There is only one actual adventure in the Box, but there are the tools to make more, especially if Blackfang escapes from the PCs. That first adventure can take anywhere between 2-5 hours, depending on if you all opt for character creation, how fast they burn through the rooms, if they do much role-playing, etc. If your group has taken several hours (or even multiple sessions) to complete that first dungeon, I would guess that they're going to have a fairly good grasp on the simplified rule set by then.
If your group opts to make their own PCs instead of using the pregenerated ones, then it sounds like they're hungry for more and might be more willing to jump in than you realize.
If your group opts to use the pregenerated characters, that is still a good way to learn rules, but they won't have experienced the character creation process. This is actually a decent segway into encouraging the players to pick up the Core Rulebook and make fresh new characters of their own design, for your new campaign.
Talk to your group before game and give them the option to use pregens or make their own PCs.
Talk to you group after the BBox quest and see how they feel. Let their input be your guide instead of it being your arbitrary decision to move to the Core Rulebook. You can progress as fast or slow as they're willing to progress with you. I say play it by ear. Listen to feedback, if certain rules are too much for everyone to wrap their heads around -- cut them out for a game or two.
on a side note, holy cow the Beginner Box throws way too much loot at the party for being level 1 heroes. There are gems, potions, wands, dragonslaying swords, it is not consistent with the amount of treasure your party should expect throughout the rest of the game. I recommend noting that to the players, or simply thoroughly reading the adventure, and cutting out some of the loot.
Spoiling new players with loot is bad. Their focus for future games will be on how many magic swords they got instead of how awesome the storytelling and roleplaying interaction was.
The Beginner Box is good, but if I have one complaint it is the loot. Its like buying a 16 year old kid a Lamborghini for his first car. Just a bad idea!
My beginner box group consists of 4 brand new players and one experienced player. We've had 3 sessions total, and inbetween, I've talked a little bit about whats going to be coming in the full book. They all seem hesitant about it, so until we run some more adventures, we're probably going to be sticking with the box.
Its alright though, I have a campaign planned out for them. Black Fang and Fatmouth both escaped, so I have plenty of hooks to go with.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Why does it have to be all or nothing? If one of your player's asks if they can disarm an opponent add the disarming procedure, same with charging or bull rushing. Let your players lead you and use the rules to tell the story of their characters. I run a campaign using just the Basic Box, Bestiary and limited feats and options from the core rules just because that's all we need. Make the game into whatever's fun for you and your group. :D
Echoing Woo's post above, I'd recommend phasing the Core rulebook in as required, rather than switching from Beginner-only to full-Core all in one fell swoop. Choose a session where, for example, attacks of opportunity get introduced. Spend a few minutes before that game explaining AoOs and get people used to them before deciding which concept(s) to add in the next session. Or even decide you don't want AoOs in your game at all!
The rulebook is a toolkit, pick the parts you want or need, ignore or change anything that doesn't work out. Don't be afraid to experiment, either - try out rules from the book and see how the group feels about them.
If the players are getting bored due to lack of options, phase some new options in earlier. If they're getting overwhelmed, slow down on the introduction of anything else new. Let the group lead your decision on what to introduce, and when.