These are some of the issues I had with this product:
1 A one pound Butterfly Knife is listed as a one handed melee weapon, not a light melee weapon (this makes it more cumbersome to use).
2. The following items have listings on the charts, but no descriptions: Dogslicer, War Razor, Earthbreaker, Ogre Hook, Falcata, Kopesh, Temple Sword, Urumi, Bladed Scarf, Shoanti bola, Stoneplate Armor.
3. Several items have the opposite problem from #2 above. The following items are described, but not listed on the equipment charts: Armored Kilt, Pata, Thistle Arrow, Thorn Bow, Combat Scabbard (unsharpened).
4. Several items could have used more information, because the text given is inadequate to describe the item, or how it is used. For Example: The Sawtooth Sabre and Tent (how many people per tent size?)
5. The Garrotte is WEAK and unrealistic.
6. The Persona section is wasted space.
7. The Travelling Spellbook is listed in the "Special Substances and Items" descriptions, but is listed in the "Adventuring Gear" list.
8. The Equipment Trick feat lists the following items: boots, cloak, rope, shield, and Heavy Blade Scabbard, yet only the Heavy Blade Scabbard and Shield are described.
9. A few items are listed out of alphabetical order. For example: The Prohecies of Kalistrade before Printing Press, and Riding Dog before Combat Trained Dog in the descriptions.
10. A few of the descriptions are confusing, and seem to contradict themselves.
Posts
