crafting alchemical items.....


Rules Questions


when i look in my own head, i see a witch or alchemist mostly the alchemist,i see this person slaving over a large cauldron and turning out 2 dozen bottles of what ever in 8 hours. so here i am thinking i will just mix up this flask here *wiggles the flask for everyone to see* and make me a acid flask. my dm is like okay you sit in front of that flask for 8 hours dripping the acid into the flask. i am like "wait WTF man i am just pouring acid into this flask it should only take a few rounds if not more." he is like " sorry man crafting takes 8 hours quit your b##@~ing its not your turn."

rules are rules but is there anything that says otherwise for such small doses?


A flask of acid is not a small dose, its about a pint of acid.

Technically the rules for crafting (alchemy being a craft skill) says you produce an amount of finished product equal to the DC times the roll in silver pieces for a week worth of effort. That is right, one week, of working 8 hours a day. The rules do let you break that down into one day portions, you just divide the total of the skill roll time the DC by 7. So a vial of acid is 100sp value, figuring you roll a 10 with an average total skill of 12 is 22 times the DC 15, or 330sp. Meaning it would take at least 2 days to make 1 vial. You can increase the difficulty to decrease the time a bit.

The point I am trying to make is crafting in Pathfinder is not mass production. Without magical assistance it takes quite a bit of time to make items.

I think your expectations of taking raw materials and almost instant titrating them into a high molarity acid with a cauldron is more then a little unrealistic. But if you really want to be able to make alchemical substances quickly, play an alchemist. They get the fast, and, eventually, instant alchemy abilities.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

You are not just pouring acid into a flask. You are taking raw materials, whose exact nature is unspecified but which are not the acid you're looking for, and putting them through mysterious alchemical transformations until, finally, you end up with some actual acid, which you put in a flask.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / crafting alchemical items..... All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.