I think there's a lot of people who didnt read the rules. I've seen wondrous and weapons or armors paired together.
My first two items to vote are a pair of wondrous items.
ha me too. And then my second pair had one wondrous item, and my third had none. 3 of 6 so far.
Would the choice between two wondrous items be a case where we select the equally good/bad button? I voted anyway, but was tempted to hit that button.
Same here, and one seemed very familiar sounding. Are we seeing last year's entries?
Same. I thought so too, but my second batch was on the up and up.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
My first two were wondrous items. Also had a pair of eligible items where one bolded the entire entry and the other didn't bold anything. :P
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
My first was wondrous vs wondrous, but since then they've all been the new types.
I have seen something using the technology rules, so at least one person ventured there!
No wondrous items for me.
Once you get past the initial pair you should be into this year's items. All is well.
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
Mine too. Are we all seeing the same items? I don't know what Paizo's tournament bracketing algorithm is.
Also seeing a TON of spelling mistakes. I suppose that's to be expected.
Wud thiss bee yoor furst yeer voating bie ennie chans?
About half (or more) of the entries I'm seeing don't have proper paragraph breaks (as in no blank line between paragraphs). Is that just a really easy formatting error to make with the template? (Really nervous that I made it if that's the case).
| 4 people marked this as a favorite. |
I saw an item with major "Wow!" factor in the first five votes. Definite Top 32 material. Hopefully this is a continuing trend. My first couple of voting hours last year were downright painful.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Well, I don't have to guess whether or not my entry was disqualified!
My first repeated item! That didn't take long!
| 9 people marked this as a favorite. |
simply flipping sides and giving me the same two items is not going to change my vote.
My first pair was two wondrous items also. Are there that many or is there some sort of statistical reason we would all see the same items right off the bat?
I also saw an item that was almost identical to one of the items I almost ran.
I wonder if all of you repeat voters aren't seeing items cached from last year that just need to be moved past?
I just came across my first worthy entry. It's really good and uses a pretty obscure item type.
Maybe it's just my run of luck, but I'm seeing a lot of animal-motif'ed items. i.e. "[Animal]'s [Equipment]"
Ive seen a lot of items using Reverse Gravity all willy nilly, and for not nearly a high enough cost to emulate a 8th level spell.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I think I saw an item from The Dresden Files...
So far I've voted 30 times, with 60 items.
Here's the breakdown:
Weapon 24
Armor 8
Shield 5
Rod 5
Ring 9
Staff 5
Wondrous Item 2
Does armor include shields, theheadkase?
Just edited my post N. Specter.
So far this comprises my unique categories. I will keep adding categories as I come across them and put them in my Google Sheet.
| 5 people marked this as a favorite. |
"attuned"
DRINK!
"prized by..."
DRINK!
Nice.
Also, isn't a belt a wondrous item?
Yes, all wondrous items will be categoried into Wondrous Item.
I got two items and voted for one. The very next pair was the same two except switched. I think the voting page is messing with me.
"prized by" again...
DRINK!
A decent item that's missing a required section of the template. Just can't vote for that, sadly. :-(
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Huh. There's a cliched line overused by too many past items, but it actually makes sense in this item. Good job.
Just voted for an item that was almost completely without formatting, it had serious mojo, even though its opposite number was perfectly formatted and not bad at all. Just goes to show that for me at least Mojo > formatting.
One Superstar item so far. Really neat consideration of the effects. Good work, [REDACTED].
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I always hate it when I'm reading what starts out as a good item, when suddenly there appears a mechanics loophole big enough to fly a dragon through.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
"Legend says..." drink
I've seen two items show up three times. (The dozens of others have shown up once each.) I suppose this is entirely the result of randomization (and goblins).
So is this the new Incessant Ramble thread?
I've encountered about four I really like so far. I'm impressed with the overall quality of most items, actually.
It's early but I've seen a lot of wind themed items so far.
| 12 people marked this as a favorite. |
It's early but I've seen a lot of wind themed items so far.
We're actually sending them all to you on purpose. We figured sorting them out would be a breeze.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Wait, what? You made a...then did two...all the word count...
*headdesk*
Rule #1 of RPG Superstar: Read the rules of RPG Superstar.
Pricing is all over the place. Might as well be random.
Wow! Just found an amazing staff.
Just wow! Way, Way better than my entry.
I neither confirm nor deny the category of my item.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Pricing is all over the place. Might as well be random.
Many people say that pricing is the hardest part of item creation.
Was just overwhelmed by two items with heavy mojo. My face melted.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
That's a really cool staff. I don't know if it's superstar material, but I certainly wouldn't kick it out of a book of magic items. Sexy.