James Jacobs Creative Director |
James Jacobs Creative Director |
CorvusMask |
Sorry about all "its up to gm" questions ^_^; I have really hard time making decisions when I'm 50-50. Though in this case I'm now leaning towards to not having Torch annexed because it would indeed be very distracting from AP... Plus would mean I'd have to be more careful with exp
So umm, two more questions I forgot: Are runeforged components items consumed when crafting runeforged weapon or can they be reused for crafting purposes?
And if they are consumed, did I understand right that Delvahine will only trade for one of her "toys" and then players would need to figure alternate way to get more of them? I'd assume they could help her get out of Runeforge as payment, but I just want to check if she would be okay with trading more of her toys to pcs for loot or pleasure.
James Jacobs Creative Director |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Sorry about all "its up to gm" questions ^_^; I have really hard time making decisions when I'm 50-50. Though in this case I'm now leaning towards to not having Torch annexed because it would indeed be very distracting from AP... Plus would mean I'd have to be more careful with exp
So umm, two more questions I forgot: Are runeforged components items consumed when crafting runeforged weapon or can they be reused for crafting purposes?
And if they are consumed, did I understand right that Delvahine will only trade for one of her "toys" and then players would need to figure alternate way to get more of them? I'd assume they could help her get out of Runeforge as payment, but I just want to check if she would be okay with trading more of her toys to pcs for loot or pleasure.
When you're 50-50, it's EASY to make decisions. If both are equally good options, which assumes each one is equally difficult/easy to do... roll a die or flip a coin.
Runeforged components are not consumed during crafting.
CorvusMask |
When you're 50-50, it's EASY to make decisions. If both are equally good options, which assumes each one is equally difficult/easy to do... roll a die or flip a coin.
I have low self esteem so I second guess myself a lot, so making decisions where I like both choices but am not sure about which is "better" is really difficult for me :'D
So uh, quick question speaking of my unsureness: So party defeated Athroxis and party fighter got the Mark of Wrath. They are kinda questioning me for "Wait, there isn't downside for this? REALLY? It doesn't make you evil? Are you being coy?" so umm, just to check I understand it right and there is nothing saying there is bad side for having Mark of Wrath? I mean, as far as I know, it just marks you as highlady/lord and gives you small buffs, but it doesn't make character more wrathful or anything or let runelords control you or anything?
BTW, text says Delvahine is only character in iron cages who wouldn't die upon leaving the wing, so does that mean alu-demons do age and can die from old age?
But yeah, thanks again and sorry that these questions are really dumb x-x;
James Jacobs Creative Director |
4 people marked this as a favorite. |
James Jacobs wrote:When you're 50-50, it's EASY to make decisions. If both are equally good options, which assumes each one is equally difficult/easy to do... roll a die or flip a coin.I have low self esteem so I second guess myself a lot, so making decisions where I like both choices but am not sure about which is "better" is really difficult for me :'D
So uh, quick question speaking of my unsureness: So party defeated Athroxis and party fighter got the Mark of Wrath. They are kinda questioning me for "Wait, there isn't downside for this? REALLY? It doesn't make you evil? Are you being coy?" so umm, just to check I understand it right and there is nothing saying there is bad side for having Mark of Wrath? I mean, as far as I know, it just marks you as highlady/lord and gives you small buffs, but it doesn't make character more wrathful or anything or let runelords control you or anything?
BTW, text says Delvahine is only character in iron cages who wouldn't die upon leaving the wing, so does that mean alu-demons do age and can die from old age?
But yeah, thanks again and sorry that these questions are really dumb x-x;
It certainly marks them with the sin of wrath, which may color the perceptions of some who look at it and understand the meaning of the rune, but no, it doesn't make you evil.
This is an example of something I love doing in games I run—rewards to a character that aren't something they expect, aren't magic items, and aren't things they could have just gotten for themselves by buying something or taking a class level. These kind of rewards are memorable and fun and exciting and do a great job at keeping the players interested in the potential for what else might be out there awaiting discovery.
Yes, alu-demons do age and can die from it. This is a result of them being half-human.
And again... they're not dumb questions. Don't worry about it! :-D
Jareth Elirae |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
If Arueshalae develops a relationship with a PC in Wrath of the Righteous and they have a child would that child be a half-fiend? Or by the blessing of Desna turn out as Half- Celestial, aasimar, or Half-fiend with evil spell-like abilities traded out for their good counterparts as they were for Arueshalae herself? Just wondering how you would judge this in a "continuing campaign" I'm the DM and I'm leaning towards the 3rd option.
James Jacobs Creative Director |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
If Arueshalae develops a relationship with a PC in Wrath of the Righteous and they have a child would that child be a half-fiend? Or by the blessing of Desna turn out as Half- Celestial, aasimar, or Half-fiend with evil spell-like abilities traded out for their good counterparts as they were for Arueshalae herself? Just wondering how you would judge this in a "continuing campaign" I'm the DM and I'm leaning towards the 3rd option.
Uncharted territory. Up to the GM.
I would have the child be a non-evil half-succubus if it were my campaign.
Archpaladin Zousha |
Does the Esoteric Order of the Palatine Eye recruit from noble kids at Lepidstadt University, or does the University's emphasis on the sciences result in a mindset nonconducive to the Order's mysticism?
James Jacobs Creative Director |
Does the Esoteric Order of the Palatine Eye recruit from noble kids at Lepidstadt University, or does the University's emphasis on the sciences result in a mindset nonconducive to the Order's mysticism?
I'm not super familiar off the top of my head with them, but I suspect they recruit new members from all over when appropriate.
James Jacobs Creative Director |
James Jacobs Creative Director |
5 people marked this as a favorite. |
Something I noticed: there is no given price for a barrel of pickles. How're we supposed to know the value of what the goblins stole otherwise? How much is a pickle barrel?
The more time we spend giving prices to things like pickle barrels, the less time we have building actual books and products to play and be inspired by.
AKA: The lack of pickle prices is your GM's fault!
Archpaladin Zousha |
I think I remember reading somewhere that officially, "early" firearms like the musket and blunderbuss exist on Golarion, but "advanced" firearms like the rifle and shotgun haven't been invented yet. Is this accurate, or am I misremembering things?
James Jacobs Creative Director |
Archpaladin Zousha |
I see. Does a vampire's vulnerability to sunlight affect only exposed skin (meaning that covering themselves in heavy robes or full plate armor allows them to venture out in the day) or would they still burn even though the sun can't reach their skin?
Timothy Ferdinand |
Rysky wrote:It is mentioned that Nocticula and Socothbenoth are siblings, were they siblings when they were mortals or did it occur after they became demons? And now would the second happen? Larvae Litters?They were not siblings before they became demons. As to how this happened... they were both born from the same mother. We have not revealed who that mother was yet... but chances are VERY GOOD that it was Lamashtu.
Hi James
Given that Nurgal is also alleged to be a half brother of Socothbenoth, would i be correct to assume his mother is Lamashtu, in which case he is presumably also a half brother of Nocticula?AlgaeNymph |
Have you ever noticed that Sorshen has an elemental motif, namely water?
• Her dungeons so far (Sunken Queen, Lady's Light) are filled with, and surrounded by, water.
• The point of reference for the megadungeon she's dormant in is Korvosa's waterline (100' below, to be exact).
• Speaking of that wretched hive, Korvosa's staple industry is fishing.
• Sorshen's empowered by blood magic, which I haven't seen associated with anything but water.
Was this elemental association intentional, or a coincidence as a result of Eurythnia being flooded? Would you be interested in expanding on it (e.g., elemental creatures in the Sorshen AP)?
James Jacobs Creative Director |
I see. Does a vampire's vulnerability to sunlight affect only exposed skin (meaning that covering themselves in heavy robes or full plate armor allows them to venture out in the day) or would they still burn even though the sun can't reach their skin?
As written, skin exposure doesn't really play a factor. GM's choice I guess.
James Jacobs Creative Director |
James Jacobs wrote:Rysky wrote:It is mentioned that Nocticula and Socothbenoth are siblings, were they siblings when they were mortals or did it occur after they became demons? And now would the second happen? Larvae Litters?They were not siblings before they became demons. As to how this happened... they were both born from the same mother. We have not revealed who that mother was yet... but chances are VERY GOOD that it was Lamashtu.Hi James
Given that Nurgal is also alleged to be a half brother of Socothbenoth, would i be correct to assume his mother is Lamashtu, in which case he is presumably also a half brother of Nocticula?
Maybe, maybe not. Demon lord lineage is complicated and doesn't have to follow biology.
James Jacobs Creative Director |
Have you ever noticed that Sorshen has an elemental motif, namely water?
• Her dungeons so far (Sunken Queen, Lady's Light) are filled with, and surrounded by, water.
• The point of reference for the megadungeon she's dormant in is Korvosa's waterline (100' below, to be exact).
• Speaking of that wretched hive, Korvosa's staple industry is fishing.
• Sorshen's empowered by blood magic, which I haven't seen associated with anything but water.
Was this elemental association intentional, or a coincidence as a result of Eurythnia being flooded? Would you be interested in expanding on it (e.g., elemental creatures in the Sorshen AP)?
It's coincidental. None of the runelords are intentionally elemental themed.
James Jacobs Creative Director |
Saberlain |
Edit: This has been answered before it seems! They do age slower. Apologies!
I've no idea if this has been asked before but it's a curiosity of mine when it comes to the various races. Do the age categories at which the different races are considered adult/middle-aged/old/venerable scale to that of humans, or do most races age the same as humans physically but are only considered adults socially later?
For example, if you have an elf that is 50 years old, are they the physical equivalent of a 7-10 year old human, or do they physically age to a certain point (say 20?) and mature mentally until they are an adult at 110?
James Jacobs Creative Director |
Edit: This has been answered before it seems! They do age slower. Apologies!
I've no idea if this has been asked before but it's a curiosity of mine when it comes to the various races. Do the age categories at which the different races are considered adult/middle-aged/old/venerable scale to that of humans, or do most races age the same as humans physically but are only considered adults socially later?
For example, if you have an elf that is 50 years old, are they the physical equivalent of a 7-10 year old human, or do they physically age to a certain point (say 20?) and mature mentally until they are an adult at 110?
That's not really something we've covered; it's mostly left to the GM to call.
James Jacobs Creative Director |
James Jacobs Creative Director |
Drahliana Moonrunner |
Drahliana Moonrunner wrote:noJames Jacobs wrote:Does bouncing count?Drahliana Moonrunner wrote:Irrelevant since neither can fly.Archpaladin Zousha wrote:I know it's a few days too late, but how much ground could a groundhog hog if a groundhog could hog ground ?European or African?
Did you know that one of things that you can get for your Toy collection in WOW was a puntable Marmot?
Drahliana Moonrunner |
Hill Giant wrote:Xhamen-Dor spreads his influence when someone learns his name and intent. I know this because you wrote an article about it. Are you in fact a Xhamen-Dor cultist?Nah. I invented him. If anything, Xhamen-Dor is a cultist of ME.
Anything we should know about your special rites? Your holy (or unholy) days?
James Jacobs Creative Director |
James Jacobs wrote:Did you know that one of things that you can get for your Toy collection in WOW was a puntable Marmot?Drahliana Moonrunner wrote:noJames Jacobs wrote:Does bouncing count?Drahliana Moonrunner wrote:Irrelevant since neither can fly.Archpaladin Zousha wrote:I know it's a few days too late, but how much ground could a groundhog hog if a groundhog could hog ground ?European or African?
yes
James Jacobs Creative Director |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |
James Jacobs wrote:Did Shimmy?Alayern wrote:Good day Mr. Jacobs. Did you enjoy your snow day yesterday?Yes.
She was intrigued by clumps of snow falling from the trees right outside my window once I opened it, but that's pretty much the extent of her interaction with the snow. She's not an outdoor cat.
Rysky |
Rysky wrote:She was intrigued by clumps of snow falling from the trees right outside my window once I opened it, but that's pretty much the extent of her interaction with the snow. She's not an outdoor cat.James Jacobs wrote:Did Shimmy?Alayern wrote:Good day Mr. Jacobs. Did you enjoy your snow day yesterday?Yes.
Hehe. Mine will run and jump into it... and then immediately regret it and run back to the door :3
Glad to hear you're doing okay.
Ifusaso |
Ifusaso wrote:If you feel it should be FAQed, please post the ques/tion in an appropriate rules forum. Posting here won't get it FAQed at all.I feel like this should be sent to be FAQ'd or errata'd.
What's the intended function of Monk/Brawler's Dwarf Favored Class Bonus:
"Reduce the Hardness of any object made of clay, stone, or metal by 1 whenever the object is struck by the monk's unarmed strike (minimum of 0)."?
Does this
- Reduce the hardness for the unarmed strike but not other things?
- Permanently/Instantly reduce the Hardness once?
- Permanently/Instantly reduce the Hardness each time an object is stuck?
- Something else?If the damage is permanent/instant, is it reversible?
Sorry! Completely missed the off-topic tag the first time I loaded this thread.
Alternate question: Who the better duelist? Inigo Montoya or Will Turner?
James Jacobs Creative Director |
James Jacobs Creative Director |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
James Jacobs wrote:Not to put you on the spot, but could you explain your reasons for thinking so?Ifusaso wrote:Who the better duelist? Inigo Montoya or Will Turner?Will Turner, but only because I think that "The Princess Bride" is lame.
Because I dislike fantasy movies that don't seem to trust the viewer with enough suspension of disbelief to accept a movie unless it's presented in a meta-sort of way as a story-within-a-story that anchors the viewer to the real world. I dislike "The Never-Ending Story" for the same reason. And because it's too whimsical for my tastes on top of that. It feels more like a comedy with a sense of humor that I just don't get or appreciate than a fantasy movie. And because the first time I saw it, the first point where I was actually starting to get into the movie was when the screaming eels attack, but then the movie robs me of that scene by cutting away to Fred's bedroom. Lame. Once you interrupt the painfully-slow-to-build interest in that way, I start wishing I was watching something else.
Hitdice |
Thanks for the speedy answer; for what it's worth, the book does present it in that meta-sort of way, but that just means I love the movie so much because I remember the book every time I watch it.
And, because I feel obliged to post a question, have you watched the FX series Atlanta, and if so, what is your opinion of it?
James Jacobs Creative Director |
Thanks for the speedy answer; for what it's worth, the book does present it in that meta-sort of way, but that just means I love the movie so much because I remember the book every time I watch it.
And, because I feel obliged to post a question, have you watched the FX series Atlanta, and if so, what is your opinion of it?
I haven't watched it.
And yeah, I understand that my dislike of "The Princess Bride" is unusual among gamers (at least vocally so). My preferences for fantasy is darker, grittier stuff with more monsters (be they human monsters or literal monsters). Not everything has to be equally liked by everyone, but I try not to be a jerk about it and take pains to not say something like "this movie is terrible" and instead say things like "I think this movie is terrible."