Weather Report wrote:Obviously enough people dig longboard-sized weaponry to allow the option, easy to ignore it if you think it is stupid, which is perfectly reasonable, at least for some campaign settings.
If that is meant for me, I was responding to Secret Wizard comment comparing being unable to use giant sized weapons to "straight up forgetting how to do a mundane act" and willuwontu idea that "Swinging larger swords makes a lot of sense as a mundane act." when referred to using giant sized weapons.
Swinging a sword as high as you with two hands can be done with the appropriate training and a good physique. Swinging an 8-10' sword with two hands or a 7-8' sword with one requires something more.
In PF2 that "something more" is the appropriate totem or, possibly, a jet undisclosed feat or class feature.
A 13-20' sarissa made for the 10" long human hand is very different from a 16' spear made for a 25" giant hand.
And I was saying mundane, as in its an ex ability, not an SU or a spell. It can be gated behind things, and would require training, but makes no sense to be classified as anything but an ex ability (which are achievable by the mundane).