U.S. Soldiers Plotted to Kill The President


Off-Topic Discussions

101 to 132 of 132 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>

This is going down a road better traveled in this thread.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder PF Special Edition, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Sanakht Inaros wrote:
Actually, it was very religious driven. It was very biblically based and pushed. Religion drove the geo-political dealings. Go back and read the literature and see for yourself. .

And the Western drive for cheap oil, the whole Cold War chess game being played between the Anglo American alliance and the Soviet Union was just incidental?

Learn your basic history.. if you want to see a root cause for major historical events it's always economics. Rhetoric with other themes may be used for propaganda purposes, but it always comes down resources and wealth. The United States and France wanted Vietnam for the tungsten found there, before oil was a factor, hardly anyone cared about who was killing who in those deserts once the Crusades stopped being fashionable.

And even the Crusaders wouldn't have marched, if there wasn't wealth to be seized, in this case potential land holdings for all those second sons that weren't going to inherit. Constantine was fond of starting wars to convert the heathens, provided those heathens were burdened with a lot of excess wealth.


I don't exactly disagree with you Comrade LazarX, but the Western drive for cheap oil, the whole Cold War chess game, etc., etc. didn't inspire the growth of the Zionist movement in the shtetls and ghettoes of Russia and Poland.

Although I'm still not sold on Comrade Inaros's theory, either. It's true, there were apparently more than a few philo-Semitic Christian somethingorotherists running around the British empire and one of them, some dude or other, read Herzl's Der Judenraat in Austria or something and arranged for TH to get a meeting with the Kaiser to ask him to ask the Sultan to maybe give Palestine to the Jews. (I've been reading a few wikipedia pages.)

But I still think that "Jewish Zionism" was a largely secular movement. Sure, it bases its claim to Israel on The Bible or whatever they call it, but my understanding was that the real hardcore religious Jews--such as the Hasidim, and a bunch that were actually living in Palestine at the time--were opposed to the establishment of a Jewish state because it violated central tenets of their belief. Or something.

Anyway, yes, it was Jewish, but I always thought Zionism was pretty much a secular nationalist movement


Lazarx wrote:
Learn your basic history.. if you want to see a root cause for major historical events it's always economics. Rhetoric with other themes may be used for propaganda purposes, but it always comes down resources and wealth. The United States and France wanted Vietnam for the tungsten found there, before oil was a factor,

Was/is tungesten of some supreme military importance? See,s an awful lot to spend on it , when you could just buy it.


Tungsten is used by the military (and by commercial products too). In some alloys, it makes for a very efficient conductor, but it's a lot cheaper than gold, making it much more cost effective.

It's also one of the heaviest metals available, with a similar density to uranium. They used to use depleted uranium for certain types of ammunition and artillery, but have switched to tungsten as it's both cheaper and safer. Uranium, if it's thin enough, can actually catch fire just by being exposed to air, not something you always want in your ammunition. The high density makes it ideal for armor piercing rounds and it's high melting point make it a great metal for rocket nozzles.

The biggest producer of tungsten is China, so I could see it impacting industrial motivations for controlling Vietnam.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder PF Special Edition, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Comrade Anklebiter wrote:

I don't exactly disagree with you Comrade LazarX, but the Western drive for cheap oil, the whole Cold War chess game, etc., etc. didn't inspire the growth of the Zionist movement in the shtetls and ghettoes of Russia and Poland.

I'm not talking about the Zionist movement. I was talking about the modern state of Israel, which bears resemblence only in name to the goal of Zionist ideals. The point I'm making is that the Zionists would have remained Palestinean style terrorists save for the fact that the United States and Britain decided that a client state would be very useful in Palestine.

Without that motive, there would be no modern state of Israel.


Comrade Anklebiter wrote:
Der Judenraat

Woops. Der Judenstaat.

An unfortunate and entirely unintentional slip.


Irontruth wrote:

Tungsten is used by the military (and by commercial products too). In some alloys, it makes for a very efficient conductor, but it's a lot cheaper than gold, making it much more cost effective.

It's also one of the heaviest metals available, with a similar density to uranium. They used to use depleted uranium for certain types of ammunition and artillery, but have switched to tungsten as it's both cheaper and safer. Uranium, if it's thin enough, can actually catch fire just by being exposed to air, not something you always want in your ammunition. The high density makes it ideal for armor piercing rounds and it's high melting point make it a great metal for rocket nozzles.

The biggest producer of tungsten is China, so I could see it impacting industrial motivations for controlling Vietnam.

Wow. The more you know...

Scarab Sages

LazarX wrote:

And the Western drive for cheap oil, the whole Cold War chess game being played between the Anglo American alliance and the Soviet Union was just incidental?

Learn your basic history...

I'd suggest you follow your own advice. The Christian Zionist movement started more than 100 years BEFORE WWII and about 20 years before oil became an American thing. The Jewish Zionist movement was/is more secular but got more of a push from Christians millienial dispensationalists.

When it comes to Israel, religion trumps anything else.


LazarX wrote:
Comrade Anklebiter wrote:

I don't exactly disagree with you Comrade LazarX, but the Western drive for cheap oil, the whole Cold War chess game, etc., etc. didn't inspire the growth of the Zionist movement in the shtetls and ghettoes of Russia and Poland.

I'm not talking about the Zionist movement. I was talking about the modern state of Israel, which bears resemblence only in name to the goal of Zionist ideals. The point I'm making is that the Zionists would have remained Palestinean style terrorists save for the fact that the United States and Britain decided that a client state would be very useful in Palestine.

Without that motive, there would be no modern state of Israel.

Oh, I missed this 4 hours and 26 minutes ago!

But anyway, yes, I realize you two are talking about different things. That's kind of what I'm saying.


Freehold DM wrote:
Irontruth wrote:

Tungsten is used by the military (and by commercial products too). In some alloys, it makes for a very efficient conductor, but it's a lot cheaper than gold, making it much more cost effective.

It's also one of the heaviest metals available, with a similar density to uranium. They used to use depleted uranium for certain types of ammunition and artillery, but have switched to tungsten as it's both cheaper and safer. Uranium, if it's thin enough, can actually catch fire just by being exposed to air, not something you always want in your ammunition. The high density makes it ideal for armor piercing rounds and it's high melting point make it a great metal for rocket nozzles.

The biggest producer of tungsten is China, so I could see it impacting industrial motivations for controlling Vietnam.

Wow. The more you know...

I looked some of that up, but some of it I knew. On navy ships they one of the anti-missile systems is called the CIWS, basically an automated machine gun that tries to shoot down incoming missiles. They have to use really dense metal because of the higher kinetic energy, you want to do as much possible damage to the missile to break it apart, explode it or change it's course. They used to use depleted uranium, but switched primarily to tungsten a while ago, I think early or mid 90's.

The system is kind of neat, there are two radar units mounted on the gun, one for detecting targets and the other for aiming. The aiming radar antenna is sensitive enough that it can actually track the rounds being fired and 'walk' them to the target. The put out something like 60 rounds per second and have an effective range of over a mile.

About 10 years ago, they made it mandatory to know this kind of stuff about the ship you were on for E-5 and above.

Scarab Sages

Actually, you needed to know that stuff when you were getting your warfare pin which used to be after you got all your basic qualifications done. Stuff like serving on the fire party (shipboard fire fighting), all the different quarterdeck watches (Messenger of the watch, Petty Officer of the Watch), and Ship-Self Defense Force (for when marines weren't on board/auxillary to the Master-of-Arms in case of emergencies). Once they made the pins mandatory, knowing that stuff went out the window. I've seen guys right of boot camp and "A"-school get their pins within a week of reporting to the ship and not be able to tell you anything about the ship.

Other stuff that you had to know: where the repair lockers are, what kind of powerplant the ship used and how it functioned, the weapon systems, what kind of aircraft was on it and their functions and abilities, etc. When I got out, the entire warfare pin system was a joke. The test for the pins is given in two parts. The first was a written part and the second was the oral board in which you stood in front of a senior person from the different departments and they fired questions at you. You could pass the written and fail the oral.

There were four blue-shirts in my division. On the day of our deployment, one of the chiefs we worked with came down and grabbed our Air and Surface Warfare books and took off with them. Two days later she came back and the books were signed off. Taped to the books were who was going to be on our board, what questions they were going to ask, and what kind of case of soda to bring. Somehow we managed to pass our written exam without ever taking it and were going to take the oral exam. The questions I was going to be asked: What is the name of the ship? (USS Theodore Roosevelt) What does the "N" mean in CVN? (Nuclear) And what is our first port of call? (Palma, Majorica Spain) When I sat in on my friend's board, the only question he was asked was "Who was Theodore Roosevelt?"

Scarab Sages

Comrade Anklebiter wrote:
LazarX wrote:
Comrade Anklebiter wrote:

I don't exactly disagree with you Comrade LazarX, but the Western drive for cheap oil, the whole Cold War chess game, etc., etc. didn't inspire the growth of the Zionist movement in the shtetls and ghettoes of Russia and Poland.

I'm not talking about the Zionist movement. I was talking about the modern state of Israel, which bears resemblence only in name to the goal of Zionist ideals. The point I'm making is that the Zionists would have remained Palestinean style terrorists save for the fact that the United States and Britain decided that a client state would be very useful in Palestine.

Without that motive, there would be no modern state of Israel.

Oh, I missed this 4 hours and 26 minutes ago!

But anyway, yes, I realize you two are talking about different things. That's kind of what I'm saying.

What I'm saying is that there wouldn't BE a state of Israel if not for the christian zionist movement.


And that, at least as far as this internet conversation goes, needs to be proven. You can tell me to go read the basic history if you like, but I'm not going to go read Herzl or Jabotinsky or Weizmann or any of those other dudes.

Scarab Sages

Comrade Anklebiter wrote:
And that, at least as far as this internet conversation goes, needs to be proven. You can tell me to go read the basic history if you like, but I'm not going to go read Herzl or Jabotinsky or Weizmann or any of those other dudes.

As I've said, I've put it on the backburner right now. There may be something somewhere else that suggests or proves otherwise, but I only do the research between semesters, so...


You could, though, mention what you've already been reading.


Sanakht Inaros wrote:
Actually, you needed to know that stuff when you were getting your warfare pin which used to be after you got all your basic qualifications done. Stuff like serving on the fire party (shipboard fire fighting), all the different quarterdeck watches (Messenger of the watch, Petty Officer of the Watch), and Ship-Self Defense Force (for when marines weren't on board/auxillary to the Master-of-Arms in case of emergencies). Once they made the pins mandatory, knowing that stuff went out the window. I've seen guys right of boot camp and "A"-school get their pins within a week of reporting to the ship and not be able to tell you anything about the ship.

I got mine around the same time the requirement was implemented (during deployment in 2001). I was on the USS Carl Vinson, but seriously, on an aircraft carrier that knowledge was useless. It was all trivia. It was good if you were giving someone a tour of the boat, but I couldn't operate equipment in the CIC or engineering.

I thought that the mandatory requirement was a bad idea and it sounds like you've confirmed it. The surface/air pins really weren't a big deal. They were sprinkles on a donut, they look pretty, but don't actually change the flavor at all.


As for the christian movement, I don't think that was the main impetus behind the formation of Israel, but it has been a motivating factor behind several American political movements for supporting Israel.


Anyway, let's get back on topic. Kind of.

Here's a series of articles for discussion:

The FBI's War on the Left

FBI Hatches Another Terror Scare

COINTELPRO

Austin Police Infiltrated Occupy Austin

Deploying Informants--FBI Stings Muslims

Ruby Ridge

I'm sorry, crazy right-wingers, but I am not as informed about US plots to frame, imprison and assassinate you guys. I'm sure Comrade Thorn or somebody could fill in some blanks.


Comrade Anklebiter wrote:

Anyway, let's get back on topic. Kind of.

Here's a series of articles for discussion:

The FBI's War on the Left

FBI Hatches Another Terror Scare

COINTELPRO

Austin Police Infiltrated Occupy Austin

Deploying Informants--FBI Stings Muslims

Ruby Ridge

I'm sorry, crazy right-wingers, but I am not as informed about US plots to frame, imprison and assassinate you guys. I'm sure Comrade Thorn or somebody could fill in some blanks.

I'm not sure the left really claims Randy Weaver.


The left doesn't claim Randy Weaver at all. :)

He's the only example of a crazy right-winger being entrapped in the whole US Gov't-concoct-a-terror-plot-smash-dissidents machine that I, a crazy left-winger, can think of.

The feds might frame up leties on 4-to-1 ratio with rightists, but I don't know, hence the apology.


Ah. I thought you were supplying a list of persecuted lefties and was surprised to see Ruby Ridge on there.

Though, at least some of the recent FBI terror scares weren't really left or right, just entrapment.


Comrade Anklebiter wrote:
Comrade Anklebiter wrote:
Der Judenraat

Woops. Der Judenstaat.

An unfortunate and entirely unintentional slip.

Spoiler:
It was a difference between council versus state.

I was waiting for someone to (erroneously) scream antisemitism by accusing you of making a tongue-in-cheek aphoristic remark. Heh.


Spoiler:
Hence the apology.

Although, honestly, my opinion of Israel is very low.


As far as government reports go, I don't really have any faith in an oganization that wastes resources watching such dangerous subversives at the Red Hat Society.


Comrade Anklebiter wrote:
** spoiler omitted **

Spoiler:

Naturally. You're a goblin.

You do it in the streets.

Scarab Sages

Comrade Anklebiter wrote:
You could, though, mention what you've already been reading.

I'll post as soon as I can find the thumb drives. I know I listed some of the books in the reading thread.

Scarab Sages

Irontruth wrote:
I thought that the mandatory requirement was a bad idea and it sounds like you've confirmed it. The surface/air pins really weren't a big deal. They were sprinkles on a donut, they look pretty, but don't actually change the flavor at all.

Before they became mandatory, they were make or break on an exam. Had I had my surface pin I would have made 2nd class first time up. Another example were the two PO2 OS's that were up for PO1. Andy and Keith both had their surface pin but Keith also had his air pin. Andy scored a couple of points of higher on the test than did Keith but missed out on getting advanced. Keith made PO1 because of the air pin.

My big thing about making them mandatory is that it became a quota game. Rules and regs were being broken left and right and no one cared. It wasn't about being able to run things in CIC or engineering. It was about knowing how it all came together. How things worked on the ship. But now you have guys who can't tell you what 01-110-1-C means or where it is. Who don't know were the repair lockers are or what a boundary-men does. In case of a NBC attack, they won't know where to go or what to do. And from what I saw, now that they are mandatory, they no longer carry the same weight as they used to when it came exam time.


Setup, they are like that every time. Some blackflag operative secret agent starts s@@%-talking blacks, asspunders , current president whatever. Eventually this feeble fallguy will manage a "yeah".
At that point they are told something needs to be done, and they are equipped with guns and plans handed out by the agents.

As they finish up, the raid comes in and arrests the fallguy.
And voila, it looks like there was a conspiracy and assassination planned that only the brave spies managed to uncover.

Its always the dumbest f$+#s that fall for it, and allow these previously unknown people to hand him all the guns and whatnot.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Adventure, Rulebook Subscriber

Well, except for the murder bit. Guess the shadowy supplier didn't swoop in fast enough.


I hadn't heard anything about FBI involvement in this one. It only came to light because of the murder.

The FBI's been focusing on talking Muslims into terror plots. Pretty much textbook entrapment in a lot of cases.

Liberty's Edge RPG Superstar 2015 Top 16, RPG Superstar 2013 Top 16

Funny how left or right, everybody hates a good old fashioned federal frame job.

101 to 132 of 132 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Gamer Life / Off-Topic Discussions / U.S. Soldiers Plotted to Kill The President All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Off-Topic Discussions