Advice / Opinion on a PFS swashbuckler idea.


Advice

Liberty's Edge

So, I wanted to make a swashbuckler that didn't feel like a swashbuckler.

I finally settled on taking the Aldori Dueling Sword and Slashing Grace, and going into Dueling Mastery. After that I'll start down the dirty trick line. His inspiration is the classic sarcastic, witty, and ridiculous swashbuckler from movies, doing things like cutting peoples belts so their pants fall down and things like cutting open a bag of flour that's above them to blind them while he taunts them.

Here is the feat progression I have so far:

1:Exotic Weapon Proficiency-ADS, Weapon Focus-ADS, Swashbuckler's Finesse
2:--
3:Slashing Grace
4:Quick Draw
5:Aldori Dueling Mastery
6:--
7:Combat Expertise
8:Improved Dirty Trick
9:Greater Dirty Trick
10:--
11:Dirty Trick Master
12:?

Anyone have any better ideas? Any mechanical combos I'm not thinking of that would fit this idea? The race is human and the traits I have so far are dueling cloak adept and inspired.

Silver Crusade

You are likely to get better advice, in the advice part of this forum.

That said, you will have to define what "didn't feel like a swashbucker" actually means. You plan should work, but is a bit redundant considering the Targeted Strike power you get at level 7.


I can find almost no reason not to go half elf if you're getting an exotic weapon proficiency.

Liberty's Edge

Oh thanks, I just posted in a hurry. Yeah, targeted strike does make it kind of redundant.

By "not like a swashbuckler" I mean that I want to do something outside the box, but still works out mechanically.

Scarab Sages

Make a slayer instead. My swashbuckler died at level 2, after I was unable to change her to a better class. More like swashsuckler.

Liberty's Edge

BigNorseWolf wrote:

I can find almost no reason not to go half elf if you're getting an exotic weapon proficiency.

I had almost done that. And am still strongly considering it. I feel kind of attached to the extra skill point.

That being said, half elves have much better alternate racial traits.

Silver Crusade

First, I would suggest going with Half-Elf like BNW suggested. You can get Exotic Weapon Proficiency as a bonus feat at first level (instead of Skill Focus). In effect, you are trading 1 skill point per level for the other bonuses that half-elves get (low-light vision, elven immunities, keen senses, multitalented, ...).

Second, for your concept you probably want to go 7 levels of Swashbuckler (for Targeted Strike), but everything after that is less interesting. I recommend four or five levels of Fighter in there somewhere. If you put some of them in fairly early, say levels 6 and 7, then you can have all of your desired feats through Greater Dirty Trick by level 7, and Dirtry Trick Master by level 9. Go back to Swashbuckler for two levels to get the 7th-level deeds, then back to fighter. Being a half-elf, you will get favored class bonuses for both classes.

Take Weapon Specialization and Greater Weapon Focus at level 11.

At level 12 take an 8th level of Swashbuckler and Greater Weapon Specialization.

Edit: forget what I said about Weapon Specialization and Greater Weapon Focus. You really want to get Combat Reflexes. You may also want Improved Trip or Improved Disarm, and probably the Greater version of whichever you go with.

Shadow Lodge

Problem is Dirty Trick Master isn't legal if I recall rightly. I'm on my phone so I cznt check so easily

Liberty's Edge

Swashbucklers can't take fighter levels because of it being one of their parent classes.

I think I'm going to go half elf, let the Aldori Dueling Sword set me apart from the Inspired Blades and the Whirling Dervishes, and go with the Weapon Specialization line, perhaps even improved disarm.

A funky idea I had while talking with a coworker kind of has me wanting to go with swashbuckler to seven, then go with ninja and take shadow clone and vanishing trick.

The goal would be to thematically recreate a nightingale from skyrim.

Silver Crusade

Steven_Evil wrote:
Swashbucklers can't take fighter levels because of it being one of their parent classes.

That was true in the play test, but not in the ACG.

PRD wrote:
Parent Classes: Each one of the following classes lists two classes that it draws upon to form the basis of its theme. While a character can multiclass with these parent classes, this usually results in redundant abilities. Such abilities don't stack unless specified. If a class feature allows the character to make a one-time choice (such as a bloodline), that choice must match similar choices made by the parent classes and vice-versa (such as selecting the same bloodline).

Link

Liberty's Edge

The Fox wrote:
Steven_Evil wrote:
Swashbucklers can't take fighter levels because of it being one of their parent classes.
That was true in the play test, but not in the ACG.

Oh wow, really? I never thought to check. That opens things up A LOT for me...

Silver Crusade

Steven_Evil wrote:
A funky idea I had while talking with a coworker kind of has me wanting to go with swashbuckler to seven, then go with ninja and take shadow clone and vanishing trick.

That sounds like a fun character too.

Silver Crusade

Steven_Evil wrote:
The Fox wrote:
Steven_Evil wrote:
Swashbucklers can't take fighter levels because of it being one of their parent classes.
That was true in the play test, but not in the ACG.
Oh wow, really? I never thought to check. That opens things up A LOT for me...

.... Kata Master of Many Styles Monk 2 / Brawler X ..... goood.


RocMeAsmodeus wrote:
Make a slayer instead. My swashbuckler died at level 2, after I was unable to change her to a better class. More like swashsuckler.

O.o

My current Emerald Spire group is level 8 ish with two of us having Swashbuckler level(s). We're... uh... destroying things. Specifically, my character's a Swash 1 Eldritch Scion Magus 7. While not the optimal build path (that'd be Inspired Blade Swashbuckler into any other flavor of Magus going Int based instead of Cha based), I still provide strong damage to the group off of spell strikes in combination with the Precise Strike deed gleaned off of Arcane Deed. In this build, Swashbuckler provides strong defensive capability, with my being able to stop attacks before they hit my secondary layer of defensive buffs (Mirror Image, Blur/Displacement, AC.) It also enables finessing with a katana, but that's just a thematic selection.

Our other Swashbuckler took 5 levels in the class, setting up a support melee build centered around Butterfly's Sting. He doesn't do a great deal of damage per strike, but each swing gives a potential crit 30% of the time, which he forgoes per Butterfly's Sting to give one of the rest of us (two Strength beaters and my magus) a crit. Oh, and it procs Outflank. Which gives us AO's. One of which crits, triggering Outflank again.

Note: these are a pair of esoteric Swashbuckler builds, but are incredibly effective in play. Our team started building around the critbuckler once he came online, and now we're rolling though many encounters in single rounds, more if the terrain is unfavorable. I've also seen two other Swashbucklers who each provide solid offensive capabilities while maintaining good defense again non casters. The trick to building a Swashbuckler, it seems, is shoring up your Fort and Will. If you can do that, you're pretty much golden, or so I've seen. I'd say that they're in the top three classes introduced in the ACG, alongside Warpriest (which is good, but incredible with the Sacred Fist) and Hunter (which is bonkers.)

tl;dr: I vehemently disagree with your assessment that Swashbucklers are weak.

Grand Lodge

Sebastian Hirsch wrote:
Steven_Evil wrote:
The Fox wrote:
Steven_Evil wrote:
Swashbucklers can't take fighter levels because of it being one of their parent classes.
That was true in the play test, but not in the ACG.
Oh wow, really? I never thought to check. That opens things up A LOT for me...
.... Kata Master of Many Styles Monk 2 / Brawler X ..... goood.

You know, I was planning something like this, using Snakebite Striker archetype, although taking those two Monk levels at 3rd and 4th leves, to complete Jabbing Style Feat tree before 5th level.

Liberty's Edge

Ryzoken wrote:
RocMeAsmodeus wrote:
Make a slayer instead. My swashbuckler died at level 2, after I was unable to change her to a better class. More like swashsuckler.

O.o

My current Emerald Spire group is level 8 ish with two of us having Swashbuckler level(s). We're... uh... destroying things. Specifically, my character's a Swash 1 Eldritch Scion Magus 7. While not the optimal build path (that'd be Inspired Blade Swashbuckler into any other flavor of Magus going Int based instead of Cha based), I still provide strong damage to the group off of spell strikes in combination with the Precise Strike deed gleaned off of Arcane Deed. In this build, Swashbuckler provides strong defensive capability, with my being able to stop attacks before they hit my secondary layer of defensive buffs (Mirror Image, Blur/Displacement, AC.) It also enables finessing with a katana, but that's just a thematic selection.

Our other Swashbuckler took 5 levels in the class, setting up a support melee build centered around Butterfly's Sting. He doesn't do a great deal of damage per strike, but each swing gives a potential crit 30% of the time, which he forgoes per Butterfly's Sting to give one of the rest of us (two Strength beaters and my magus) a crit. Oh, and it procs Outflank. Which gives us AO's. One of which crits, triggering Outflank again.

Note: these are a pair of esoteric Swashbuckler builds, but are incredibly effective in play. Our team started building around the critbuckler once he came online, and now we're rolling though many encounters in single rounds, more if the terrain is unfavorable. I've also seen two other Swashbucklers who each provide solid offensive capabilities while maintaining good defense again non casters. The trick to building a Swashbuckler, it seems, is shoring up your Fort and Will. If you can do that, you're pretty much golden, or so I've seen. I'd say that they're in the top three classes introduced in the ACG, alongside Warpriest (which is good, but incredible with the Sacred...

It's been my experience that Swashbuckler's are one of the top classes in the ACG. One of my favorite builds of all time is my Swashbarian. I think it was four (maybe two?) levels of Urban Barbarian and the rest into Swashbuckler. I took the rage power that lets you reroll failed saves by drinking alcohol. He was pretty awesome.

As far as my recent proposal of the ninja levels after swash 7, I'm trying to run the action economy in my head to see if that would be far too many swift action options, but I don't think it is. I think it'd be an interesting build. Probably would lag behind some other PFS builds as far as brute damage and defensive capabilities but I could make it work.

Silver Crusade

Ryzoken wrote:
RocMeAsmodeus wrote:
Make a slayer instead. My swashbuckler died at level 2, after I was unable to change her to a better class. More like swashsuckler.
I vehemently disagree with your assessment that Swashbucklers are weak.

+1

Shadow Lodge

The Fox wrote:
Ryzoken wrote:
RocMeAsmodeus wrote:
Make a slayer instead. My swashbuckler died at level 2, after I was unable to change her to a better class. More like swashsuckler.
I vehemently disagree with your assessment that Swashbucklers are weak.
+1

+1

Oh they are most definitely effective. My swashbuckler (inspired blade) has managed to take on several baddies at once. Like the bbeg at the end of level 2 or 3 of the emerald spire and his minions. Of course having six AoOs and the panache to parry 6 times without getting any more back from a crit. :D

Dark Archive

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Lost Omens, Rulebook, Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game, Starfinder Society Subscriber

As a head's up, dirty trick master is not allowed in PFS. See the Additional Resources:

Additional Resources wrote:

Pathfinder Player Companion: Bastards of Golarion

Archetypes: the archetype on page 9 is legal for play; Equipment: kin's face tattoo and ring of culturemeld are legal for play; Feats: all feats on pages 16-17 and pages 23-25 are legal, except the gillmen feat and dirty trick master; Misc.: the bard masterpiece on page 27 is legal; Traits: The traits on pages 4-13 and 28-29 are only legal if your character is of the same ethnicity as the section with the trait. All traits on pages 4-29 are legal, except azlanti inheritor, curse in the blood, evader, marked by unknown forces, mordant envoy, signature moves, and thinblood resilience.

(Emphasis mine.)

Liberty's Edge

Ok, thanks for the heads up.

I think I've settled on the swashbuckler/ninja combo. It just sounds far too fun to pass up.


Thomas Graham wrote:
The Fox wrote:
Ryzoken wrote:
RocMeAsmodeus wrote:
Make a slayer instead. My swashbuckler died at level 2, after I was unable to change her to a better class. More like swashsuckler.
I vehemently disagree with your assessment that Swashbucklers are weak.
+1

+1

Oh they are most definitely effective. My swashbuckler (inspired blade) has managed to take on several baddies at once. Like the bbeg at the end of level 2 or 3 of the emerald spire and his minions. Of course having six AoOs and the panache to parry 6 times without getting any more back from a crit. :D

I've been fairly disapointed with mine. Besides the parry riposte the swashbuckler class doesn't do a lot thats... swashbucklery. It doesn't enhance movment, and the poor saves have been a problem on the front lines to the point that I think I'm going to mix in a few levels of paladin.

The level of dervish dancing bard i took for the scimitar and dex to damage feats gave a few things that felt swashbucklery enough that i'm starting his twin brother as a dervish dancing bard (that may take a level in swashbuckler)

The rest of the litter will have a bit more variety though.

Liberty's Edge

Why not just take the whirling dervish swashbuckler archetype?


Having to get to 4th level before dex to damage kicks in is a bit of a stretch.

The bard level added expeditious retreat and feather step for mobility which is kind of nice. (probably should have taken vanish) and opens up a host of useful wands.

For dropping peoples pants around their ankles, the targeted strike ability opens up a lot of options for that.

Liberty's Edge

True that. I personally never did the Whirling Dervish but my brother has. I don't like that dex to damage waits so long to come out either.


BigNorseWolf wrote:


I've been fairly disapointed with mine. Besides the parry riposte the swashbuckler class doesn't do a lot thats... swashbucklery. It doesn't enhance movment, and the poor saves have been a problem on the front lines to the point that I think I'm going to mix in a few levels of paladin.

Derring-Do does a fair bit to enhance mobility in that it gives you the extra oomph you need for Climb and Acrobatics checks. Outside of that, you'd probably want to look into ways to enhance your land speed, if only by using UMD and a wand of Longstrider. That said, it is easy for a Swashbuckler to end up not moving around a lot.

The saving throws are the larger concern, which is where the bulk of your build attention should probably go. By all means, grab dex to damage, but after that I'd work hard at those saves. Half Elf with Dual Minded for an extra 2 to Will, Additional Traits for an extra 1 each to Fort and Will, prioritize your cloak, consider making room for Iron Will and or Great Fortitude, use Antiplague/Antitoxin, consider Battle Cry if you're still a Charismatic Swashbuckler, dip into strong save classes like Paladin or Monk... Heck, build up a half orc with Fate's Favored, Sacred Tattoo, and mix in two or more levels of Warpriest for Fervor'd buffs.

My Swashbuckler Magus definitely does feel the sting of low Fort and Will. At 8, my saves are floating around 6/10/6, definitely not helped by my being an Emerald Spire character and thus being poorer than normal. Heh. I may have been focusing too heavily on damage dealing til now, and am scrambling to put together defenses. Hazards of playing an archetype that trades away Intensified Shocking Grasp, I suppose.

Shadow Lodge

BigNorseWolf wrote:
It doesn't enhance movment, and the poor saves have been a problem on the front lines to the point that I think I'm going to mix in a few levels of paladin.

Swashbuckler/Paladin is crazy good. I took mine through Bonekeep 1/3.


if your aldori swashbuckler takes the slashing grace and slashing strike feats will he also receive swashbuckler benefits that rely on a light piercing weapon?

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Advice / Advice / Opinion on a PFS swashbuckler idea. All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Advice
Druid Gear