of the North Star, Mugura and Nrithu, Phi Deva, Srikalis, Sritaming, and Sribaril) all seem awesome and I can't wait to read their entries properly. PRONUNCIATION GUIDES are one of my absolutely favourite additions and something I'd been hoping for since the announcement. No more worrying that I've butchered a name.
The expansion on different belief systems and the introduction of Tests of Virtue is fantastic, I hope we see many more in the Character Guide.
All of the art is fantastic and everything I've read so far just screams that the authors knew and loved what they were writing about.
This has only increased my desire and need to get my hands on the Character Guide in August.

![]() |

Oh right I can buy this book finally :O
But yeah, I do have to say alignment being replaced with short descriptor can be really mouthful at time. Like "detail-oriented" both says a lot and not much without further context.
But yeah, realized that with the better less orientalist approach that means we likely don't have factions like Kusarigama which had weirdly random japanese word name for "training warriors for apocalyptic war" cult. I'm curious to see if they still exist in book or get renamed or just retconnect completely

![]() |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

Hmm oki, yeah, there are few things in minkai section that give me bit of headache in unexpecting ways, would have been nice to know before finishing running Jade Regent yeah x'D Nothing too unmanageable and it is cool to see writers doing something with npcs, but yeah definitely stuff I wasn't expecting them to do since lot of time paizo is pretty hands off with ap npcs post adventure.
(the thing that gives me headache is revelation that eldest daughter of npc from Jade Regent is advisor to Ameiko. Reason why this gives me headache that nothing implied in Jade Regent that said character has children or any family in general because they really seemed like loner x'D Guess it doesn't help that its sometimes hard to tell age of characters)

![]() |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

This book has helped me to realize my own biases: Additional reason I like alignment is that without it, I'm too optimistic/idealistic about all npcs unless text is explicit about their villainy :'D
Like, even with npcs who were evil in 1e sometimes in this book gives me pause where I'm like "sounds like they are misguided" :'D Its surprisingly hard for me to read npc as potential campaign villain without it being mentioned they are actively doing something tyrannical, violent, horrific or etc

![]() |
7 people marked this as a favorite. |

I'm naturally pacifistic and I have tendency to assume everyone is reasonable when that isn't the case :'D So easy for me to read everyone like "they are reasonable people you can convince with diplomacy check, no need to get violent at all or have villainous machinations" xD
But yeah, I don't think the nuance present is from removal of alignment specifically, but from interpretation of text without the alignment. Like, even previous PF2e books could write evil characters who didn't sound moustache swirling evil, but the presence of capital E made you think "ah, they have potential to be even worse". Removal of it means its hard to tell difference between "neutral antagonist" and "evil antagonist" without something to spell it out, so personal bias will come, and it turns out in my case that bias is "towards good" xD
(tldr: paizo writing often has more nuance that people give it credit for and its still present here)

TheBardicOne |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

Any updates on the seemingly excessively large file size on the PDF? I've been holding off on downloading hoping it will be reigned in a bit. Seems to be happening more and more often where we end up with 300+MB PDFs.

![]() |
6 people marked this as a favorite. |

IS there any reason specifically that they didn't do settlement stat blocks in this? Is that a remaster thing?
I think the pronounciation guides took their places in the sidebars. And really, they were needed a lot. I don't know a lot of people that know how to read romanizations of many of the Asian languages. I know how to read the Japanese-inspired names, but it helped me a LOT with all the other ones (the only one I have been able to memorize before was the "C" in the name of some Chinese people, like in Cao Cao, that is actually closer to "ts-" than "k-".) I'm still working hard to learn the others, but until then, it's been VERY helpful. (TBF, I have trouble with prnounciations with my first language too, and English too sometimes... AND TBF, pronounciation guides have been asked A LOT in general for Pathfinder books.)
It's also one of the biggest continent they have treated with a book yet (Casmaron being bigger, but unpublished yet), and there would have been a LOT of settlements.
They definitely had a bunch of very hard choices to make to fit the page count.

Leliel the 12th |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
So, I'm reading, and...
Is it saying something about me that a complete backstory for a Tianjinese mad scientist came into being? One who started as a benign abbot but upon experiencing the horror of the qlippoth directly was traumatized into this line of logic:
"Qlippoth are the worst thing in the world. When demons were created by polluting the Outer Rifts with sin, they turned the qlippoth from a cosmic-scale threat to dire one fighting for their own existence. Demons are better than qlippoth by default, ergo their creation was the benign will of the universe, and mortal sin can more easily fight alien evil directly. The seals are failing, and the idiots in charge refuse to notice. Ergo, learn to summon demons and engineer the creation of an army of demonblood cambions into being to serve as the ultimate line of defense for Tianjing and the world."
Had it that he's still an extremely pleasant, spiritual individual who is very empathetic and forgiving of darker emotions...he just sees more purpose in weaponizing those emotions, and what care he has for his "children" also comes with the suffocating expectation that they are his super soldiers - not his children.
Hell, he could even have found some Valashai tech caches earlier in his life to grow some clones and do Fun Things With Genetics, it's not incredibly far away.

VerBeeker |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |

KaiBlob1 wrote:IS there any reason specifically that they didn't do settlement stat blocks in this? Is that a remaster thing?I think the pronounciation guides took their places in the sidebars. And really, they were needed a lot. I don't know a lot of people that know how to read romanizations of many of the Asian languages. I know how to read the Japanese-inspired names, but it helped me a LOT with all the other ones (the only one I have been able to memorize before was the "C" in the name of some Chinese people, like in Cao Cao, that is actually closer to "ts-" than "k-".) I'm still working hard to learn the others, but until then, it's been VERY helpful. (TBF, I have trouble with prnounciations with my first language too, and English too sometimes... AND TBF, pronounciation guides have been asked A LOT in general for Pathfinder books.)
It's also one of the biggest continent they have treated with a book yet (Casmaron being bigger, but unpublished yet), and there would have been a LOT of settlements.
They definitely had a bunch of very hard choices to make to fit the page count.
I mean I personally would have been fine with a number for the populations listed next to the capitals.

Perses13 |
4 people marked this as a favorite. |

IS there any reason specifically that they didn't do settlement stat blocks in this? Is that a remaster thing?
The Lost Omens World Guide didn't have settlement stat blocks either, so there's some precedent.

![]() |
7 people marked this as a favorite. |

Elfteiroh wrote:I mean I personally would have been fine with a number for the populations listed next to the capitals.KaiBlob1 wrote:IS there any reason specifically that they didn't do settlement stat blocks in this? Is that a remaster thing?I think the pronounciation guides took their places in the sidebars. And really, they were needed a lot. I don't know a lot of people that know how to read romanizations of many of the Asian languages. I know how to read the Japanese-inspired names, but it helped me a LOT with all the other ones (the only one I have been able to memorize before was the "C" in the name of some Chinese people, like in Cao Cao, that is actually closer to "ts-" than "k-".) I'm still working hard to learn the others, but until then, it's been VERY helpful. (TBF, I have trouble with prnounciations with my first language too, and English too sometimes... AND TBF, pronounciation guides have been asked A LOT in general for Pathfinder books.)
It's also one of the biggest continent they have treated with a book yet (Casmaron being bigger, but unpublished yet), and there would have been a LOT of settlements.
They definitely had a bunch of very hard choices to make to fit the page count.
Personally, I feel like population numbers are specifically a "trap". They will probably ALWAYS feel wrong for someone, and I'm not sure they are THAT useful in play. I personally rarely look at them, because as soon as they get higher than 3 numbers, I can't really understand what it means. xD

Leliel the 12th |
VerBeeker wrote:Elfteiroh wrote:I mean I personally would have been fine with a number for the populations listed next to the capitals.KaiBlob1 wrote:IS there any reason specifically that they didn't do settlement stat blocks in this? Is that a remaster thing?I think the pronounciation guides took their places in the sidebars. And really, they were needed a lot. I don't know a lot of people that know how to read romanizations of many of the Asian languages. I know how to read the Japanese-inspired names, but it helped me a LOT with all the other ones (the only one I have been able to memorize before was the "C" in the name of some Chinese people, like in Cao Cao, that is actually closer to "ts-" than "k-".) I'm still working hard to learn the others, but until then, it's been VERY helpful. (TBF, I have trouble with prnounciations with my first language too, and English too sometimes... AND TBF, pronounciation guides have been asked A LOT in general for Pathfinder books.)
It's also one of the biggest continent they have treated with a book yet (Casmaron being bigger, but unpublished yet), and there would have been a LOT of settlements.
They definitely had a bunch of very hard choices to make to fit the page count.
Yeah, that's my feeling too. Population numbers never make sense for various reasons. I'd rather have pronunciations than that.
Personally, I feel like population numbers are specifically a "trap". They will probably ALWAYS feel wrong for someone, and I'm not sure they are THAT useful in play. I personally rarely look at them, because as soon as they get higher than 3 numbers, I can't really understand what it means. xD

VerBeeker |

I'd rather see percentages of population makeup instead of total numbers.
That too! Honestly, I’d prefer that if not a combo!
Like look at Songbai, I know there is tensions amongst the majorities and minority populations but how vast of a split in population between the new majority and the original natives is there?

Davelozzi |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Populations numbers are super useful to me in understanding a settlement/nation. I understand they are not always realistic to everyone, but it's great to have a good place to start. Lost Omens World Guide at least had them for the capitals of each country.
That said, if anyone is looking for population figures for the settlements of Tian Xia, they are available Dragon Empires Gazetteer (and the populations for capitals only in the Dragon Empires Primer), both for PF1 (even if those sources are otherwise not up to the standards of the new book).

VerBeeker |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |

Populations numbers are super useful to me in understanding a settlement/nation. I understand they are not always realistic to everyone, but it's great to have a good place to start. Lost Omens World Guide at least had them for the capitals of each country.
That said, if anyone is looking for population figures for the settlements of Tian Xia, they are available Dragon Empires Gazetteer (and the populations for capitals only in the Dragon Empires Primer), both for PF1 (even if those sources are otherwise not up to the standards of the new book).
So did the Mwangi Expanse and Impossible Kingdom Books, that all I’m really looking for, though as I agreed with above a population breakdown would also have been pretty helpful.

keftiu |

VerBeeker |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |

Finished reading it last night, overall a great book, some locales stood out to me more than others, but altogether I’d heavily suggest getting your hands on this one.
I would like to see another one down the line if they ever chose to break this continent up into sections like they did the Inner Sea, because I can see some clear region-divisions that could be created.

![]() |

For anyone that has the PDF, does this have the same quality compression issues that Rage of Elements has which makes the images real low quality?
Nope, the opposite, it's very very big. xD 300ish MB

drakkonflye |
7 people marked this as a favorite. |

I saw this review! I cried a lot reading it, but it's very heartfelt, explore a LOT the dangers and omnipresence of "orientalism", and ultimately gives GREAT PRAISES for the book. :3
Lost Omens: Tian Xia World Guide Review on reddit
Just read through this myself and it really hurts that the author had to endure such b~@%%*#*. Like I said there, *I* would have let him play his druid and if anyone else said anything, THEY could play the damn monk or take a walk. I don't tolerate racist bull at my tables, and if I ever say anything that might offend, I encourage my players to tell me and I will strive to not do it again.
As for me, I have Amerindian ancestry on my father's side, so I am hoping when Paizo does a full exploration of Arcadia, they can give as much respect to that heritage as they have for Mwangi Expanse and Tian Xia
Ishmael Constantyne |

After all that they went through in Sandpoint, I know Ishmael, Parthenia and Aliexabeth cannot wait for their ship to dock.
Ishmael has to rustle up some new and old contracts for his Herbalism side hustle.
Parthenia is off to the first or second or third temple to see what is new in the world of monkishness.
Aliexbeth just wants to find a temple park and let the peace flow back into her.
Who knows, they may event run into Rork, the Gentleman Giant.