Paizo Top Nav Branding
  • Hello, Guest! |
  • Sign In |
  • My Account |
  • Shopping Cart |
  • Help/FAQ
About Paizo Messageboards News Paizo Blog Help/FAQ
Pathfinder Roleplaying Game
Pathfinder Society

Pathfinder Beginner Box

Pathfinder Adventure Card Game

Pathfinder Comics

Pathfinder Legends

Proud Moments at the table

Pathfinder Society GM Discussion

201 to 229 of 229 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | next > last >>
Silver Crusade ***

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Maps, Modules Subscriber

5-06: You Have What You Hold

Playing up with: lvl 4 barbarian, lvl 5 cleric, lvl 6 sorc, lvl 6 ranger, lvl 6 rogue, and a lvl 7 valeros. I expect some scary fights and I'm a touch worried that I might swarm the barbarian.

I needn't have worried.

12 baddies versus 6 players and a pet? The solution is: FIREBALL!


small boats and many baddies = cramped quarters. What else is a sorceress to do? The fact that the survivors shot her full of arrows didn't overshadow the fact that 6 baddies fell down from the blast.

BBEG who has the ability to shred the party?
Hideous Laughter (sorceress) and Aboleth's Lung (cleric) on the BBEG in a single round can really wreck a GM's plans if the dice so decree. It hurts to fail 2 saves in a row, especially when all you needed was a 7+ on the die. I still hurt the party significantly, but this broke the back of my assault upon them.


Pathfinder Adventure Path, Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Sabre wrote:
and Aboleth's Lung (cleric)

I didn't think there were any Gillmen in the Society?

Shadow Lodge ****

5 people marked this as a favorite.

I was GMing Eyes of the Ten, pt 1. I look down at the rules for a second and when I look up 3 of my players have cameras out and are taking pictures of the epic fight that's going on.

Andoran *****

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber
Pirate Rob wrote:
I was GMing Eyes of the Ten...



Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber; Pathfinder Comics Subscriber; Pathfinder Adventure Path, Card Game, Maps, Modules, Pawns, Roleplaying Game Subscriber

From pazioconoz.

Blackros Matrimony:


The devils/demons surround us we are in darkness.

Lots of us(including my cheetah) are down.

One PC has a daylight SLA , fails to cast defensively

It Looks very much like a TPK.

Their is a hellknight fighting in the wedding area.

I manage to get into a position to cast daylight.

Somehow both me and my cheetah end up finishing the fight on full hit points.

You Have What You Hold


The 1st problem was at the hut where one player charged in, and found their was three enemies not two. The rest of the players easily rescue him.

Then the manticore fight was hard. My druid ended up using CLW charges to keep players alive. (until a lucky net attack meant he yielded)

Then we come to the final fight. A lucky grease and the BBEP was down. Two rogues then attacked her. Followed by a monk.

GMing: Assault on the Kingdom of the Impossible


Two rogues approach from the stealth side. They fire.

Having cover they get sneak attack and none of the guards are able to spot the party.

Osirion **

Pathfinder Adventure Path Subscriber
Catprog wrote:
Then we come to the final fight. A lucky grease and the BBEP was down. Two rogues then attacked her. Followed by a monk.

Monk says hi ;)

Also from PaizoConOz -

Siege of the Diamond City

In the very first encounter of the special, our group is rushing past something that we are pretty sure is a disguised demon, when sure enough, the Vrock attacks. My Cleric of Calistria, for the first time ever, casts Dismissal. Makes the concentration check, breaks the Spell Resistance, Vrock fails the save. Combat over, with the only blow struck being the one from the surprise round.

Elven Entanglement

The entire party, riding on the back of the druid (who is currently in Ankylosaurus form) win initiative in the final fight, and (with a haste) charge directly at the Hezrou BBEG, ignoring the Quasits. The Hezrou says a bad word, affecting only the Barbarian, who immediately loses 10 Strength points. My Cleric of Calistria, incensed at the language and taking vengeance for the Barbarian, casts Dismissal, for the second time ever. Makes the concentration check, breaks the Spell Resistance, Hezrou fails the save - mod over. And Dismissal is now 2 for 2 on demons over CR8.

Qadira ****

YogoZuno wrote:
Catprog wrote:
Then we come to the final fight. A lucky grease and the BBEP was down. Two rogues then attacked her. Followed by a monk.

Monk says hi ;)

Also from PaizoConOz -

Siege of the Diamond City
** spoiler omitted **

Elven Entanglement
** spoiler omitted **

Siege of the Diamond City:
My cleric at the 14-15 table tried that (knowing we would be up against demons I had several dismisal/banishments prepared), only to have the demon teleport back into combat the next round. Teleport into a better tactical position at that. Kind of depressing really, realizing that my "one shots" were not going to work even with all gimmicks I'd bought to get thru SR/Saves.

The judge pointed out of the room and said, "the Abyss is just a few miles over that way, well in range of a teleport spell." It wasn't until after the game that I realized that there's a chance that the spell would have sent it to different plane... drat!

Andoran *****

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber

Our Lady Of Silver.

Our party is facing off against an enemy with Spell Resistance. My Holy Vindicator is doing the 5ft shuffle with it, when the GM announces that the latest attack has staggered it.

I proceeded to use my shirt reroll to make sure I beat the SR with a Sound Burst, effectively cherry-tapping it unconscious via sonic damage.

**** Venture-Lieutenant, Australia—Canberra aka powell01

YogoZuno wrote:
Catprog wrote:
Then we come to the final fight. A lucky grease and the BBEP was down. Two rogues then attacked her. Followed by a monk.

Monk says hi ;)

Also from PaizoConOz -

Siege of the Diamond City
** spoiler omitted **

Elven Entanglement
** spoiler omitted **

As your gm on eleven entanglement, it was very amusing. Even more amusing when I was playing with your cleric on the special. All sorts of fun was had at those tables and I would rate them as among the best I have experienced.

Shadow Lodge ***** Venture-Captain, Washington—Eastern Washington aka WalterGM

5 people marked this as a favorite.

What better way to revive this thread than with another barbarian story. Well, a 3 barbarian, 1 rogue story.

That was our party composition for Maiden, Mother, Crone, the 3rd installment of the Reign of Winter AP.

Barbarian 1: Jill, our DPS dwarf barbarian
Barbarian 2: Rukk, my half-orc barbarian
Barbarian 3: Iesha, sassy ifrit rage-prophet
Rogue: Eliandra, master of deception aasimar dancer

I'd bore you with details of the entire game, suffice it to say every combat was lots of damage being taken on either side of the GM screen, followed by Iesha expending dozens of wand charges at the end of each fight.

Some highlights:

  • Getting a gorgon to accompany us as an ally.
  • Having said gorgon turn an evil fey to stone, then smashing her hands off before she could return to flesh.
  • Soaking damage from 8 shadows before using Jill's ghost touch greataxe (what a backup weapon!) to take them all out
  • Using a necklace of fireballs blindly to start a fight against a giant spider
  • Never making a majority of the Knowledge checks asked of us to identify a monster

But the best moment came during the final fight. Not to spoil much, but at the end there's some BBEG and his equally evil buddy. Both hit pretty solidly. The fight so far was rough--Rukk was already bloodied before we were able to drop the weaker one (warhammer crit = ouch!). It was getting down to the wire, so after dropping the first guy, Rukk took a fleeting swing at the BBEG before "tagging out" with the other barbarians behind him. The BBEG took his AOO, and dropped Rukk into the negatives. Thank god for Diehard.

The barbarians took their swings, dealing some decent damage; but not even bloodying the BBEG. He goes, circles to the side to break flanking, and tears into Jill. She's now bloodied.

Low on options, Rukk decides to roll the dice.

He activates his ring of ferocious action as a free action and pounces. He takes the BBEG's AOO to the face. 26 damage, 20 after DR. I do the math. Rukk has 4 hit points before he's true dead, sitting at -42.


Full attacks from the pounce. Hit, natural 1, miss, natural 20. Portfolio reroll on the natural 1. Reroll is a natural 20. Both crits confirm. Crits are x3 on claws. Roll the dice, do the math. 126 damage. BBEG falls. Rukk takes 1 point of damage from his strenuous action. Rukk has 3 hit points left.

Thanks to Raging Vitality, Rukk can't drop rage or he dies. Luckily, Iesha is ready with a wand.

Victory from the clutches of defeat. What an excellent fight.

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Alright I have one. It's been about 10 years and no moment has ever lived up to this one. It's nothing heroic and probably more of a "You had to be there moment" but I will share nonetheless.

We were playing fantasy D&D in the Hero System. It was fantasy like most other campaigns but with a few changes. Namely, in this GM's world elves elves were about 2-4 feet tall. Anyway I made a 3 ft tall elven sorcerer named Tiax The Mighty (Kudos if you know where my inspiration came from)

He always talked in the third person, and thought he could do anything he wanted. He was delusional and believed that he was all powerful and that everything belonged to him. He had a pony named Tiax II. That pony died and the next one he named Tiax 2 the II etc...

He claimed to be all powerful but among the first things he did when a fight broke out was go invisible and and fly to a safe distance. After that he would throw fire etc... but safety first lol.

If he failed at anything, he claimed that if he *really* wanted to, he could deal with it with a snap of his finger but chose not to because "This amuses Tiax". The system didn't have alignments but I'd cement him at a comfortable Chaotic Neutral. His personality was easy for me. What would happen if someone with the mentality of a 3 or 4 year old had insanely powerful magic at his fingertips? He was never disciplined and learned to (almost always) get his way.

Whenever he entered a town, he would telekinetically roll out a red carpet, magically enhance his voice, and bellow "ALLLL HAILLLL TIAX!" He would use TK to make one person bow and others would bow because that's how people work lol. (In This system powers cost endurance which recovered over time. I didn't have to worry about "blowing" my powers for the day) He wasn't "violent" per se but he would use Telekinesis to make people bow to him, charm people, threaten, posture etc... but was mostly harmless unless his life was threatened. Haha I don't know how many times I introduced myself and then the group offhandedly as my escort, bodyguards, or servants. After a while, they quit objecting lol.

Now that there's some context, the actual story.......

Well one day we were traveling to another town (After being exiled from the town we just left). We actually had a map with marks on all of the places we weren't allowed back to lol (mostly because of Tiax's antics).

The group was traveling on horseback and we were pulling our cart full of treasure. I think there was a new party member because a character had recently died. Tiax was educating this person on the party dynamics AKA everyone there were servants of Tiax. This new party member had the ability to detect magic and that was when everyone realized Tiax had cast his own version of Arcane mark on their foreheads (Something I had told the DM about in secret when he first met them haha) His mark? TM :)

One of the players sarcastically asked Tiax if there was anything that *didn't* belong to Tiax. Somebody then noticed that Tiax the Mighty had plastered TM all over the cart. The party member that actually paid for the cart said

"No, I bought this cart and it is the group's cart."
"No, Tiax's cart"
"Group's cart"
"Tiax's cart"
Everyone in Unison: "GROUP'S CART!"
Everyone thought they finally won an argument with Tiax when I passed a note to the GM
The cart explodes in fire as Tiax calmly says "No one's cart"

We had to take a break for about 15 minutes because we were laughing too hard.

Story #2

Same character - different reincarnation. I used to like playing Tiax for a new group to evaluate their level of RP and their comfort level in regard to characters with extreme personalities.

I believe Anzyr was actually the GM for this one. It was 3.5 I believe I was a Sorcerer/Incantrix.

We were attempting to infiltrate a party of some sort. One player turned to me and said (out of character) "Oh god... how are you going to have Tiax blend in/not blow our cover?" I said easy. I'm gonna to Rick James this s*!~. lol I still don't know if people just thought I was a bard telling tales of some badass named Tiax (because I referred to myself in the 3rd person) or if they were just picking up what I was puttin down.
Either way it would have worked out but our hot-headed monk got drawn into a fight lol.

** RPG Superstar 2014 Top 16, RPG Superstar 2013 Top 16

I was proud of my players when I ran

The Stolen Heir:
...and they didn't even think of attacking Tercio at the end.

I was proud of myself in the same module

The Stolen Heir:
for encouraging the alchemist to let me help her flee Sourton to Absalom and seek asylum with the PFS

Has anyone else realized how many of these proudest moments involve a crit of some sort? Maybe Keen and Improved Critical SHOULD stack...

Cheliax **

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Causing a very powerful enemy NPC to full retreat as a result of being sundered into nudity.

Cheliax **

... Or, well, my Carrion Crown party successfully defeating encounters that are between four and five CR above our level with zero losses.

*** RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

RainyDayNinja wrote:
I was proud of my players when I ran ** spoiler omitted **

Maybe more of a sadistic than proud moment, same scenario.

Two newish players, both Andoran squirming horribly on if tehy should turn in the BBEG and support their faction over the society, or if they should blackmail him and use that to gain both prestige points. It was awesome to see new players embrace their faction. (and my inner Taldan was cackling with glee at their suffering.

Shadow Lodge ***** Venture-Captain, Washington—Eastern Washington aka WalterGM

3 people marked this as a favorite.

Last night my dwarven foehammer caused a small boat to capsize, as he ran and jumped on the bow while enlarged. With a successful Knowledge (engineering) check, the GM allowed me to accurately catapult my ally on the other end at the fleeing enemy spellcaster.

He also headbutted an enemy mook through a wall. When I beat his CMD by 20 on a bull rush, the GM wagered that the ramshackle wall wasn't enough to stop him, so he broke through it and flew into the swamp beyond.

What a good GM.

Andoran *****

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber


The CR 10 [REDACTED] smashes the eidolon, who gets unsummoned. My 7th level paladin has to step up and go toe-to-toe with it. Holding the choke point and eating 40-50 damage a round while the two clerics channel to keep him in-between it and the rest of the party.

Teamwork at its finest.

Cheliax **

Making a GM actually ragequit a game by forcing a bunch of mooks into provoking so I could AoO them to death while keeping their spell casting leader pinned. .... And subsequently beating their leader to death while keeping it pinned. >_>

*** RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

one of my players.

Beating the only really challenging fight in <redacted> by making the DC 25 intimidate check on a natural 20. I was hoping the sandman would kick their afts.

Insert a good 30 seconds of profanity from me. (I don't swear much).

*** RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

One for me.

you have what you hold, boat fight.

Already had heroism up, want to get in the caster's face. So I check the map.

"Any penalty for the mooks since I'm on the upper deck to jump?"

"No, I've been calling it a DC 5 to jump to the other ship."

"30 from where I am."

*Gm checks the map* "Are you sure?"


"Ok. Make that DC 30 check."

"Alright, burning luck."

My archerologist makes the dc 30 jump check vaults from the barge and lands on the other boat, nocks an arrow and hits the druid. Only thing that would have made it perfect would have been a crit. +17 to jump is awesome.

Edit: Later drilling the BBEG with two arrows, doing enough damage to drop her to the surrender threshold. This was after she dropped our cleric to -4 in one shot.

My Enemy's Enemy had some moments. From the Barbarian critting the LBEG, to the BBEG dropping fireballs at his feat and me going toe to toe with him (we both had evasion) it was an awesome fight.

I have a pretty awesome Halforc Assassin in a party of 4 who seems to take any female npc I throw at him. During the first 3 sessions of our RotR AP he managed to get himself into quite a bit of trouble.

Ven's Daughter:

During the plot line of Ven Vinder's Daughter he managed to get into a room alone with her, take off half his clothes and upon hearing Ven approach his immediate action is to stand up and greet him by the bedside and scream "I DIDN'T DO IT!". He later got power attacked into unconsciousness and thrown out the door naked with all his gear left behind.

Don't do drugs:

During the next session when looking for a missing daughter, he figured going to the Pixie's Kitten was a good place to look for information. At this point, he was already dubbed a hero of Sandpoint.He walked into the brothel and asked if they had any brunettes and drugs. The ladies there led him into a room where he proceeded to take off his gear again. As I told him that he heard footsteps approach his room, he held off any action until the door was opened. I told him 2 guards recognized him as the hero of Sandpoint to which he replied. "Don't you dare touch me! I'm a cop!"... he got over run and thrown out. Once again, leaving behind all his gear.

During the 3rd session the following week, I thought he had learnt his lesson, but nop. Once again he leaves the party in hunt for information. This time at a tavern. Giving him very obvious hints that the ladies in this tavern are crooks, and greedy liars, he still proceeds to try to sleep with them and after failing some bad checks, he gets his gold stolen from him the following day.

He has never talked to another female NPC since then. This campaign has been running for 3 months now.

Osirion ***

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Adventure Path, Modules, Tales Subscriber

GM-ng Shattered Star, Chapter 4:

A battle against a mixed group of Ettins and Hill Giants ends in confused treachery when the Oracle casts Murderous Command on the lead Ettin. After failing the save, on its next turn it scores three hits and a critical against a neighboring hill giant.

Seeing this, the other Ettins shout "Is it time to kill Shoggo now? OK, let's kill Shoggo!" And the remaining Ettins dog-piled the poor Hill Giant.

The players couldn't stop laughing for several minutes.

Shadow Lodge ***** Venture-Captain, Washington—Eastern Washington aka WalterGM

I GM'd the Blackros Matrimony the other night. Here are a few highlights (spoiler free).

  • Their summoner got thrown out of the wedding for summoning his genetically perfect pig under the buffet table after being told it would not be allowed to associate with guests.
  • The party's luchador (tetori), "El Churrito," was able to swoon the captain of the guard by engaging in a wrestling match with her.
  • I used the party's create pit against them by bull rushing a party member into it (this was more fun for me).
  • Even without faction missions being handed out, half the table still completed their individual faction goals by playing in character. I awarded them bonus cool points.

  • *** RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

    3 people marked this as a favorite.

    Confirmation Story.
    Ok, things went well to start, hyper Halfling, not needing the Underdark map (because I misplaced mine), teaching the newish player why you don’t wander off alone at first level. We had two paladins in the party. Janira asks the first, “So do you have the stick up your aft yet? He says “Yes.” Perfectly deadpan. So she asks the other paladin. “No.” First paladin says, “Don’t worry, I’ve got a spare.”
    “I’ll scout ahead story” (Here there be spoilers)

    Half orc scouts into the room, rolls a one for his perception (giving him a 6) I describe the room, and the body on the floor, tell him he might see the glint of coins below the body. He walks in to stab the body, I ask for the d6 roll…

    Three zombies he fails to notice get a surprise round! One hits, dropping him to 2 HP. Initiative is rolled, he withdraws as far as he can, past the rest of the party.

    Me: The rest of you hear the sound of what seems to be a little girl crying in panic, then see your half orc friend go running past you, clutching his side in pain.

    They dispatch the zombies and are disappointed to see the body was hiding shiny rocks.

    After dispatching the oozes (almost resulting in dissolved paladin) and healing, they go fight the minotaur. It drops Janira, and is getting ready to Coup de grace her. (note, I missed he has Javalins to throw, this comes up later) Our paladins, and archeologist go running into combat. Minotaur drops paladin 1 to negatives, but he has die hard. Other paladin goes charging in, and draws the AoO. Now she’s at negatives (and doesn’t have die hard). Archeologist, being the only one in melee, tries to trip the minotaur, misses, and down he goes.

    Half orc ranger is standing 70’ away, pinging with his crossbow ineffectually. Die Hard paladin swings, GM forgets he’s already at negs, minotaur returns the favour and now he’s permadead. After the archeologist goes down, it is pointed out to the ranger, “Well at least you no longer have the ‘in melee’ and cover penalties…”

    Minotaur comes towards him. He gets off two more shots and retreats into the caves. Minotaur is still coming, but is squeezing now. Half orc is trying to draw him in (fortunately I had all the caverns maptiles, so making a tunnel was easy). Minotaur moves, half orc is going: Shoot, move. Move, reload. Shoot, move.

    GM suddenly remembers (as the Minotaur moves into a 10 X 10 section) he has a javelin! Minotaur drills ranger for 8 points, he’s down to 2 HP (new player, 10 con) He retreats into a narrow cavern where he’s squeezing. Minotaur spends some time to get to him, then turns to go back and finish off the rest of the party.

    Half Orc heroes up and comes out, shooting the minotaur. Minotaur throws Javelin, hitting.

    One of the players points out, “Did you remember the squeezing penalties?” I hadn’t. Missed, by one. I describe it as “A javelin, as big as a spear, imbeds itself deep in the stone beside your head.” Half orc, stands his ground, reloads and shoots, knowing the minotaur can reach him with his axe.

    Hit! 8 points! Dead minotaur! Much rejoicing at the table, even from the half orc player’s dad, (who played the dead paladin) Likely one of the more nail biting tables I’ve ran in a while.

    Andoran *** Venture-Captain, Tennessee—Knoxville aka Talgeron

    Matthew, I wish I'd been at that table. That sounds awesome. My Confirmation stories are a bit more.., tragic...

    1 person marked this as a favorite.

    Sewer Dragons of Absalom


    While a drunken four classed wonder-PC was charming the pants off of a disguised kobold at the opera, the rogue managed to sneak in the back and disguise himself as part of the acting troupe. Unfortunately, through just lack of attention to the scenario or just some absentmindedness, he didn't realize that the Chelish play he was an extra in might have him being stabbed during the play. It was funny to have him play "odd-number out" with some NPCs (he cheated) whilest not realizing why he was doing it until the guy next to him got stabbed on stage. Pretty funny reaction from the player!

    Also, I went 10 rounds as the boss at the end. Who knew illusions were so useful ...?

    Night March of Kalkamedes

    Priest of Lamashtu jumps off the cliff with a rope tied to him, fighter tries to break the fall by grabbing the rope, gets pulled to the bottom, other fighter falls down after them, ranger tries to occupy the sleepwalker, eventually almost hangs him from the cliff. Describing it, we were all rolling around with laughter at the table. Love it when it's a skill-less party ...

    *** RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

    Night March story.

    Newish player believes the gnome, hook line and sinker. They attack the dragon, the gnome starts screaming in pain. New player's character runs back to the circle trying to chip it away telling everyone else, "Don't kill the dragon until we get the gnome out! We're killing him!"

    201 to 229 of 229 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | next > last >>
    Paizo / Messageboards / Paizo Publishing / Pathfinder® / Pathfinder Society® / Pathfinder Society GM Discussion / Proud Moments at the table All Messageboards

    Want to post a reply? Sign in.

    ©2002–2014 Paizo Inc.®. Need help? Email or call 425-250-0800 during our business hours: Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Inc., Paizo, the Paizo golem logo, Pathfinder, the Pathfinder logo, Pathfinder Society, GameMastery, and Planet Stories are registered trademarks of Paizo Inc., and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure Path, Pathfinder Adventure Card Game, Pathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Battles, Pathfinder Online, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Inc. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Inc. under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.