Zoomba's page

Have both played (high tier) and run (low tier) this scenario.

First, the good. This scenario has a decent mix of both combat and roleplaying opportunities. The settings for both main encounters are interesting, and my party and my players both enjoyed interacting with the festival and the villagers. There is also a real sense of mystery hanging over the adventure that gets the players motivated to try and piece together every clue.

Unfortunately, since this is Part 1, no satisfying answers can be found. While the overall plot in this duo of scenarios is quite interesting, most of it is beyond the player's ability to discover and lacking that knowledge means that the adventure abruptly ends on an unsatisfying cliffhanger rather than a compelling revelation or twist. The result is that the Pathfinders mostly just go to various places, do things, have some of their efforts box texted away, and then realize the scenario is suddenly over. Even multi-parters shouldn't have players confused as to most of what is happening.

The Lost Legacy also runs incredibly short, with essentially three setpieces, though one of them in particular can become much more involved if the players are interested in roleplaying it to its fullest. The infamous combat mentioned in several other reviews is quite deadly: even following printed tactics and unbalanced or simply unlucky party could easily get multiple casualties if GMs don't recognize when to softball some of their options.

I'd also like to echo a below poster regarding the formatting. Some of the scenario, particuarly Act 2, is layed out in a very unintuitive way that results in a lot of wasted time flipping back and forth trying to find the page needed information is on.

(I'll write a review of Part 2 soon. Short version: the follow up is better, but this is still a lesser multi-parter)

GM'd this on low tier and played on high tier.

As a season opener this scenario is a bit odd, touching not at all on the ongoing Aspis war (though definitely including the unexpectedly-prevalent occult subtheme). Beyond that however, this is a fun and innovative 1-5 scenario that I would be happy to run again.

Divided roughly into two halves, I appreciate how the first section of the scenario allows for options. While in many ways the general structure is a series of 'fetch quests', it's easy enough to have a choice in which encounters to experience and there are enough differences between them to make those choices matter. (Between being a player and behind the screen I experienced all of them).

Still, if the first half is a solid execution of a standard scenario, the second half is where Between the Lines shines. The setting our Pathfinders find themselves in is incredibly unique, which in turn leads to very unexpected encounters for a low level party. I was initially apprehensive about how the roleplaying in this half would go (as much of it is done in a limited if creative manner), but my players managed to really get into the spirit of it and communicated quite well with their target. Most delightful to me however, was that this scenario also does an excellent job in fleshing out the Venture Captain giving you your assignment. Given how much players eye-roll at the obstruction and ineptness of their V.C.s, I appreciated how much one of them is humanized here, and look forward to seeing Wulessa Yuul again.

It's not perfect: the first act is fine but standard, and the final encounter is a bit underwhelming, especially considering how much the scenario wants to make even risking facing it a meaningful choice. But overlooking a few flaws, this is a fun and engaging scenario with a epic feel that many low-tier scenarios never quite reach.

GM'd this on the low tier, with a 4 person party.

A fairly combat-heavy scenario, but one based around an interesting location and set-up. Plus, in addition to a good situation for roleplay at the start, the scenario includes multiple encounters where good negotiations and RP can alter the nature of the fights, a nice touch that could lead some parties to have markedly different experiences at points.

Still, the primary focus of Ironbound Schism is fighting giants, and on that front the adventure does not disappoint. The combats can be both long and deadly (we had one death, and a second PC be a single round away from the Great Beyond when the final monster went down) but the scale of the locations and the good use of iconic foes let strong tactics be rewarded even as tough opponents can punish reckless choices. The encounters are tense and the last encounter contains a creature who was a true beast, but it's a fair set-up for a 7-11.

There were two things that I felt could have used a bit more work. First, while the influence mechanic was fine, its payoff is something my PCs were more frustrated by than satisfied with.

Much more annoying from a scenario deisgn standpoint was the last 'encounter'.

This scenario is not the most original thing PF has ever done, but its a good romp against giants and a simple concept executed (mostly) well.

GM'd this for a party of 4 in the low tier (Rogue 8, Monk 6, Paladin 6, Brawler 5?) Would be 1 1/2 stars if possible, but 1 star since its not.

I really like the idea of a social-infiltration mission. And parts of it work: the opening exploration of a smuggling expedition was nice and the multiple avenues of 'assault' for the final act feint at a sandboxy -style experience. The problem comes down to the execution of the Bronze House and the final encounter however which sadly needed another pass or two.

In short, while I would like the see more of this type of scenario in the future, I hope we don't get one again until Paizo does a lot of development work to make sure it runs smooth. Conceptually its a nice change from the norm, but between the massively long run-time, very specialized character expectations, and a situation that seems designed to trick players into getting a debilitating punishment I cannot recommend Bronze House unless you have few other options.

Having played and GM'd this, School of Spirits has quickly vaulted its way towards being one of my favorite low-tier scenarios Paizo has ever put out.

Steeping in excellent flavor and interesting encounters, this scenario offers an intriguing story mixed with great opportunities for role-play. It also introduces two NPCs so well-drawn I immediately started wondering when we might see them again. It does a nice job of incorporating the 'cool new toy' that is Occult Adventures while making it a perfectly organic aspect of the plot. The encounters are surprisingly varied too, and admirably allow for multiple approaches in how a party wishes to handle them.

The faction element within is also now exactly how I hope such things are handled going forward: extremely relevant to Liberty's Edge players, containing surprising revelations to Pathfinders of other stripes, and resulting in players making an important choice regarding their chosen faction's future.

The faction aspect and the sequel-y nature of this scenario prevent it from being a perfect introductory mission for brand new Pathfinders or players. But for everyone else, this is a new classic, and one I expect to run happily for years to come.

GM'd this at the 7-8 tier. 4-player adjustment.

As many of the reviews below go into at far greater length than I feel like, the plot for this is...questionable at best. There's a heavy over-use of red herrings here, and even reading the scenario and thus knowing everything going on, the villain's scheme is full of tenuous assumptions and leaps of logic. My players, even at the end seemed to only partially understand why the enemies were doing what they were doing, and the player who most seemed to get it mostly did so because he had just prepped to GM the 'prequel' to this (Darkest Vengeance).

But zooming in from the macro view of this scenario, the individual encounters here are also just hit or miss. The theater was a solid start (with a player groaningly expecting a haunt the moment he found out about a ghost in Ustalav), but led them to immediately want to search the entire sewer complex. This is a reasonable plan for a team of highly trained pathfinders, but as the scenario doesn't allow for such apparently unpredictably creative thinking, their only choices were to faff about for a few hours or get back on the very visible rails of the scenario.

The rest of Abduction's encounters are fine, but after the third 'your REAL clue is in another castle' they seemed jsut resigned to do what the adventure wanted to get to the end. The swamp encounter was an interesting idea for a multi-choice resolution, but as my players were not murder-hobos, they never considered fighting the swamper (and thus avoided the likely best outcome simply by listening to their briefing orders). The creatures in the house itself at the end could have been quite dangerous, if one of the players wasn't an aasimar (not entirely the scenario's fault, but the main villains' gimmick is certainly goes from awesome to useless depending on whether a single ability's present.

All in all, its not the worst scenario I've ever played (and the Scarab Sages boon is quite nice, with a fitting mission), but its certainly the worst I've GMed.

I will second whoever mentionned GMs should read, re-read, then read again the Blog post on darkness

Played this this weekend as low tier. 4 characters present, three at level 2 and one level 4 playing down.

Compared to the other two parts in this series it's a dungeon delve, but the setup is nice and the location pretty interesting. Plus, mark this down as another adventure where we really felt like PATHFINDERS instead of murder-hobos. Exploring a site, noting its features, trying to come to terms with locals: all of these things are what more scenarios should feel like.

In our table, the adventure did run a bit on the short side, and it seemed a bit lighter on the challenge than other recent scenarios. That said, two other tables running it that day both ran longer, with one nearly wiping; there's enough variety in how parties can deal with the ruins that I can see a lot of variance here.

Coming as the end of this season's first multi-parter (4 if you count a certain other Garundi scenario being related), this did a solid job at serving as a capper to the arc. It's not quite as fun to play as parts 1 and 2, but The Golden Guardian is an interesting tweak on the dungeon-crawl scenario, and a fitting end to this story.

Also, I loved how this scenario incorporated previous chronicles. A+ Paizo. Hope you continue to explore things like this in the future.

I died during the first combat of this adventure (admittedly playing up). Two more of our six-man party died at the end and the rest fled to avoid a TPK. The combats here can be brutal for those unprepared or reckless.

And yet I'm still giving this 5 stars.

Cultist's Kiss is a spectacular scenario, with a whole town to roleplay through and an investigation broad yet interesting enough that it was two hours before an initiative check was rolled. The story set up here is top notch, with a plot and set of cult mysteries that hold up remarkably well.

As mentionned, the fights can be HARD, but they didn't feel unfair. A few startegic blunders on our part led to some casualties but the enemies are interesting and create some great tactical challenges.

This adventure can and likely will definitely run long (we were at 4 1/2 hours when it became clear we wouldn't survivie if we kept pushing forward) but if you have the time and are looking for a fun challenge then this is a spectacular choice.

A nice dungeon delve in Tian. While I (both in and out of character) was not especially versed in the backstory/current politics of either Tian Xia or the Way of the Kirin, the adventure set up the plot and goals quite well, and left me with both a clear idea of what was going on HERE, as well as intrigued to see follow ups with this plot in the future.

The scenario as a whole is primarily a dungeon delve into a sunken tower. Roleplaying opportunites were relatively limited, with one notable exception being a tower denzien we had great fun trying to come to terms with. The location itself was also well drawn and mapped, with enough structural details that kept us thinking things could go horribly wrong in a hurry.

The combats were quite fun, with the first being fairly easy and pedestrian but all the rest a cleverly designed change of pace from the norm. Nothing beats the final fight however, which had us yelling "What?" when a creature appears, then "WHAT?" when we realized what it was.

One thing I did not like however, is this scenario's new overland travel rules. It's a minor part of the scenario, and I appreciate the effort to minimize the 'make a bunch of checks over and over' way of showing a journey, but I think this went a bit too far in the other direction.

Overall, still a very solid dungeon dive, and a fun 7-11 that doesn't run overly long.

Review based on the 7-8 tier, with 5 players

An excellent jaunt in the jungle resulting in one of the best low-level adventures I've played in a while. Plenty of solid role-playing opportunities between the feckless count, gruff baron, and, unexpectedly, some of the wildlife.

I particuarly appreciated the encounter variety here. We got to test our skills in a low-stakes, semi-roleplay hunt, a campsite encounter was open-eneded enough to give us plenty of options, and one shining late combat had an interesting starting twist on top of spotlighting a rarely-used creature. Only the final fight seemed mildly underwhelming, but it's possible that this was due to something we had accomplished earlier in the scenario (and it was a nice surprise to see that come back in our favor)

Review based on the 4-5 tier, with 4 players.