Sheath of Bladestealth doesn't work with rapiers or short swords?

[SlimGauge]

A rapier and a short sword are both piercing weapons.

A Sheath of Bladestealth (APG,pg309) works with "any bladed slashing weapon, from a dagger to a greatsword".

This means that the rogue can't hide his rapier and shortsword this way, but the fighter can hide his greatsword. Really ?

Errata, please ?

[Matt Stich]

SlimGauge wrote:

A rapier and a short sword are both piercing weapons.

A Sheath of Bladestealth (APG,pg309) works with "any bladed slashing weapon, from a dagger to a greatsword".

This means that the rogue can't hide his rapier and shortsword this way, but the fighter can hide his greatsword. Really ?

Errata, please ?

Or you could rule it that way. Talk to your DM about it. Or if you are the DM, just say it works.

[Maxximilius]

I think there is more need for a complete UC errata than for something developers would assume any DM can just handwave the "problem" and be done with it.

[Morgen]

It could be intentionally made to only work with slashing weapons too, just to point it out.

After all the Fighter with the Greatsword needs the bonus a heck of a lot more then the Rogue.