Elan

Kaelaru's page

Organized Play Member. 2 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists.


RSS


Xaaon of Korvosa wrote:
DeciusBrutus wrote:

You aren't voting for 'this item should advance/that item should not advance'.

You are voting for 'this item should be judged before that item.'

The final result isn't a score, just a ranking.

Therein lies the flaw....if item x is horrible but slightly better than y...and get seen 150 times more than item z...which is amazing....will item x make it to top 64...while item z never gets seen by the actual judges....?

So what happens with rock-paper-scissors?

I really wish there was an option for "both are great" and another for "both are terrible." Every person should have their own lists, so the same combination could appear to 100 people. If I am a terrible judge of items, does someone else get to also vote on whether "paper" really does beat to "scissors"?


Anthony Adam wrote:

A very detailed run through of the template is also here and is still valid for this year's competition.

I hope it helps.

Just read over the Round-1 Template post - very very helpful!

Glad I read it before I submitted. Now for some more edits....

Thank you for the post!