Pathfinder Society Intro #1: The Second Confirmation

3.20/5 (based on 5 ratings)

Our Price: $5.99

Add to Cart
Facebook Twitter Email

A Pathfinder Society Scenario designed for levels 1-2.

A Pathfinder Society initiate goes missing on their Confirmation mission to become a fully-fledged field agent. With no update on the initiate’s whereabouts, the Society assembles a group of initiates into a rare group Confirmation in order to spearhead a rescue. It’s up to a new generation of heroes to save one of their own, and potentially make a few big discoveries along the way!

Written by Thurston Hillman

Scenario tags: Repeatable

[Scenario Maps spoiler - click to reveal]

The following maps used in this scenario are also available for purchase here on paizo.com:

  • Pathfinder Flip-Mat Classics: Ancient Dungeon
  • Pathfinder Flip-Mat Classics: Swamp
  • Other Resources: This product is also available on the following platforms:

    Fantasy Grounds Virtual Tabletop

    Note: This product is part of the Pathfinder Society Scenario Subscription.

    Product Availability

    Fulfilled immediately.

    Are there errors or omissions in this product information? Got corrections? Let us know at store@paizo.com.

    PZOPFS9901E


    See Also:



    Average product rating:

    3.20/5 (based on 5 ratings)

    Sign in to create or edit a product review.

    Standard Dungeons and Dragons

    3/5

    Confirmation is a mix of investigation followed by a dungeon crawl.

    The best part about Confirmation is the main NPC, Rains. He is cute, unwise, and can add fun to the party.

    Paizo needs to understand what make a good renewable story. It’s not about changing monsters necessarily, it’s about subtle changes to the story, or what needs to be done.

    ”Examples”:

    For example, at the end, the runes were resolved with Thievery. But what if they weren’t runes, what if they were faces engraved into the column and we needed to talk to it? What if we needed to fix the column with Crafting to stop it from malfunctioning? What if approaching the column causes the dungeon to collapse and we just needed to escape? You see, that’s an interesting change. Changing a ball python to a giant frog isn’t a meaningful change.

    The main problem I have with this scenario is that there is no theme around the encounters. It's just random creatures, thrown together. I really dislike this. The repeatable nature of this scenario doesn’t add anything for the player and makes it more inconvenient to prepare for the GM, adding word count where it's unneeded.

    ”I tried to fix this by”:
    I tried to make it an elemental theme (because of the summoning runes), by picking the Living Boulder, Mudwretch, and Snapping Flytrap. None of the other “themes” made any sense.

    The Necrophidius should not have been included as a summons, it’s a construct.

    There was also some redundancy that added to the word count.

    Spoiler:

    The stat block of the ANCIENT SUMMONING RUNE didn’t need to be added again and again.

    One last comment. If you want your scenario to be found, put it in a season. For months I missed this one because it’s at the bottom of the main page, uncategorized. Or perhaps put it in both a season and at the bottom of the main page, like you do with other introduction scenarios.

    Overall: An OK scenario with a cute NPC. (7/10).


    A Solid Introduction

    4/5

    I ran this module twice in a Play-By-Post format and had great success with it. It introduces what the average Pathfinder experience will be like. There's a small bit of gold management, downtime investigation, careful use of exploration mode, traps, and - of course - encounters.

    The hazards feel very fair and there are plenty of opportunities for players to anticipate and counteract them. The encounters introduce some interesting elements to combat that can be interesting for players new to PF2. If there's a weak point, it's just that The Second Confirmation does what it says on the tin incredibly well. It's an introduction - one with a lovely and fun NPC - but it feels like a very curated experience. Very color in the lines. It's not bad, and I actually recommend this to anyone trying out PFS for the first time. If you're a GM looking for a one shot game around your home table, there are much more exciting modules to try.


    Reminds me of 2-18 in a good way

    5/5

    It has a likeable protagonist, good RP and enemy variety, exploration, and it's repeatable. A good way to start for new players imo.


    Good intro scenario. Does exactly as advertised.

    3/5

    (I GMed this.)

    First of all, I must say that I don't agree with the reviewer below me. None of the enemies are scripted to start next to the players and all of the traps have Perception DCs. I think Kurald Galain's experience won't be the experience most people will have.

    Other than that, it's a nice scenario. Nothing mind-blowing, but there's a nice variety of enemies, and the NPCs are fun to interact with.

    No real complaints, other than that the adventure feels rather mediocre. Nothing wrong with that, just that in the end, it's not very memorable.


    Lethal "gotcha" situations

    1/5

    For an introductory adventure, this has serious issues with lethality, and with how suddenly it springs this lethality on the players before they can do anything. It's like those old adventure games, where every room has surprises that kill you; but at least in adventure games you can reload.

    One encounter has enemies that cannot be spotted (no roll allowed for that) and appear right next to the front character. If they win initiative, you'll be down before you can act. Another has an invisible trap (again, no roll to notice it) that will likely drop you before you can respond. In both cases, an unlucky crit may kill you before your first turn.

    I'm sure this is par for the course for experienced players and higher-level scenarios, but as an intro this is a serious letdown, and likely to chase away new players with "ha-ha, you're dead and you couldn't even do anything".


    Paizo Employee Organized Play Associate

    1 person marked this as a favorite.

    Announced for August! Cover and product description are not final and are subject to change.

    Wayfinders Contributor

    A new Confirmation, this one written by Thurston Hillman?

    SQUEEEEEEEEE!


    Very interesting.

    Dark Archive

    1 person marked this as a favorite.

    Sounds great, new initiatives going out to save one of their own!

    P.S. A few typos in the description. "Spreadhead" should likely be "spearhead" and "save on of..." should probably say "save one of..."


    This doesn't specify which edition it is for - is it safe to assume ALL new products are 2e? It would nice if they were labelled that way.

    Grand Lodge

    4 people marked this as a favorite.
    Pathfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Adventure Path Subscriber
    Khouri P. wrote:
    This doesn't specify which edition it is for - is it safe to assume ALL new products are 2e? It would nice if they were labelled that way.

    I think it is pretty safe to assume that all new products are 2E unless labeled otherwise.

    Hmm

    Paizo Employee Organized Play Associate

    Cover and map list updated.

    Sczarni

    2 people marked this as a favorite.
    Khouri P. wrote:
    This doesn't specify which edition it is for - is it safe to assume ALL new products are 2e? It would nice if they were labelled that way.

    In a Blog some time ago (as in, Pre-Covid) they announced there would be no more 1E content being published.

    Grand Lodge

    The chronicle references an addition reward for completing the adventure but it is not listed on the Boon page. Where do we find the details/stats for it?


    There was an announcement in the Events Discord that the boon will become available later as they are working on an issue they had with it.


    A question about the monsters in the final combat:

    GM eyes only:
    The Ancient Summoning Rune says following:
    "The trap summons one of the creatures previously encountered from area B with the weak adjustment."

    Since the base monsters have different CLs, is the summoning list:
    weak ghoul/weak weak living boulder/weak sun-scorched shadow drake (CL 0) OR
    ghoul/weak living boulder/sun-scorched shadow drake (CL 1)?


    Pathfinder Adventure, Adventure Path, Rulebook Subscriber

    I got this as part of my subscription, looks like a cool module! But trying to find it myself on the Paizo website? Impossible. I think this is not categorized correctly.


    I will spend some of this weekend reading this.


    I asked this in the GM thread as well, but is there supposed to be a section on bribing people with gold for information? The scenario hints at gold being used to loosen tongues, but there's no explicit (or implicit, even) rules for it.

    Also, I agree with stese, finding this on the website is horrible.


    Khouri P. wrote:
    This doesn't specify which edition it is for - is it safe to assume ALL new products are 2e? It would nice if they were labelled that way.

    "SECOND EDITION" is on the top right corner of the 2E products


    Hmm wrote:
    Khouri P. wrote:
    This doesn't specify which edition it is for - is it safe to assume ALL new products are 2e? It would nice if they were labelled that way.

    I think it is pretty safe to assume that all new products are 2E unless labeled otherwise.

    Hmm

    "SECOND EDITION" is on the top right corner of 2E products

    Grand Lodge

    2 people marked this as a favorite.

    Just putting this here for myself and others that may be interested in running these all in a mini-arc after Intro #1.

    PFS Intro #2: United in Purpose.
    Bounty #13: The Blackwood Abundance.
    Bounty #14: The Blackwood Truce.

    Community / Forums / Paizo / Product Discussion / Pathfinder Society Intro #1: The Second Confirmation All Messageboards

    Want to post a reply? Sign in.