|3 people marked this as a favorite.|
A mere offer cannot be construed as threatening or harm and you guys effectively killed her for it.
If you go up to someone and offer to buy their soul or whatever, they might very well take offence.
It's difficult to handle this type of situation, either in character ("I'm just doing what my character would do!" "Well, I'm just what doing what my character would do - killing you because I'm a Paladin and you're obviously evil.") or out of character ("We've decided to cut you out of our gaming lives, please leave.")
They probably didn't handle it the ideal way - whatever that was - from the start, but there's no need to insult the entire group over it. It sounds like they tried to work around the problem and eventually lost patience. That's what most people would do.