I just ran this a few times for some local groups, and everyone found it very enjoyable. The map is setup in a way where there is a logical break between gaming sessions. As it was a crypt, most people guessed correctly about what they would be seeing inside, but that didn't take any of the fun away. From slaying baddies to dealing with traps, the players had fun.

The only reason why this wasn't a 5 star is there were a few effects that weren't easily fixable, especially since the party was made of level 1 PCs. Also, I'm sick of swarms. They only slow things down.

I ran this adventure in combination with Hollow's Last Hope (HLH) as the start of a new campaign and the players and I really enjoyed it.

I found the adventure itself to be a good introduction for my players who had never used Pathfinder rules (CMB, CMD, changes to the new feats, etc...). The dungeon was a bit linear and I had to remove one or two encounters so that it didn't become too much of a slog, but overall the players had a good time. The story of Kassen and Asar also serves as a good start for any far reaching campaign plot as the nature of it is left fairly open.

I'm planning to follow it up with the Falcon's Hollow modules as I wasn't really impressed with the Masks of the Living God adventure.

I ran this adventure for a mixed party which included first time roleplayers, long time gamers who had never played pathfinder before, and one person who played pathfinder before, and they all really loved it. It does a great job of explaining rules/concepts to the DM, while providing a immersive experience to the players. I ran this with the dungeon flip map which turned out great. Can't wait to start Masks of the Living God!

After a long break from role-playing, this was my first experience with the new Pathfinder rules. I appreciated the way feats, skill checks and other game mechanics were explained in the text. It made my first DM session in years much, much easier.

I was also very pleasantly surprised by the story and the Crypt design. It was well-thought and nicely written. Modules have come a long way since 1979! I highly recommend this module for beginners or GMs looking for an excellent crawl to customize. Great work!

A fun introductory module, that can be linked with two other modules to form a nice campaign, spanning 7/8 character levels.

I enjoyed DMing it, and the challenges are real for 1st level adventurers, may they be newbies or experienced gamers.

I recommend it!

Wow! I have been away from playing Pen and paper RPGs for about 3 years now, much to my chagrin. Over the past year, I had toyed with the idea of picking up the Pathfinder RPG and finally did around Christmas time last year (2009). Crypt of the Everflame was the first module that I had bought for the system and I must say WOW! It was possibly the best 1st level module I have ever read. I felt like I was back in my formative teen years getting ready for the big game that upcoming weekend! It was clear and concise with enough detail that you wouldn't be stammering around for explanations to your players about the individuals they encountered. However, if was also flexible enough to allow you to make changes on the fly! Very well done! With the new Pathfinder RPG and modules like this coming out, I am ABSOLUTELY looking to getting back into the Pen and Paper genre! I highly recommend this module and am eagerly looking forward to the sequel (Masks of the Living god) and climactic conclusion in the third book (City of Golden Death) of the Price of Immortality arc! Keep up the good work Paizo! Im off to order some more modules...

When I kick off a new campaign, the kind that begins with a bunch of 1st level PCs scrambling for every copper piece they can strip off a dungeon, I make sure of some things.
Among the values that I consider most important to a campaign is it's feel. Playing a bunch of low level lackeys should be very different than playing the high level tough guys who are there to save the world. Accordingly, I strive to pronounce that feeling of "building your legend from the ground up" to my PCs in the first levels of play. I make many encounters that relay on naturally dangerous things, such as a poorly constructed bridge over a foaming, freezing cold river, or perhaps even getting caught in a thick forest while a storm is raging in the sky above.
This mentality is prominence in Crypt of the Everflame. The adventure is set to make the players feel as if they are in the shoes of young men and women, going for a memorable adventure to prove their worth, without actually taking any great risk to their life. When they came to realize that something real was going on, my players were actually terrified (well, the PCs were, and the players played it well). What begins as a nonlethal journey quickly becomes an awesome dungeon crawl with varied encounters and hazards.

Highly recommended!

I ran this module from pdf online, so I cannot speak on the physical quality of the product.

What I can attest to is the amount of fun (A LOT) both me and my players had. Nothing is very complicated in this campaign, yet it challenges the players to use their wits to bypass traps and enemies that a normal head-on collision would not have easily overcome. Great job in balancing simplicity with challenge, Paizo!

Also, I like the fact that the CR and total experience are listed next to every room. I am a huge believer in efficiency and that improves saved me a lot of time, time that I used to make the module more enjoyable for everyone.

One of the best things about this module is the production value. The pages are all of a nice magazine-quality stock, the artwork is well-done and appropriate to use as a game aid.

For those of us who have moved from 3.5 to Pathfinder it was also nice to have some "hand-holding" on the differences between those two systems (and the PF beta). The only down side (as previously mentioned) is a need for more boxed-text. Not a lot, but a bit more could have helped.

This module is also well-suited to those of us who need something to plop down in our own campaign world. Very little tinkering is needed to mold it to the home brew I've been running for about 7 years. Keep up the good work, Paizo. :)

I wasnt as taken with this as previous reviewers. I liked the story, although it's not my favorite Paizo module it's a very good "Fresh faced adventurers heading out into the world" module which usually tend to feel somewhat contrived to me. I also thought it was excellent at introducing some of the more important changes from 3.5 to Pathfinder.

Where it fell down, in my opinion, was in the room descriptions. Some examples: there's no mention of two stairs between rooms 4 and 9 on the first level (presumably they just join up, but it would have been nice to have that spelt out). I'm not sure how one unlocks the door in the southwest corner of room 6... Those sorts of things let the module down for me.

It also hit my pet peeve - the inside back cover is a reprint of the picture on the front. I would so much have preferred the second level map to go there, freeing up one page for expanded room descriptions as per the paragraph above. It's a nice second-best option to have the dungeon map in the centre of the book, but not as easy to find as if it were on the inside cover.

A good introductory module, despite that - the omissions are relatively easy to sort out yourself. It would just be nice to not have to.