I've played this adventure, but I remember nothing about it other than fighting some circus animals in the opening scene. Obviously I can't give it a star rating based on that, but the fact that it left little or no impression on me is hardly a ringing endorsement...

This is a great module. I ran it at T8 with a 6 person party of PCs lvl 6-8.

The combats are challenging. I almost killed two PCs as the monsters can pack a good punch if the party isnt careful. You can easily adapt the monsters to good tactics if you have an experienced group.

Where this module shines is the RP. We played up the wedding and trial so well that it ended up dragging this module well beyond what would be expected at a Con game. In fact we had to divide this game into 2 gaming sessions due to the complexity and abundance of RP. I cant figure out how this scenario could be run in a 3.5 hour sitting.

This scenario consists of 18 pages, 1 front cover, 1 OGL, 1 chronicle sheet, 2 pages of faction missions and 1 page of credits.

The faction missions, while not perfect, are cool and innovative, one ties in with scenario number 3. Very nice. My players really liked them.

That leaves 12 pages of adventure and I've rarely seen such an awesome scenario. Consisting of a wedding, a trial, cool battles, a conspiracy and some awesome fluff, this adventure is great. It contains enough ideas to actually make it a full-blown adventure or even series of adventures, while it's also possible to play it one time-slot.
It also has 2 handouts for player characters and several nice maps for the encounters.
It's also perhaps the potentially most role-playing heavy scenario of all the scenarios we have played so far. It is outstanding. Great job, James MacKenzie! I'm looking forward to reading more from you!

Played, then GMed once so far. I think this scenario has one of the best role-playing encounters I’ve seen in PFS so far. There is a lot going on in the first act, but it engaged everyone’s attention even though no combat had broken out. GMs *really* need to prep Act 1 well so it flows smooth. Otherwise the players will metagame the fun out of it. Take advantage of Russel Akred’s nifty prop available here. Great campaign world flavor. Faction missions were appropriate but a bit distracting as everyone wants to complete them right at the beginning. This author understands Pathfinder Society. Now for the bad stuff. The combats are way too easy. Nothing goes more than two rounds before it’s over. The DCs for everything were way too low for PCs levels 5-9. The scenario is looking for a 15 and my players were rolling in the 30s. I had more fun when we weren’t rolling dice. Anyway, despite the pushover fights the story was enjoyable and things actually made sense. I’m looking forward to running this again.