|Paizo Pathfinder® Paizo Games|
|About Paizo Messageboards News Paizo Blog Help/FAQ|
James Raine wrote:
really... last year it was postulated that there were only 503 unique items post cull which would put the pre-cull numbers at ~630
James Risner wrote:
here is a LINK to the thread where the claim was made.
I like my item, and am happy that I submitted it... it would be a lie if I said that every year I don't end up seeing items that I like better than mine though (and the last two years with the public voting, quite a few of the items I like better than mine don't make the top 32... while items that make the top 32... in fact since public voting began only about 20% of my personal favorites have made the top 32).
Anthony Adam wrote:
and b) might not always do it... the first year of public voting there was an item that had obviously been designed for AD&D rather than pathfinder, to the point of producing spell effects and using spells that do not exist in Pathfinder (for example continual light), and after I flagged it for DQ Sean sent me an IM letting me know that they were allowing it to continue on... of course I didn't see it again after the first cull, so perhaps they just decided that it was doing poorly enough that they didn't need to worry about it.
Feedback for GM_S
The arbelast is cool, but I can see where your concerns about it come from (although I am not sure being thematically similar to last years submission would be a problem in and of itself).
The chimera shield is cool as well, but as written is a bit over powered IMO although since you don't have a price listed that may have been taken into account in a way when it was finished.
The two items that I briefly thought about and rejected before going with my actual entry were:
A set of armor that allowed the wearer to shadow-blend and gave a few other darkness related abilities... rejected because I figured there would be a lot of competition in that niche.
A crossbow that caused its bolts to do bludgeoning damage and made an automatic trip attempt against those that were hit. rejected mainly because I couldn't come up with a name I liked for it in under five minutes.
I'd post statblocks but neither of them got past the rough planning stage.
I on the other hand was not bothered by the shorter time frame... my long, considered, tinkered with, play tested, tinkered with some more, polished, submissions from previous years never amounted to much... so this year I decided before hand that I was going to think on my feet... Therefore, I pulled my submission out of my ass over the course of about 20 minutes yesterday afternoon. Let's see if spontaneity gets me further than forethought in this case.
If he has to drive through Bellevue it probably feels like he is relocating on a daily basis... the 520 bridge (which will avoid some of the Bellevue traffic if he is coming from Seattle) has commute problems of its own. When I lived in Renton and was attending classes at the UW, I took the bus over the bridge and through Bellevue every day, so I got to experience both sets of commute problems. I got a lot of reading done on the bus rides though.
Mikko Kallio wrote:
I agree it is not really a staff... now as a Rod...
Nickolas Floyd wrote:
Wait he sleeps in his car? Somebody needs to ask for a raise I think... I mean I know the east side is expensive, but that's ridiculous... :P
Don Hastily wrote:
As I voter, I can honestly say it doesn't matter to me which way they go about tying it to the setting (so long as the attempts to tie the monster to the setting do not take up so much of the word count that the monster suffers in other areas).
Well I've already shared my first entry (Spirit Bottle) and last years entry (Scarf of Battle Trickery) so I might was well share the three items that came in between...
Sphere of Searing Smoke
Spindle of the Moirai
*added for clarification here, the word blinded was accidentally cut from my entry, and I didn't notice until after I had posted it.
one note of interest is that (before this year at least,) all but one of the items that I entered started with the letter 's' Spirit, Sphere, spindle, and scarf.
James Risner wrote:
If you have seen unique items since the cull that are not on the post cull item list on the other thread could youadd them too it maybe (or PM the person who is keeping that list with a list of items you've seen post cull that are not on it)... so that people who might be checking that list to see if their item made it through can have a load taken off their mind.
I know I have not seen my item post cull while voting, and only know it made it through the cull because of the list on that thread.