| Mike Shel Contributor |
|
|
I've seen it mentioned by people on the boards a few times that parties running through Ghenett Manor have failed the overall mission. While I knew that this was a real possibility that I actually wrote into the scenario, I'm curious to know:
A) How often are groups failing the scenario objective?
B) What is the reason they fail?
C) Does failing the mission have a big impact on their overall enjoyment of the scenario?
Mergy
|
|
|
I haven't run it yet, but I have a few thoughts on the matter:
While I do think that failure should be an option for scenarios, this one seems especially hard and I could see that leaving a bitter taste in one's mouth at the end of a four-hour session.
| Mike Shel Contributor |
|
|
I haven't run it yet, but I have a few thoughts on the matter:
** spoiler omitted **
While I do think that failure should be an option for scenarios, this one seems especially hard and I could see that leaving a bitter taste in one's mouth at the end of a four-hour session.
Mergy:
I think that's a fair criticism, though...
Also, truth be told, it was Mark Moreland who added the Perception check to notice the scuff marks. I hadn't even given players that much of a clue!
Radiostorm
|
|
|
a) My group decisively failed to retrieve the tome.
b) I'd attribute the failure to a couple factors.
One, by the time we had finished the final encounter we had both exhausted our spells and health and hit the four hour mark. We figured the tome was our capstone reward, and it never occurred to us that it could be a counterfeit.
Two, the tome's actual hiding place is a bit irregular. We failed our broad perception checks and never looked back.
Three, there are so many potential hiding places for the book that we simply got tired of making perception checks and singling out specific shelves, dressers, safes, etc.
c) Failing to find the tome was really just a final kick in the pants. What makes this scenario unenjoyable is that the NPCs are allowed to get away with murder, but the players get browbeat for standing up for themselves. In my mind, if an NPC arranges for a amorphous tentacle monster to attack you, you shouldn't have to worry about keeping his house tidy anymore. I've never felt more suffocated by Pathfinder Society alignment requirements than I did in this scenario.
I think the scenario would be more effective if either:
a) The master of the house was cast as a clearly benevolent figure who wished to test the mettle of the heroes. The challenges could be less lethal, and the tome could be offered as a reward at the end. This would make adhering to the "do not steal or break anything" restriction more palatable.
b) The master of the house was cast as a clearly malevolent figure who was actively trying to kill the heroes. The stipulation of leaving his house in one piece could be waived, and confronting and slaying/capturing him could be the final encounter. This would add a satisfying payoff that the original scenario is lacking.
As it stands the scenario skirts the line between these two binaries and consequently makes the players feel jerked around.
| licidy |
|
|
The biggest threat to our characters when we ran through it was the Chaos Beast - 4/5 of the party wound up as puddles of goo before we could return to civilization for a Remove Curse. During the scenario, for ease of play, the GM ruled to only have us save for stability once between encounters otherwise we would have been bogged down by rolls of minutia. Only the party sorcerer didn't get infected, so he could escort our puddles to get help.
Not sure if any other players considered this, but our group escorted Besai to the Manor's front gates and told him to wait for us down the road and away from the dangerous house.
I was unaware the Perception DC was so high! 0_0 My character saw the empty book stand, thought the Aspis Consortium had beat us to the book due to our saving Besai, so I threw the podium in a fit of rage... which revealed the secret hiding spot.
| Mike Shel Contributor |
|
|
I was wondering...
|
Radiostorm
|
|
|
As for the podium, again, it's a weird place to hide the tome and requires a very high perception check for a party that skews lower level.
The World Is Square
|
|
|
H'okay, here's a quick question about a certain encounter in the manor.
Exactly what kind of illusions are the flesh golems in the banquet hall? The description in the module only states that they are "intricate illusions."
I put the golems in initiative order when my players enter the room, so they had potential to get up and attack them (reacting to aggression). But if I don't know what type of illusion they are (figments, shadows, etc.), I don't know how to treat their damage.
I know they poof out of existence after a round, but there is still potential for interaction beyond "hey look, weird things are coming."
Also, are they all individual illusions or is the room one large illusion?
