Huh. Arcane Archer is elf only again?


Rules Questions


10 people marked this as FAQ candidate. Answered in the errata.

I was pretty sure it got errata'd to being available to any race that met the requirements. Did it get a reverse-errata to being elf and half-elf again?

Dark Archive

Umbral Reaver wrote:
I was pretty sure it got errata'd to being available to any race that met the requirements. Did it get a reverse-errata to being elf and half-elf again?

I'm pretty sure its always been as such. Unfortunately.


I vaguely recall a thread of celebration when the errata was issued. Was that errata just in a post and not incorporated into the official errata by oversight?

Dark Archive

Umbral Reaver wrote:
I vaguely recall a thread of celebration when the errata was issued. Was that errata just in a post and not incorporated into the official errata by oversight?

That I cannot tell you. However, I've houseruled in my game to allow anyone who meets the Prereqs minus the racial ones to take levels in it. Dwarven Defender was redone in APG minus the racial prereqs. Stalwart Defender. So it makes sense to me.


I remember vaguely someone from Paizo saying that the racial requirement doesn´t really make sense any more, so it would be entirely reasonable to remove it.

To my knowledge no new errata has come out after he posted it.


IRC, James has been vocal about not liking race restrictions on PRCs. I believe he dislikes the restriction on Arcane Archer specifically. However, AFAIK, there has not been any Official errata on the matter.


I agree with james.

Bloody Elven Racists!

Silver Crusade

Rite Publishing wrote:

I agree with james.

Bloody Elven Racists!

Down with this sort of thing!

Findeladlara too! That uptight, self-righteous, ethnocentric, patronizi- dragged off

Dark Archive

Yeah, Arcane archer, according to either James or one of the others "should" be open to everybody. Would be nice to get it into the errata for PFS play and such.

Paizo Employee Creative Director

36 people marked this as FAQ candidate. Staff response: no reply required. 1 person marked this as a favorite.

I'm not sure what happened here... I think this is a bit of errata that just keeps slipping through the cracks whenever we do an update. Or maybe it's something Jason decided not to do... but the last I heard, it WAS supposed to be errataed so that there's no racial limitation to the prestige class.

Perhaps it's still at the "It is entirely reasonable to remove this restriction," but just hasn't been done yet since it's sort of a zero-sum situation. It's not a "broken" rule in either case, so it doesn't really need to be "fixed," after all.

For those of you in games I'm running, though, there's no race restriction for the prestige class.


Thanks for the explanation. :)


Everybody FAQ-up.

I FAQed. Did you FAQ? If not, then you should FAQ yourself ASAP. Let's get this question to the top of the FAQ-it-all list!

Sczarni

DM_Blake wrote:

Everybody FAQ-up.

I FAQed. Did you FAQ? If not, then you should FAQ yourself ASAP. Let's get this question to the top of the FAQ-it-all list!

oops i hit flag when i wante to hit FAQ...

Scarab Sages

DM_Blake wrote:

Everybody FAQ-up.

I FAQed. Did you FAQ? If not, then you should FAQ yourself ASAP. Let's get this question to the top of the FAQ-it-all list!

I'm a VIP b/c I FAQ'd ASAP.


1 person marked this as FAQ candidate.
James Jacobs wrote:
I'm not sure what happened here... I think this is a bit of errata that just keeps slipping through the cracks whenever we do an update. Or maybe it's something Jason decided not to do... but the last I heard, it WAS supposed to be errataed so that there's no racial limitation to the prestige class.

Likewise, I think there was discussion of removing the Riding Dog from the Summon Monster I list, but that never happened either.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Huh. Arcane Archer is elf only again? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions