Rogue Eidolon wrote:Nefreet wrote:Ah, only what's listed, I see. I don't think that's a universal PFS rule, though, is it? Mike seems in your link to be specifically referring to the summon minor monster spell.
In order to avoid table variation, we can only go off of what's listed in the description of the item.
Scrolls are not on that list.
He actually confirmed Carlos' comment earlier in that thread, which stated "in PFS, in order to avoid table variation, we go with what's listed".
And so, since it's an Adventurers Armory item, you said you can't FAQ it, right?
So, in PFS, no scrolls.
Carlos's earlier post in the linked thread actually mentioned there being table variation when you go off of such a list. I think we are in an area of table variation, so for now, while I intend to continue allowing them, I also completely respect Chris standing his ground and not allowing them. I have played at Chris's table before and would happily play at his table again and just not use my scrolls in wrist-sheaths if it's one of my characters who has scrolls instead of wands.