I wasnt as taken with this as previous reviewers. I liked the story, although it's not my favorite Paizo module it's a very good "Fresh faced adventurers heading out into the world" module which usually tend to feel somewhat contrived to me. I also thought it was excellent at introducing some of the more important changes from 3.5 to Pathfinder.

Where it fell down, in my opinion, was in the room descriptions. Some examples: there's no mention of two stairs between rooms 4 and 9 on the first level (presumably they just join up, but it would have been nice to have that spelt out). I'm not sure how one unlocks the door in the southwest corner of room 6... Those sorts of things let the module down for me.

It also hit my pet peeve - the inside back cover is a reprint of the picture on the front. I would so much have preferred the second level map to go there, freeing up one page for expanded room descriptions as per the paragraph above. It's a nice second-best option to have the dungeon map in the centre of the book, but not as easy to find as if it were on the inside cover.

A good introductory module, despite that - the omissions are relatively easy to sort out yourself. It would just be nice to not have to.

This brand new adventure module (and the very first one!) for PFRPG features a classical dungeon romp, with some wilderness travel added for variety.

The module shines in a number of different areas, from the overall plot, simple yet well thought and full of possibilities for roleplay, to the great layout, which is awesomely easy to read and navigate.
The goodness doesn't stop to these two points, as the side bars explaining quirks and stat-blocs are great both for novices and veterans transitioning to the new ruleset.

The characters are in for some great encounters, will they be fights, puzzles and traps, or old-fashioned good roleplay.
As a 1st level adventure, it also has a neat way of explaining why the characters are there and how they come to form an adventuring group.

The tie-in to the Dungeon flip mat is a great idea to bring more atmosphere to the gaming table (even if a map pack would have served better, with separate tiles for different rooms).

Can't wait for the sequels!

A very nicely put together first adventure using the new rules.

Great use of Sidebars to explain new rules, even to the point that these could be dropped and the module run fine for just 3.5 users who maybe didn't want to run under Pathfinder rules.

Loved the CR and XP given right next to the description of the rooms, something I hope they continue with.

Something I enjoyed, but perhaps others might not, is the inclusion of the Flip map line. The Dungeon flip map I received can be used for the entire adventure! Very nice bonus!!!

I can't wait to run this for our new adventurers (our kids) who will soon be running their very first campaing in ANY D&D world. I can't think of a better place to start than right here.

In one word:
FANTASTIC.

Highlights include:
>Quick, fast, easy to read, master, and run this module from minute one.

>Layout deserves a trophy! Open it up and it falls immediately open to the stapled middle, revealing the dungeon map and great artwork. Functionally, this module layed-out with the user in mind, for example: bold stat block headings, concise Pathfinder RPG defense, offense, statistics sections and clear treasure/development/hazzard/XP/CR ratings/creature #s in bold, making this product very easy on the eyes of young and old gamers alike. The inside covers along with all art throughout is simply the very best and delivers the emotional feel of the world's oldest roleplaying game.

>This is the first Pathfinder RPG adventure compatible with v.3.5 and it absolutely thrives at this. My entire collection is instantly compatible.

>Story selection including the adventure summary and introduction are written concisely and effectively for both novice GMs and expert GMs to grab and use, yet it possesses all the quality of depth we've come to expect from PAIZO over the years. As the first ever Pathfinder RPG module, Bulmahn delivers, and even more powerfully (if you can imagine) than he did with Hollow's Last Hope.

In sum, this review is one of the best rpg modules ever designed--an immediate classic belonging with the hallowed ones we revere and respect. Yet, everything I see is fresh, new, exciting, and immediately satisfying.

Crypt of the Everflame, right down to the font and color selection of its title, is everything you would want from the world's oldest roleplaying game, and delivers a completely new, incredibly smart, sophisticated, and lavishly produced rpg module experience.

WOW! 5-STARS! WAY TO GO, PAIZO!