I think the paladin class is too restrictive so I am proposing a group of tenets that every paladin(lawful good) should have to follow. How much a paladin can ignore these and still keep his powers should decided by his deity, which means the player and the DM. These may differ from what is in the book.
These are not in any particular order. Many come from the Book of Exalted Deeds.
Your laws are based on your deity, and your country, and they come first. If you are in another country try to work within a country’s laws as long as the laws are not designed to promote evil. Breaking someone else’s laws will still land you in jail so be smart about it if you HAVE TO DO IT.
Protect the innocent, and defend the weak.
Thou does not have a license to kill, unless certain circumstances specifically give you that power. The license to kill does mean kill at your leisure. The individual must be guilty of something. Undead, and outsiders with the evil subtype will not count against you when it comes to killing without provocation.
Prisoners are to be treated well. You are now responsible for their well-being.
Evil kills because it’s convenient. Good kills because it has too*. How does this affect taking prisoners, good question? You have to decide who to take prisoner, and who to kill off. It may be a good(alignment wise) thing to offer quarter, but it may not be the smart thing to do. *Yep, that one is mine.
Oh yeah, you must accept quarter from any creature that does not have the evil subtype if it ask for it, but that does not mean you have to offer it.
I won’t be making every monster give up just to stab you in the back later. Doing so would just be me going out of my way to make life hard for on class, which is wrong.
Frontal assaults don’t make you any more of a paladin. They may make you more dead however.
There will be times when doing a good act conflicts with the local law, or even the church. Being good takes priority, you may be thrown in jail, but you will still be a paladin.
Another example is if you capture someone, and you know local law dictates turning them in to be tortured. If I were a paladin I would not turn them in to the local authority. Yes, it may place a bounty on your head for helping a fugitive escape, but that is the life of a paladin.
The book has some nonsense about how if some criminal keeps escaping prison, killing people, and surrendering before the party can finish him off; the party still has to take him prisoner every time. The bad guys should get one free surrender. If they want to cause trouble after that, off with their heads. That one free surrender assumes you are a paladin of course. Other good types are supposed to take the bad guy prisoner, but I think common sense has to step in sometimes, and quarter is not always a good idea.
If it is reasonable try to convert the evil person.This will probably never ever happen in a game. If it does it will probably only works with someone who wants to be good on some level, but circumstances may not allow them to do so and thrive(or at least stay alive).
More on this subject: The greatest act of good is redemption of an evil soul. Getting evil to see the error of their ways helps the innocents, and gains them a blessed afterlife in the Upper Planes. Converting someone by sword point is not a real conversion. A real conversion begins in the heart and soul of the individual. If you put a sword to my throat I will “convert” to any religion you tell me to convert to, and not ask any questions about it.
The ends never justify the means for a paladin. If you torture the bad guy to get the information you may save many lives, but you will probably be a warrior(NPC class) soon, or at least or at least feel like one. As a paladin you must not only do the right thing, but do it in the right way. This does not mean you are excused if you allow a party member to do so. You must make a valid attempt to stop them. Torturing is evil, and you WILL NOT stand for it.
Chaotic paladins are just as good as Lawful paladins, but they will break a law here and there to get things done. They will also not enforce a law that infringes on personal freedoms. Well, maybe if it is for the good of everyone, but they still would not like it.
Closing: I would not be a paladin for long if I had to play one.
I am basically looking for feedback.