|Michael White Venture-Agent, California—San Francisco Bay Area North & East aka TechGnosis|
|2 people marked this as a favorite.|
Regardless of if you are for or against replays, for whatever reason, you have to realize there is going to be an initial problem of availability of scenarios. This problem has already reared its ugly head with Starfinder. I understand why there are only two scenarios published a month, and obviously we dont want to rush Paizo as we would rather have quality scenarios, but in the mean time there isnt going to be much to do.
If we had unlimited 1e replays, at least for the first year or two (at which point Im betting there would be enough content for 2e that 1e would just die out naturally, as previous editions of games such as AD&D did).
That said, I do think the reasons for disallowing replays, and perhaps slightly laxer rules regarding them should be examined. I see old PFS players in my store all the time playing 5th Ed, and when I ask them why they don't play Pathfinder anymore, 9/10 of the time the answer is along the lines of it became too hard to find games they could play anymore, so they moved to another system where that wasnt an issue for them.