Subdomains for pre-existing characters


Pathfinder Society

Silver Crusade

Hi, I'm taking my second cleric level and was wondering what the rules are on domains, as I couldn't explicitly find them. I have two domains from the core book, but was wondering if I had the legal option to replace them with APG subdomains or are my domains I chose at creation permanent, especially in the case of Society. If I can't, that's fine but was weighing my options. Thanks!


Back when the APG became official for PFS play, Josh was still in charge and he ruled that the only changes to characters allowed was to adjust playtest characters to match the final rules. Other than that, there was no rebuilding or swapping out allowed.

5/5

Enevhar Aldarion wrote:
Back when the APG became official for PFS play, Josh was still in charge and he ruled that the only changes to characters allowed was to adjust playtest characters to match the final rules. Other than that, there was no rebuilding or swapping out allowed.

Unless the features of a rebuild character would not have come into play at the pressent level.

Thus a low level character might still be given an archtype from the APG if that optional build's first class features would first be granted at a higher level.
But it is try that Josh ruled no retroactive changes were allowed.

Silver Crusade

Thanks guys. Makes my decision making easier actually. But at least I have a new character concept to try out later :)

Paizo Employee Director of Brand Strategy

Slipstream wrote:
Thanks guys. Makes my decision making easier actually. But at least I have a new character concept to try out later :)

What subdomain were you looking at? Many of them have their first alternate ability at levels higher than 2nd. If you're only taking your 2nd cleric level, you may still have some options without needing to actually rebuild anything.

Sovereign Court 5/5

I thought that it was legal to adjust a character's make-up during its first three adventures of play. Of course I couldn't find it in the Guide.

Sovereign Court 5/5 Owner - Enchanted Grounds, President/Owner - Enchanted Grounds

Nope.

The only thing I've ever seen done is hand-waving a brand new player's mistakes in his first couple adventures. "Wait, you mean I'd have to masterwork both ends of the Gnome Hook Hammer, so it'd be 600 gp? Oh. Um, I wouldn't have bought that, if that were the case."

It'd be nice to have some sort of re-build mechanic, but there is nothing. I think even the above example falls under the, "That sucks for you," realm. He would have to sell the item back at half gold, and buy a new one if he wanted to switch after his first adventure. I can't see treating brand-new players that way, is all.

Fascinatingly, if someone "cheats" without knowing it, they *have* to fix it, though. "What do you mean I can't have Weapon Focus as a first level rogue? I have to have a +1 BAB?" That guy has no choice except to pick a new feat and "rebuild" during his first couple adventures.


Diego Winterborg wrote:
Enevhar Aldarion wrote:
Back when the APG became official for PFS play, Josh was still in charge and he ruled that the only changes to characters allowed was to adjust playtest characters to match the final rules. Other than that, there was no rebuilding or swapping out allowed.

Unless the features of a rebuild character would not have come into play at the pressent level.

Thus a low level character might still be given an archtype from the APG if that optional build's first class features would first be granted at a higher level.
But it is try that Josh ruled no retroactive changes were allowed.

Yep. I was just not including something like that as a "re-build" since you are not replacing something you have already chosen for the character beyond core vs. archetype class.

5/5

Drogon wrote:
It'd be nice to have some sort of re-build mechanic, but there is nothing.

That's a popular opinion in our region. I think it could be implemented with relative ease if players had to spend PA to perform certain types of rebuilds.

Sovereign Court 5/5 Owner - Enchanted Grounds, President/Owner - Enchanted Grounds

That's a pretty cool idea, Kyle. Very elegant. Anyone floated it by Paizo (outside this thread)?

Silver Crusade

Drogon wrote:
That's a pretty cool idea, Kyle. Very elegant. Anyone floated it by Paizo (outside this thread)?

Yes, there's a two page thread floating around in the archives I found before posting this.

Mark Moreland wrote:
What subdomain were you looking at? Many of them have their first alternate ability at levels higher than 2nd. If you're only taking your 2nd cleric level, you may still have some options without needing to actually rebuild anything.

My domains are Good and Protection. Was looking at Defense subdomain. That one in just the first level of cleric particularly swaps the Sanctuary spell for Sheild and Resistant Touch power for Deflection Aura.

I've got a Cleric 2/Rogue 2 build, so I'm past my first few adventures.

1/5

Mark Moreland wrote:
Slipstream wrote:
Thanks guys. Makes my decision making easier actually. But at least I have a new character concept to try out later :)
What subdomain were you looking at? Many of them have their first alternate ability at levels higher than 2nd. If you're only taking your 2nd cleric level, you may still have some options without needing to actually rebuild anything.

While it's somewhat moot in this case, by the strict RAW interpretation I'm told we're supposed to be taking, this can't be allowed without a special exception in the Guide. It's not even iffy like Archetypes (which I would also interpret this way, but I'll acknowledge there's room to argue that one.)

Subdomains are exactly like domains. They're selected at Cleric 1 and can't be changed thereafter. Even if there's no difference between "Domain" and "Subdomain" at Cleric 1, you can't suddenly change your mind at Cleric 8 when you get the new abilities, even if there are no spell substitutions before then.

Again, this is strict RAW. If you don't want it to work that way, you've either got to errata or call it out in the Guide. Otherwise, if someone came to my table stating that they'd changed their domains, I'd be forced to make them change it back.

Silver Crusade

Chris Kenney wrote:


Again, this is strict RAW.

For the uninitiated, what is RAW?

1/5

Slipstream wrote:
Chris Kenney wrote:


Again, this is strict RAW.
For the uninitiated, what is RAW?

"Rules as Written." Basically, the assumption in PFS is that we're going 'by the book' with the minimum level of human interpretation required (which is still quite a bit), to keep the experience as consistent as possible.

Paizo Employee Director of Brand Strategy

Drogon wrote:
That's a pretty cool idea, Kyle. Very elegant. Anyone floated it by Paizo (outside this thread)?

Who says someone from Paizo didn't float it by Paizo?

Liberty's Edge 4/5 5/55/5 **

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber; Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Charter Superscriber; Starfinder Charter Superscriber
Mark Moreland wrote:
Drogon wrote:
That's a pretty cool idea, Kyle. Very elegant. Anyone floated it by Paizo (outside this thread)?
Who says someone from Paizo didn't float it by Paizo?

Is there a flood in Seattle?

5/5

Mark Moreland wrote:
Drogon wrote:
That's a pretty cool idea, Kyle. Very elegant. Anyone floated it by Paizo (outside this thread)?
Who says someone from Paizo didn't float it by Paizo?

Crap. I think Mark found a second set of hidden cameras... (he'll never find them all)

Community / Forums / Organized Play / Pathfinder Society / Subdomains for pre-existing characters All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.