Artillery_MKV's page

RPG Superstar 6 Season Star Voter. 6 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists.


RSS

Star Voter Season 6

In the event I make it through I used the wiki for my rough draft and will use the pdf for polish. ;-)

Star Voter Season 6

Anthony Adam wrote:
GM_Solspiral wrote:
Eric Morton wrote:

I'm much more nervous this year than I was in any previous year. In previous years, I just had to worry about my own item not making it. This year, I also have to worry about all of the other items I like not making it.

Because, let's face it. If none of my favorites make the Top 32, what's the point in trying again next year? The rejection of my favorites would demonstrate that my own idea of a Superstar item is at odds with the judges' idea of a Superstar item, so my previous Round 1 success was achieved despite my item design skills, not because of them.

Wow, yeah didn't even think about that!
But then again, would that not be something you have learnt and can then work on for next year? Come on, positive now.

Part of freelance writing (which is what this really is) is writing for your customer's wants. Once you're well established then you can try to draw customers into your zone. The greatest comic artists almost all started in a bullpen, drawing the staples, but it was their unique takes on those staples that brought them outside success. The same is true for freelance writing for niche products.

Keep heart, learn from what wins and consider how you and your favorites could have made those ideas better.

Star Voter Season 6

Fingers crossed (eek! Never saw my item . . .), and good luck to all! I look forward to pinching the best of the top 32 for my campaign! :-P

The creativity I've seen was great, if sometimes not tempered by the wisdom of my great age (Hey! I'm young in Dragon years!), but I LOVE the obviius enthusiasm for a hobby that has given me countless hours of joy since I was but a wee dice slinger.

Skol!

Star Voter Season 6

I would simply suggest that you take your item and compare it to one of the top 32 it mostly closely resembles and see where it differs. Then ask yourself how you could have sharpened your entry.

Star Voter Season 6

1 person marked this as a favorite.

My criteria: Is this something that anyone would reasonably want/need to make? So I voted for a lot of utility items that would make an adventurer's life better.

Star Voter Season 6

I, also have the 'never saw my item' dreads, and I voted a LOT. There were several I saw over and over again, but just as I would despair, fresh new items would appear. I saw a lot I liked, many I would never allow at my table and some with good ideas and poor execution. I'm sure the judges have a tough job ahead of them!