My Self |
Would any of these be balanced Bard archetypes?
Basically:
1st: (Replaces Spellcasting) Replace spells with Alchemy, keyed off of CHA instead of INT.
2nd: (Replaces Well-Versed) Get Brew Potion, and let Craft (Alchemy) use CHA instead of INT. (Replaces Versatile Performance) Get an Alchemist Discovery.
6th: Get an Alchemist Discovery.
10th: (Replaces Jack of All Trades) Get Poison Resistance equal to 1/2 level. Get an Alchemist Discovery.
14th: Get an Alchemist Discovery.
18th: Get an Alchemist Discovery.
20th: Get Poison Immunity.
Second archetype-ish thing:
Basically:
1st: (Alters Bardic Performance) Bardic Performance has CHA+1/2 level uses, but can be sustained for up to 1 minute per use (instead of 1 round). Casting spells or starting other performances during a performance pause the effects of the first performance and count towards its duration, but allow the performer to finish the first performance without spending additional uses.
Third archetype-ish thing:
Basically:
1st: (Alters Bardic Performance, Spellcasting) 6+CHA rounds of Bardic Performance at 1st level. Lots of casting changes listed above.
20th: Can cast 6th level spells every round while performing.
Amanuensis RPG Superstar 2015 Top 8 |
1) I have trouble imagining an alchemical bard flavor-wise. Why wouldn't I play an alchemist instead?
I guess I can see a medicine man who uses a mix of drugs and performances to put himself into trance. That would work better as an alchemist archetype though.
2) I think that is unnecessary, any mid-level bard has enough rounds of performance to last throughout an adventuring day without being stingy. If that is not enough for some reason, Lingering Performance also helps a bard to make his bardic performance last longer. By the way, casting a spell does not disrupt a performance.
3) I'm not sure if I understand this correctly. Does the spell's casting time increase to 2 or 3 rounds? Or can I cast these spells after a certain amount of time spent performing for free?
Anyway, I think a better way to implement the concept of a casting-focused bard is to introduce more Bardic Masterpieces which often mimic spell effects. That way, you can use rounds of performance for spell-casting and you have a bigger selection of spells at the same time.
My Self |
For #2, the idea is that any bard of any level gains a good number of uses of each thing without having to micromanage a number of rounds. Perhaps the language about spells should be dropped, but the idea is that once you start a performance with a duration, you can use that performance any time during the duration.
Example:
Round 1: Starts Inspire Courage
Round 2: Starts Dirge of Doom
Round 3: Starts Fascinate
Rounds 4-10: Can continue Inspire Courage, Dirge of Doom, or Fascinate
Round 11: Can continue Dirge of Doom or Fascinate
Rounds 12: Can continue Fascinate
For #3, you declare that you are going to cast a spell of a certain level or lower (but don't need to specify the spell, then you perform one of your Bardic Performances for a number of rounds, then you cast it. So yes, the casting time increases to 2 or 3 rounds, but it also occurs basically for free - whenever you are using a Bardic Performance, you can be casting a spell without spending any additional actions or resources.