I (and many others) seem to no longer be considered superscribers, including people I'm pretty sure are subscribed to literally every product line available here. Is this a website glitch or is there a new subscription that I'm unaware of that is now required for the tag?
Looking at Vic's breakdown last March, looks like you're missing Pawns and maybe Tales. (Not sure if that's still considered a Paizo subscription or a licensed one, now that it's Tor).
Unless it's changed (hence why I made the thread), I qualify for the RPG superscriber tag (grey border). The breakdown as I know it is:
RPG Superscriber (grey border): AP, Campaign Setting, RPG, Player Companion, Modules, Card Game, Class Decks
Paizo Superscriber (purple border with shadow): All of the above plus Maps, Cards, and Pawns
See also people like gbonehead immediately below the post you linked who has every subscription offered but is not listed either. The "unexpected" bit in Vic's post for RPG superscriber was likely that it also includes the PACG subs (card game and class decks).