Paizo Top Nav Branding
  • Hello, Guest! |
  • Sign In |
  • My Account |
  • Shopping Cart |
  • Help/FAQ
About Paizo Messageboards News Paizo Blog Help/FAQ

Kvantum's page

Pathfinder Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Companion, Roleplaying Game Subscriber. Pathfinder Society Member. 2,500 posts. 6 reviews. No lists. 1 wishlist. 1 Pathfinder Society character.

1 to 5 of 6 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>

Sign in to create or edit a product review.

Our Price: $3.99

Add to Cart

A mostly successful attempt to recapture the old-timey Catalog/Catalogue feel

****( )

This review is based upon a free copy via Flaming Crab Games's very generous "free copy to the first 10 posters" initiative.

Presented as an artifact from a crashed warship originating on an alternate universe magical Earth, this catalog from, oh, 1918 or so, aims to capture the feeling of old turn-of-the-century Sears catalogs, and for old school RPG gamers, the oh-so-fondly remembered 2e Forgotten Realms accessory known as Aurora's Whole Realms Catalogue (which was also trying to capture the feeling of those old Sears catalogs.)

There's 28 pages worth of items, spells, and alchemical items to be had here, all of which are of minor use outside of the home at best. (It's a 39 page PDF in total, but 28 pages of actual items, plus cover, credits, an intro, lists of contents with prices, the OGL and a couple of other decorative pages.)

A few of the alchemical items have their uses for adventurers, but mostly this book's contents are for decoration and an attempt at verisimilitude for a magical civilization. Nothing is egregiously anachronistic, well, except for the "Room Baa," a mechanical sheep atop a floating magical disk that roams the home sucking up small pieces of debris and depositing them into an extradimensional space. That one just triggers my "too silly even for a game" sense.

The groan-inducing silliness of the Room Baa aside, there are also some things that feel a bit oddly balanced, power- or cost-wise, and it feels like some of the alchemical items might work better as magic (or vice-versa), but these are minor quibbles at best.

Overall it is a well done product, and does a good job of recapturing the old-school feeling of old-school gaming, and really old school catalogs. (The "Room Baa", though, that pun is just so terrible it's why my review settled down to just 4 stars. Bad pun. Bad.)

Our Price: $3.95

Add to Cart

It's all fun and games, until you hit on something major.


So what are you getting with this product, an attempt to revive the types of things you'd see in an old April issue of Dragon Magazine? Well, you get a 17 page PDF (cover, 14 pages of actual content, credits, and OGL) that ranges from the pointlessly silly to the actually quite ingenius and *very* useful for a Golarion game.

* Half a dozen comedic traits.

* Comrade (Commoner). Basically they have a kind of inverted Leadership where they get stronger the more allies ("buddies") they have around them. They learn buddies' feats, class abilities, skill unlocks, etc., and they learn to become quite proficient indeed with Aid Another.

* Derelict (Paladin). Meh. Why bother? Evil's just going to triumph in the end. I can't even risk bringing down a celestial spirit by having them serve me or my weapon, but my own personal crushing despair, now *that* I can use for a weapon.

* Gnostic Atheist (Cleric). This is the single biggest and best thing in the book, and what inspired me to write this review. Sounds to me like much of the Rahadoumi world-view all in one archetype. No domains, no domain spell slots, no favored weapon, but they do get a sort of "Antimagic" domain and bonus spell slot per level per day. They become very skilled at counterspelling any divine spell, and they gain SR against any divine spell, or the spell-like abilities of outsiders. Finally, and this is where they might start to make very good BBEG's, or at least big rivals, their intense denial of divinity starts to spread out into an aura around themselves in an ever-widening radius, applying their anti-divine SR to everyone else, forcing any divine caster trying to cast a spell to overcome their SR just to function at all.

Yeah, this archetype has Rahadoum written all over it.

* Mad Scientist (Alchemist). Do you want to ditch alchemical mixtures and replace them with all sorts of crazy steampunk-esque gadgets while risking your lab blowing up if you mistranslate a forumla? Here's your class archetype. SCIENCE!

* Prankster (Bard). This is the truly comedic option in the book. The other archetypes might be funny sounding or have a comedic air about them, but this one is all-out comedy. Do you want to Heckle opponents that fail attack rolls or saves, be able to conjure Prismatic Pies out of nowhere, or hit them with the literal Killing Joke? (The mechanics also seem to have picked up a bit from the design process behind RGG's Talented Bard which just released recently, so there's no set progression on Comedic Antics, just level pre-requisites to meet.)

* Comedic Feats. These seem to keep to the trend of "heavily themed, but actually rather useful when you think about it." They also have that RGG/4 Horsemen level of "is this a little overpowered, or just about right?" I like the higher level of power, but I can see why some would say it's a bit too much.
- Dodecahedral Spell is one of my favorites. "Because there just aren't enough uses for d12s." It's a Metamagic feat that increases the damage dice of a spell to d12s, but at a varying cost depending on what the original spell's damage dice are.
- Extra Antics. Grants a Prankster Bard an extra type of Antic.
- I Think I Can. Grants you a cumulative (in)competence bonus to a skill check every time you fail it, as long as you can retry it again. This does come with an increasing cost of nonlethal damage for every attempt, though.
- Just Swing That Anywhere. Basically I Think I Can for melee attacks, but can only be used during a melee full attack, and the bonus goes away the next time you hit the opponent, or your full attack ends.
- Please Stop Helping. Your Aid Another attempts are effective, even when you aren't.
- Round Up. Exactly what it says. You round fractions up rather than down to determine bonuses or DCs that scale with level.
* Comedic Spells. Bull's Grace and Cat's Strength to inflict penalties to stats, Nag to conjure up a figure from the target's past to inflict increasing fear levels, Rubber Chicken to polymorph a given animal companion/eidolon/familiar/phantom to turn it into a rubber chicken for a short period of time (great for sneaking it past guards!), or Vuvvuzela, to conjure a crude trumpet that grants allies a bonus to attack and damage rolls while inflicting the same penalty on opponents.

All in all, there's actually quite a bit here for a $3.99 PDF. At first glance it all seems like silly jokes, but when you think about some of it, at least mechanically, it starts to seem less and less silly, and more like "You know, I can really use that in my next game."

And that Cleric archetype just screams Rahadoum to me louder and clearer than almost anything else I think I've seen. I've never really been able to quite get how that country could survive in Golarion with all of the obvious, powerful divine casters and outsiders around. After seeing this archetype, though, I can finally get a good idea of just how enough of them really could kick out the servants of the gods from an entire country.

Our Price: $9.99

Add to Cart

A very interesting new addition to tabletop combat

****( )

Strategists and Tacticians is a new book by Ryan Costello Jr. and published by 4 Winds Fantasy Gaming, dealing with combat and strategy, including new options for maneuvers. First off, I do want to start this review by noting a big improvement in this book over some of 4WFG's past books - the internal art is (other than a reused piece or two) finally what I expect to get out of a PDF that costs this much. It may all be B&W, but it's *well-done* black and white. The cover is a slight step down from their previous releases like the one on their overall excellent release Luven Lightfinger's Gear & Treasure Shop but it's still a decent looking piece.

Chapter 1 - Strategic Characters (18 pages)
It opens with a good but too brief section on combat strategies for each of the core races. Next comes variant class features for every core class, from Serene Barbarians and Violent Bards to Learned Sorcerers and Intuitive Wizards. Then there is the Apprentice class, a way of essentially achieving the same goals as the old 3.0 0-level character rules, a multiclassed character at first level, neither (for example) fighter nor mage but a little bit of both. The chapter finishes up with an alternate version of the Bard, a Schooled Bard, one that focuses on music's capacity to induce feelings and states of mind in others, in one of five schools of performance distinct from the core varities.

Chapter 2 - Prestige Classes (27 pages)
There are 14 prestige classes presented here, in varying degrees of quality, with a few unfortunate typos here and there
Armor Bonded - a warrior who really gets attached to his armor.
Blood Caster - an arcane caster who can use her own blood to power her spells
Butcher - an expert in severing limbs
Crowd Displeaser - a Bard who thrives on the angry roar of a disapproving audience
Daredevil - movie-style martial artists and Parkour enthusiasts
Expert Fighter - more fighter than a Fighter (?)
Holy Striker - a nice Fighter/Cleric hybrid that actually has flavorful class features at each level
Ioun Angel - an arcane spellcaster with a thing for Ioun Stones
Jinx - curse-oriented warrior/arcane caster hybrid
Land Shark - not bulette-related, but a druid with a strong facility for nature's eating machines... just walking around on land
Monster Within - Dr. Jekyll as an arcane spellcaster, basically.
Pikeman - a spear specialist with a touch of the Final Fantasy Dragoon
Righteous Rager - a Barbarian/Cleric hybrid
Roughhouse - a bar fighter and improvised weapons specialist

Chapter 3 - Options (24 pages)
New feats and spells. Unfortunately, for every good, balanced, and useful feat here, there are two or three ones that are either far too powerful or that no one would ever take. The new spells introduced here are as a whole pretty good in terms of flavor, balance, and usefulness, but GMs may not exactly want to allow their players complete free reign over them. ("I cast Autocannibalism on the king.")

Chapter 4 - Tactical Maneuvers (6 pages)
Here is the real meat of the whole book, the new combat options that some of us might have thought were missing from d20 combat all along. Choking Strike, Sever, Strangle, Throat Threats (holding your blade against a target's neck), and then Off-Hand Tactics, in other words, fighting dirty. The chapter then details the mechanical effects of losing body parts.

Chapter 5 - Flynn Dielle
More of an appendix than a true chapter, this is the statistical details of the book's narrator, including tips on how to incorporate him into a GM's campaign

Appendix - Prosthetics (7 pages)
This section is reprinted from 4 Winds' earlier release Luven Lightinger's, though I don't begrudge them the reprint here at all, as limb loss and limb replacements do tend to... err... go hand in hand.

All in all, this is an interesting book with many good ideas for combat, even with its problems. A good buy.

Add Print/PDF Bundle $18.95

Add PDF $9.99

An excellent book with a few debatable art choices


Dark_Mistress's review goes into much more detail than mine will, but she said one thing that I agree with whole-heartedly - I really regret not buying the print release of this wonderful book, probably for the first time in years of buying almost exclusively PDFs.

Not being familiar with Everything and a 10' Pole, there's really only one book for me to compare this excellent new release to, an almost-twenty year old 2e release by the name of Aurora's Whole Realms Catalogue. Any older gamer will immediately perk up at mention of that classic, and they absolutely should. This is a excellent book, and any GM who's wanting a more detailed approach to their PCs' gear beyond "We go back into town and buy rations" needs to check this one out. Wonderful detail, even extravagant by some measures, but so familiar when one compares it to the classic Aurora's, and a welcome return to Pathfinder-era gaming.

The only real issue I have with the book is some of the art choices, particularly in chapter 1. The weapons and armor art looks more to me like the rough sketch of an idea that should be sent out to the artist as something to work from and improve, not finished, publishable work, to be honest. And I know the book has a lot of 2e nostalgia going for it, but Larry Elmore's style never felt "3e" to me at all, so to me it feels even more out of place for NPC portraits in a Pathfinder release.

The (relatively minor) art issues aside, this is a great book. Don't hesitate to pick it up if you want a more detailed, realistic approach to PC gear, or even just as a nicely detailed gear shop and inn/tavern for your PCs to make their home away from home.

EDIT: If you haven't noticed from the commentary on this product recently, there's now a 2nd edition of the PDF featuring new and improved art for the armor and weapons. You can ignore what I said above in my initial review about any art issues. They've all been fixed.

This is now exactly what I hoped it would be, the best 3rd party equipment guide for Pathfinder, period.

Our Price: $4.25

Add to Cart

Don't let initial impressions fool you...


At first glance when I read through this PDF, I was underwhelmed. It seemed like a mediocre little book of modified core classes, just little meaningless tweaks to abilities here and there, swap this for that, blend these two classes together, etc.

Then I sat down and really worked with the material here. The eleven new classes, (or about 22 cents a class) are all non-magical, with the partial exception of some of the Scholar's abilities, and those are only if they are chosen, so this book makes for a great counter to those who feel the Advanced Player's Guide will go overboard with caster classes.

I can't give it the in-depth review it really needs here, because the genius in the classes only comes out with time spent working with them, statting out characters, seeing how they compare to core classes, and recognizing just how the changes all counter-balance one another and the new options they bring to the gaming table.

And did I mention it's only 2.39, people? Half the price of a latte, in other words. It's certainly worth 239 of your gaming pennies.

1 to 5 of 6 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>

©2002-2017 Paizo Inc.® | Privacy Policy | Contact Us
Need help? Email or call 425-250-0800 during our business hours, Monday through Friday, 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM Pacific time.

Paizo Inc., Paizo, the Paizo golem logo, Pathfinder, the Pathfinder logo, Pathfinder Society, Starfinder, the Starfinder logo, GameMastery, and Planet Stories are registered trademarks of Paizo Inc. The Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure Path, Pathfinder Adventure Card Game, Pathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Battles, Pathfinder Legends, Pathfinder Online, Starfinder Adventure Path, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Inc. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Inc. under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.