Maximize Spell and Summon Monster spells


Rules Questions


This seems like a silly question to me but I want to see if there are any known issues with this combo.

If a wizard casts a maximized Summon Monster VI to summon 1d4+1 medium elementals, will this maximize to 5 medium elementals? I can't see why it wouldn't but as I said above, I want to double check. Thanks in advance for the input.


Yes.
It is a numerical part of the spell, hence maximized.


Yes, it works, but I can't help wonder why that wizard can't find something better on the Summon Monster IX chart - I'm betting that one Glabrezu or Astral Deva can be far more effective than 5 medium elementals except maybe in a corner case when you need to track down 5 fleeing enemies at the same time (although outsiders with teleport at will can be almost as effective there, too).

Then again, if you're using a Wand of Maximize, maybe it's not too bad a use for it, but again, I can think of other maximized 6th level spells that would be more interesting than 5 medium elementals.


DM_Blake wrote:

Yes, it works, but I can't help wonder why that wizard can't find something better on the Summon Monster IX chart - I'm betting that one Glabrezu or Astral Deva can be far more effective than 5 medium elementals except maybe in a corner case when you need to track down 5 fleeing enemies at the same time (although outsiders with teleport at will can be almost as effective there, too).

Then again, if you're using a Wand of Maximize, maybe it's not too bad a use for it, but again, I can think of other maximized 6th level spells that would be more interesting than 5 medium elementals.

With Superior & Augmented Summoning, 6 Augmented Medium Air Elementals can be one hell of a force. They block vision, including true seeing and such, and can force a large amount of reflex saves and concentration checks to avoid being screwed over. Failing one of those reflex saves might mean they fly 400ft skyward and drop you next round. Fun times.


By RAW there is no issue with the OP's question. And it is very fair to say that it is also RAI. Whether or not it is powerful is I guess a matter of circumstances but I'd say it probably wouldn't be good enough unless you are using a rod of maximize (and even then it would be questionable).

Dark Archive

DM_Blake wrote:

Yes, it works, but I can't help wonder why that wizard can't find something better on the Summon Monster IX chart - I'm betting that one Glabrezu or Astral Deva can be far more effective than 5 medium elementals except maybe in a corner case when you need to track down 5 fleeing enemies at the same time (although outsiders with teleport at will can be almost as effective there, too).

Then again, if you're using a Wand of Maximize, maybe it's not too bad a use for it, but again, I can think of other maximized 6th level spells that would be more interesting than 5 medium elementals.

Due to Medium Elemental being a Summon Monster IV (4) and not a Summon Monster VI (6) spell, I think that the OP meant a maximized Summon monster 4 (so a 7th level slot). Otherwise, why summon 5 medium elementals for a 9th when you could be summoning 5 huge elementals for that same 9th..

Not that this does not change it much (still corner cases for usability), but I have made that typo in the past myself.


Happler wrote:
DM_Blake wrote:

Yes, it works, but I can't help wonder why that wizard can't find something better on the Summon Monster IX chart - I'm betting that one Glabrezu or Astral Deva can be far more effective than 5 medium elementals except maybe in a corner case when you need to track down 5 fleeing enemies at the same time (although outsiders with teleport at will can be almost as effective there, too).

Then again, if you're using a Wand of Maximize, maybe it's not too bad a use for it, but again, I can think of other maximized 6th level spells that would be more interesting than 5 medium elementals.

Due to Medium Elemental being a Summon Monster IV (4) and not a Summon Monster VI (6) spell, I think that the OP meant a maximized Summon monster 4 (so a 7th level slot). Otherwise, why summon 5 medium elementals for a 9th when you could be summoning 5 huge elementals for that same 9th..

Not that this does not change it much (still corner cases for usability), but I have made that typo in the past myself.

Not a typo at all.

He has to use Summon Monster VI to summon 1d4+1 creatures from the Summon Monster IV chart. Otherwise, if he summoned one single huge elemental, there would be nothing to maximize at all.

Summoning FIVE huge elementals would require Summon Monster VIII which cannot be maximized unless you use a Rod of Greater Maximize Spell (of course, he could just cast Summon Monster VIII and hope he rolls a 4).

Dark Archive

DM_Blake wrote:
Happler wrote:
DM_Blake wrote:

Yes, it works, but I can't help wonder why that wizard can't find something better on the Summon Monster IX chart - I'm betting that one Glabrezu or Astral Deva can be far more effective than 5 medium elementals except maybe in a corner case when you need to track down 5 fleeing enemies at the same time (although outsiders with teleport at will can be almost as effective there, too).

Then again, if you're using a Wand of Maximize, maybe it's not too bad a use for it, but again, I can think of other maximized 6th level spells that would be more interesting than 5 medium elementals.

Due to Medium Elemental being a Summon Monster IV (4) and not a Summon Monster VI (6) spell, I think that the OP meant a maximized Summon monster 4 (so a 7th level slot). Otherwise, why summon 5 medium elementals for a 9th when you could be summoning 5 huge elementals for that same 9th..

Not that this does not change it much (still corner cases for usability), but I have made that typo in the past myself.

Not a typo at all.

He has to use Summon Monster VI to summon 1d4+1 creatures from the Summon Monster IV chart. Otherwise, if he summoned one single huge elemental, there would be nothing to maximize at all.

Summoning FIVE huge elementals would require Summon Monster VIII which cannot be maximized unless you use a Rod of Greater Maximize Spell (of course, he could just cast Summon Monster VIII and hope he rolls a 4).

D'oh, I blame pre-coffee Danka!


Thanks for all the information guys.

As to the question of effectiveness, there are a few things that are more character specific. More powerful options may exist but won't work for the character.

Basically this is a re-build of a 3.5 character that I played and wanted to see how he would work as a Pathfinder character. I found a few interested options, including Greater Spell Specialization. Figuring that he could sacrifice a 9th level spell for a Maximized Summon Monster VI if needed to get 6 Augmented Medium Elementals (with Superior and Augmented).

The character story limited him to summoning elementals (actually elemental scorpions to be specific). In my experience 1 big creature doesn't always mean a greater force. 6 medium elemental scorpions can make a great army to deal with. Or one well place water elemental that grapples and drowns a sorcerer before he can even finish his gloating speech.

Again, thanks.


You are more than welcome.
The talk on this forum is very litteral.
When a person say something isn't RAW, it doesn't automatically mean that the person agree that the game should be run the way RAW tells us.
When a person say that an option is weak, it doesn't mean that you should automatically stay away from it. It simply means that you should be aware why you are using that option. If it is for flavours sake and your group aren't min/maxers then go for it. Personally speaking I try to go for flavour, but I sometimes end up going slightly more powergaming than I really want.
There are also options that are a complete waste. A good example of an option you litterally should NEVER pick is: "Weaken Powder"... If you don't believe me, then compare it to "Dampen Powder". I dare you to come up with a reason that Weaken Powder exists other than two writers must have written them independently.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Maximize Spell and Summon Monster spells All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.