Who is your quintessential comic book fighter?


Comics

1 to 50 of 52 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>

At first, I thought Captain America, but he's more of a Paladin.
Batman doesn't count because Batman is a Rogue, Alchemist, etc.
I'm thinking Nick Fury might be the quintessential comic book fighter.
And that's interesting because I think Nick's schtick is ready access to a lot of military resources (tanks, helicopters, battleships, etc.)-something that the Fighter doesn't have. Maybe the Fighter should have a "Resources" value that gains in level and doesn't include his wbl.

Silver Crusade

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Groo the Wanderer.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
LilithsThrall wrote:

At first, I thought Captain America, but he's more of a Paladin.

Batman doesn't count because Batman is a Rogue, Alchemist, etc.
I'm thinking Nick Fury might be the quintessential comic book fighter.
And that's interesting because I think Nick's schtick is ready access to a lot of military resources (tanks, helicopters, battleships, etc.)-something that the Fighter doesn't have. Maybe the Fighter should have a "Resources" value that gains in level and doesn't include his wbl.

Luke Cage


The Comedian.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

luke cage would be more a monk prehaps?

for a fighter?

dead pool.

Silver Crusade

2 people marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Adventure Path Subscriber

Taskmaster, of course.


Taskmaster or Hawkeye (Clint Barton).

EDIT: Ninja'd by Gorbacz


I'd argue that Superman, Supergirl, and Powergirl are fighters. All of their supernatural abilities are racial traits and not class features. Their fighting style is the drag-em out, beat em-up style of fist fighting more suitable to fighters with improved unarmed strike. Ms. Marvel is pretty much they same way.

Also, Red (Abiding Perdition), Fandral (Thor), Citizen Steel (JSA), and Hawkman (JLA) all seem like fighters to me.

Of course, I don't think comic book characters are using D&D at all. If anything they are using Champions, Mutants and Masterminds, or Mutant City Blues.

Contributor

Moved thread.


Luke Cage leapt first to my mind.

I wonder if you'd consider Cerebus the Aardvark ?


Andrew Besso wrote:

Groo the Wanderer.

+1

Gotta love a fighter who dumps all of his mental stats.


Hawkman.

Liberty's Edge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Deadpool, hands down.


Nobody mentioned Wolvie yet???

Silver Crusade

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Adventure Path Subscriber

Deadpool.

Wolverine I'd call a barbarian. Then get my guts handed to me.

Liberty's Edge

Sissyl wrote:
Nobody mentioned Wolvie yet???

Love me some Wolverine/Logan but he strikes me as more of a Ranger/Barbarian/once upon a time Samurai. Very much more woodsy though so I'd wager Ranger over anything else with some serious rage issues.


Badger.

Greg


Conan? Hes called "the barbarian", but he doesnt really rage...he just cleaves and power attacks until all foes are driven before him...


Travis Morgan aka The Warlord


Wolverine. Thinks with his weapons constantly (when he bothers to think) and is generally aggressive.

If that doesn't say Chaotic Neutral Fighter, I don't know what does. Sure the super regeneration and claw thing adds a little bit of twist but hey, fantasy, right?


Kaiyanwang wrote:

The Comedian.

You bet Comedian. Hmm. Raise with Ozymandias.

Regards,
Ruemere


Taskmaster, Bullseye, Deathstroke (oddly enough all villains). Hawkman was a good suggestion as well.

Someone mentioned Clint Barton/Hawkeye, I see him as more of a Ranger.
Also Luke Cage I see as more of a boxer type, Monk (unarmed) type without the discipline.

RPG Superstar 2015 Top 8

Wildcat (Ted Grant). Yes, he's a boxer, but I doubt he's got monk levels. Just loads of bonuses to his unarmed attacks.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Ben Grimm - uber tough meatshield scrapper

Grand Lodge

Sunderstone wrote:
Also Luke Cage I see as more of a boxer type, Monk (unarmed) type without the discipline.

Sounds like a Fighter to me.

Spiderman? Colossus? Kilowog?


DM_aka_Dudemeister wrote:

Deadpool.

Wolverine I'd call a barbarian. Then get my guts handed to me.

Barbarian Samurai actually, he follows Bushido in the comic books to keep his anger in check.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
ruemere wrote:
Kaiyanwang wrote:

The Comedian.

You bet Comedian. Hmm. Raise with Ozymandias.

Regards,
Ruemere

Watchmen, Pathfinder version (just for fun):

Spoiler:

The Comedian is a Fighter. He just kills stuff efficently, and he's expert of a good array of weapons. He's just not te BSF, he's a smart person. Combat expertise? He displays good uses of few strenght based skills.

Rorscharch is an Inquisitor. Ruthless, intimidating: His "divine power" in the setting is his convinction. He continuously seeks and looks for answers. He's resourceful and stalwart.

Dr. Manhattan is a Diviner Wizard. Level 20, and with the immortality discovery. He did not ban trasmutation school for sure - spams disintegrate several times! Conjuration neither since teleports. Is powerful as a 20th level wizard + immortal. Template? divine rank 0?

Nighr Owl is an Alchemyst, melee oriented. He has several interesting tricks and devices, intelligence, and the ability of adapt his gear (in a magicless world, he changes gear intead of himslef to adapt to a situation). The power level is not of a full caster.

Silk spectre seems a..? Monk! She delivers few interesting attacks, is well versed in melee and defends herself even with very light clothes. She's able to interact wisely with the wizard when really needed, and uses evasion.

Ozymandias is a Cleric. As with Rorsharch, a superior principle guides him, and to that you must add the cult.. of HIMSELF. he wants de facto ascend to divinity himself. He's enough powerful to outsmart the Wizard (Wisdom vs Intelligence), and prepared (read: carefully BUFFED) beats the Fighter (an old Fighter in that moment, penality to physical stats, and morale penalties). He has a lot of resources and utility, of high level, and this thanks to his convinction.

And now, i want to play an adventure, or remake the whole story :(


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Well played. I'd use Savage Worlds or EABA (with larger than life characters).

My interpretation of characters is a bit different:

Comedian's a brute. Slow, powerful and tough. And nasty.

Roscharch is presence/stealth commando. He relies on his ability to terrify opponents, uses stealth, gadgets and improvised weapons to great effect. He has also extremely forceful personality. In times of need he can draw on hysterical strength to perform feats of extreme brutality. Suffers from paranoia. Obsessive.

Dr Manhattan is an addict, drunk on hyper-reality and possibilities, lacking in social graces, with his gifts slowly eroding his humanity. He is less than human and extremely focused, to the point of being a bit dumb. Often spaces out distracted by phenomena beyond anyone else's perception.

Night Owl is a more mundane version of Dr Manhattan, with skills in applied science. His strength is a product of his dedication to ideals of perfection. Though, being less driven than most of the characters, he's fallen a bit behind.

Silk Spectre is a martial artist and adrenaline junkie. Highly skilled and quick, prone to bouts of aggression.

Ozymandias is the opposite to Dr Manhattan. Totally focused on reality, he is capable of manipulating it to great effect, both in micro (personal ability to control and overpower opponents) and macro scale (the world). Extreme levels of awareness coupled with agility and ability to use opponent's maneuvers against them.

Regards,
Ruemere

Scarab Sages

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber; Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber

Shiva.

Silver Crusade

Thor, he does most of his fighting with a weapon. He goes without his weapon for too long and he's useless.

You could argue iron man is a fighter in Celestial Plate with a Celestial Shield, though his repulsor beans sort of defy fighter definition. Though in one of the cartoons set in the future, he refers to himself as a Knight (I got kids who love to watch the straight to DVD Avenger cartoons)


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Red hood.


Gonna have to second Deathstroke. He's like the alternate company equivalent of Captain America but without the pesky Boy Scout syndrome, and he does all of his ass-kicking with weapons and his fists.

And I LOVE me some Deathstroke. Hands down my favorite villain.

Shadow Lodge

Pathfinder Rulebook Subscriber

I gotta go with Captain America as I really don't see him as a paladin. He's neutral good, not lawful (anybody remember the Civil War storyline?) and doesn’t seem to have any magical abilities beyond enhancement.

So, Captain America gets my vote :-)

Also Cassandra Cain Batgirl, Wonder Woman and Deadpool.


Just because you disagree with specific laws doesn't mean you're not lawful. At least that's how I see it. I definitely think that Captain America is Lawful Good personally. But he's closer to a fighter than a paladin because he doesn't get powers from his alignment.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Kieviel wrote:

I gotta go with Captain America as I really don't see him as a paladin. He's neutral good, not lawful (anybody remember the Civil War storyline?) and doesn’t seem to have any magical abilities beyond enhancement.

So, Captain America gets my vote :-)

Also Cassandra Cain Batgirl, Wonder Woman and Deadpool.

Civil War storyline AKA a bunch of marvel heroes acting completely out of character.

Shadow Lodge

Pathfinder Rulebook Subscriber
ikarinokami wrote:
Kieviel wrote:

I gotta go with Captain America as I really don't see him as a paladin. He's neutral good, not lawful (anybody remember the Civil War storyline?) and doesn’t seem to have any magical abilities beyond enhancement.

So, Captain America gets my vote :-)

Also Cassandra Cain Batgirl, Wonder Woman and Deadpool.

Civil War storyline AKA a bunch of marvel heroes acting completely out of character.

As opposed to the very strict and stringent character quality boundaries that they usually have? It seems to me that the vast majority of comic book characters bend and twist their personalities throughout the years.

Hell, Batman started out using a gun and recently Cap was part of a black-ops team of Secret Avengers.

If you want lawful good you may want to look to the way DC Comics tends to portray Captain Atom. He's a Government sanctioned good guy who works within the bounds of established law.

*edited for spelling

Grand Lodge

Valeros..

RPG Superstar 2015 Top 8

Maccabee, he is at least the most iconic.... hee.

Not sure why I didn't say it earlier, but here's a contribution to the discussion:

Gail Simone wrote:
[Wonder Woman is] the best g@&%+#ned warrior planet Earth has ever known, and she happens to carry a mystical arsenal around just for the hell of it.

Grand Lodge

DeathQuaker wrote:

Maccabee, he is at least the most iconic.... hee.

Not sure why I didn't say it earlier, but here's a contribution to the discussion:

Gail Simone wrote:
[Wonder Woman is] the best g@%$~~ned warrior planet Earth has ever known, and she happens to carry a mystical arsenal around just for the hell of it.

Hey, he's in a comic and unlike the rest, has actual fighter levels. Heh.

In all seriousness I would pick Diana as well, being the apex warrior of the DCU and all that. Not to mention my wife's all time favorite role model.


yea that's true, wonder woman is a straight up figher, but so is superman


First I thought of Deadpool, then for pure kick you teeth to next Tuesday, it had to be the Midnighter. Of coarse, Authority never did any crossovers, so I don't know what power level this guy is on.


Captain America's a lawful good fighter. He's also very high level, with the Leadership feat and incredible amounts of reputation.


What about Aunt Petunia's favorite nephew, the ever-lovin' blue-eyed Thing? Think about it, he's an Air Force vet with combat training, he once made a living the UCWF, he fought the Champion for three rounds, and enters battle with the cry "It's Clobberin' Time!"

Silver Crusade

Squirrel Girl.

Wolverine's afraid of her...and been beaten by her.

Grand Lodge

I can't believe he hasn't been mentioned yet, but Lobo is all fighter.

But an argument could be made for ranger for him as well.

Grand Lodge

Blayde MacRonan wrote:

Squirrel Girl.

Wolverine's afraid of her...and been beaten by her.

Squirrel Girl has beaten Dr. Doom, she doesn't count. She has magical super fan following powers that allow her to do things that should get her killed.


I always thought Lobo might make a good Anti-Paladin.

If I remember right the only time he does anything good is when it furthers his own ends or he's getting paid, so he's not really breaking the Code.


Midnighter of course,cause as he sees you for the first time he's already found 367 ways to kick your ass,most of them will make you beg for mercy, and then he kisses his godlike boyfriend in front of you!
Midnighter rules!


Roy Greenhilt.


Hmmm I guess martial arts is a subset of "Fighter," unless you are figuring that differently.

If I can use martial arts I say Shang Chi, Master of Kung Fu.

He really hasn't been used much since his series ended in the early 80's (?), but I always thought of him as the ultimate martial artist. None of the rest of the Marvel martial artists (yeah it was a thing once, like westerns) measure up: Sons of the Tiger, White Tiger, Iron Fist.

DC did okay with that theme, but Richard Dragon, Lady Shiva, none of the rest of them measure up to what Marvel was doing in the 70's with that. And Shang Chi was definitely the poster boy for that era. Hmmm Richard Dragon may be an older character than Shang Chi, not sure, but he just isn't as memorable.

Philosophizing with Shang Chi worked so well, unlike Mr. A or even the Question.

1 to 50 of 52 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Gamer Life / Entertainment / Comics / Who is your quintessential comic book fighter? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.