Overall, I liked the Compendium. I would have made some choices differently, but probably every reader would've.I was saddened to see Tesseracts included though as I've long held that was the biggest waste of space EVER in a dragon magazine (and that's saying a lot). One request for specific content - can we do reprinting of some of the older comics like Phil & Dixie, and Fineous Fingers?
I would've liked to see this in a 3-ring binder format so I could take out all DM/GM Advice from all Compendium(s) and photocopy them for inclusion in my campaign journal.
Now if you do five of these I'm back to needing an index to remember which compendium contained that great article on World Creation, etc. Or if I just wanted those FR-specific content I could just copy those. Now it's hard to do that unless each compendium came with a CD containing the content in PDF format.
Mostly, this was just like a chance to reminisce through some favorite (and not so favorite) content of issues gone by.
Bruce